3 ms·
What’s missed in these discussions is these regulations had a point to them. It’s obvious Uber driving around without passengers increases congestion. Really l
by Retric 5y ago
What’s missed in these discussions is these regulations had a point to them. It’s obvious Uber driving around without passengers increases congestion. Really look at AirBnb, Bird, etc and they all offload externalities from the company and it’s customers to everyone around them.
When the basic building model is to break the law, chances are the law had a point and people are going to want a return to normal eventually. The only way they survive long term is if the general population feels it’s the new normal is a useful tradeoff. In the short term they can massively subsidize users, but long term the same basic economic reality sets in so they need some actual innovation.
- horsawlarway 5y ago> What’s missed in these discussions is these regulations had a point to them. This varies a lot by area - For example, I'd say the NY medallion regulations had a point to them, and that point was to systematically abuse cab drivers for the profit of the local government and banks. Then for example - in my area (Atlanta) medallion supply was capped at 1600 - the result meant cabs basically didn't exist outside of the airport. Need a ride home from a party? Called a cab company? They won't show up. At all. They will dispatch cab after cab after cab that simply will never EVER show up. Cabs would show up to exactly two places - Nice hotels that paid them under the table to make sure they kept coming, and the airport. Conveniently those two places tended to make circular trips. So are there negative externalities to ride-sharing? Sure. Is it currently better than the previous cab monopolies? I'd argue yes. Do Uber and Lyft really represent a sustainable model? I don't think so.
- bsder 5y ago> This varies a lot by area - For example, I'd say the NY medallion regulations had a point to them, and that point was to systematically abuse cab drivers for the profit of the local government and banks. NY cab medallion regulations were rooted in the aftermath of the Great Depression where it was a race to the bottom and little things like "car maintenance" were viewed as a burden. Funnily enough, Uber and Lyft are in this race to the bottom right now. Hopefully we can stop it before they start kidnapping people. History doesn't repeat, but it sure rhymes
- horsawlarway 5y agoSure - Regulations need to be a balancing act, though. Without any - Folks will cut every corner they can to save money, which leads to lots of negative externalities. With too many - there's no reason to offer a compelling product, because the regulations define such a static status quo. Both of those are bad. You need a healthy mix.
- wolverine876 5y agoNY medallion regulations auction off street space to the highest bidder, rather than allowing a tragedy of the commons: giving that limited public resource away to businesses who profit on it and consume it to the point where others are restricted from using it.
- dominotw 5y ago> people are going to want a return to normal eventually. Except now airbnb is accepted by city regulations and cities give out permits and make occupancy dollars. Same with uber.
- Retric 5y agoRegulators are ultimately subordinate to the laws and thus the voters. That process is just really slow.
- Day1 5y ago
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>What’s missed in these discussions is these regulations had a point to them And what point would that be? Satisfying some legislator's desire to show Karen they're "doing something"? Raising the barrier to entry for new entrants? Protecting people? Everyone who has a poorly thought out regulatory knee-jerk reaction likes to imagine that it's all the 3rd option but there's a heck of a lot of the first and second sailing under the flag of the third and a heck of a lot of people who would rather just use some heuristic like "more laws, more paperwork, more license fees, more better" than actually think critically about all three options. A critical mass of the general public assuming that every regulation's primary purpose was to protect people when created and that said purpose has stood the test of time is how you get crap like the taxi medallion system in the first place.
- Retric 5y agoInitially the point was to reduce the number of Taxi on NYC streets, especially unsafe Taxi. The existing regulations did require a defensive driving course for Taxi drivers as well as a fairly clean driving record etc. But at it’s core was New Yorkers being fed up by how crowded the streets had gotten.