3 ms·
As I read the argument, it doesn’t point to continuing racial animus in the present as being the explanation for continuing disparities. I.e. racial wealth ineq
by rayiner 5y ago
As I read the argument, it doesn’t point to continuing racial animus in the present as being the explanation for continuing disparities. I.e. racial wealth inequality isn’t the result of realtors being racist against Black people in 2022. It is focused on the present effects of past prejudice that segregated Black families into less desirable neighborhoods with low property values. The characteristics of these neighborhoods is what perpetuates income and wealth disparities. Lower property values alone can’t be the explanation, because many waves of immigrants have come here with no wealth at all but have economically converged nonetheless. Hispanics continue to do so. It’s not just that these neighborhoods have lower property values, but there are things about those neighborhoods that keeps people poor.
My point is that communities that trap people in generational poverty aren’t unique to inner city Black neighborhoods. There are many white people who aren’t just poor, but who are in communities with generational poverty, and where that poverty lines up with ethnic groups.
My further point is that different structurally impoverished communities may have similar mechanics. Appalachian Americans weren’t redlined into where they live, but those communities seem to be just as hostile to upward mobility as inner city Baltimore.
- tedunangst 5y agoAnd yet property values go up very substantially when you "unblack" your house by having a white person answer the door. https://amp.usatoday.com/amp/8316884002 https://amp.usatoday.com/amp/8316884002 https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/19/homes/black-homeowner-home-appraisal-feseries/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/19/homes/black-homeowner-home-ap... https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2021/12/09/business/black-homeowners-appraisal-discrimination-lawsuit/index.html https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2021/12/09/business/black-homeowners...
- tptacek 5y agoIt has examples of active, specific, targeted anti-Black racial animus in zoning laws going into (iirc) the 1980s.
- rayiner 5y agoThat was 50 years ago. A Black millennial may have grown up in a $200,000 house instead of a $300,000 house because their parents were redlined into a lower income neighborhood. But that Black millennial will have much lower income mobility as an adult than not only whites, but Hispanics and Asians who also grew up in $200,000 houses. The first order effect of redlining into the 1980s is reduced housing wealth. But that doesn’t explain why Black-white gaps haven’t changed since the 1980s while multiple waves of poor immigrants have come to the US since then and dramatically closed the gap with whites. What explains those gaps? One possibility is persistent anti-Black animus. That doesn’t explain why Nigerian immigrants enjoy similar income mobility to whites with comparable education levels. It also doesn’t explain why gaps remain static even as prejudiced attitudes decrease. There must be some explanation, such as higher order effects from housing segregation, to explain the persistent disparities. My point is simply that Black and indigenous people aren’t the only ones who have faced structural disparities that aren’t closing—so do some white ethnic subgroups. The reasons why these groups came to live in these communities in the first place may be unique, but the characteristics of these communities that make them poverty traps likely are not.
- tptacek 5y agoObviously, that was not in fact 50 years ago.
- whimsicalism 5y ago> A Black millennial may have grown up in a $200,000 house instead of a $300,000 house As an example: In Boston, the average net household wealth of a white family is $200,000. The average net household wealth of a balck family is $5 (no typo). Your examples are just wildly off-base if you are trying to paint them as a "typical" example.