2 ms·
When I first read up on economics, I had similar doubts about the gold standards. It doesn't help that most modern day advocators of a gold standard have but a
by eru 5y ago
When I first read up on economics, I had similar doubts about the gold standards.
It doesn't help that most modern day advocators of a gold standard have but a dim understanding of history and economics.
So, first: if the population in one country goes up, they can import more gold from elsewhere. It's a commodity after all.
Similar for one country digging up a lot of gold.
(The global economy wasn't quite as integrated back when Spain had their windfall from the new world. But even then, the long term impact on the price level in Spain compared to the rest of the world was rather modest compared to levels of inflation we see today.
Spain just imported more goods and services from the rest of Europe for a while than they exported; naturally losing gold in the process.)
So the real concern is about global population vs global gold stocks.
Similarly for economic growth: productivity increases under a gold standard lead to decrease in nominal prices. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26386115 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26386115 for how this works (and worked in history).
The more important problem isn't so much population changes or economic growth; it's changes in demand for money balances!
Depending on the state of the economy, people want to hold on to different amounts of money vs other assets. That's true not only in nominal terms, but also in inflation adjusted real terms.
Those swings can be wild.
A central bank can print money (or take money out of circulation) to adapt to those swings in the desire for money balances. Look at the various measures of amount of money, like M1 or M2, change over time. Eg M2 for the US at https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=MSEz https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=MSEz
It is entirely fair and accurate to say that this would a disaster for an economy trying to run on gold coins.
Luckily, we have and had the technology to make the gold standard work: fractional reserve banking and privately issued bank notes. See https://www.alt-m.org/2015/07/29/there-was-no-place-like-canada/ https://www.alt-m.org/2015/07/29/there-was-no-place-like-can... for how that worked fabulously in Canada, and why it worked so much worse in the US.
- rr808 5y agoThe worlds population has quadrupled in 100 years, you can't say that "they can import from elsewhere" or each country can just dig it up. What happens if you live in a country where you can't just dig it up and people are poor.
- eru 5y agoSorry, I wrote 'So the real concern is about global population vs global gold stocks.', but I never addressed that. So for your first question: there was lots of global population increase during the time when many countries where on a gold standard. We can have a look at how they dealt with it. Basically, in the long run you can dig gold out of the ground. If gold prices get too high, more mines will become profitable, so people mine more. If gold prices drop, fewer gold will be mined. Empirically in the long run the price of gold compared to eg the price of labour had been really rather stable in the past. It helps that the global population and the global stock of gold typically change much slower than individual countries'. > What happens if you live in a country where you can't just dig it up and people are poor. Almost by definition a poor country has less economic activity. So they would need less gold. Instead of me writing a lot of hypotheticals here, have a look at how 'dollarisation' works in the real world. That's when countries abandon their own currency (either officially or de facto) and run their economy on eg the USD or the Euro or so. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_substitution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_substitution That happens mostly with poor countries, and just like they can't dig up gold in our example, they can't print new USD either. They have to get their hands on them via exporting more than they are importing. (Or in the short run they can also take out loans; but those need to be serviced eventually.)
- throw0101a 5y ago> So, first: if the population in one country goes up, they can import more gold from elsewhere. It's a commodity after all. Unless governments ban the exporting of gold, which has historical precedent. It is possible to run out of gold on which to run an economy. We know this because it has happened: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Bullion_Famine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Bullion_Famine For a good history of the topic see The Power of Gold: The History of an Obsession by Bernstein: * https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/249245.The_Power_of_Gold https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/249245.The_Power_of_Gold We've used/tried gold and the world has moved on for good reason. There's no reason to regress (unless you want to relearn the painful lessons of the past). > Luckily, we have and had the technology to make the gold standard work: fractional reserve banking and privately issued bank notes. It's interesting that you bring up fractional reserve banking and Canada in the same paragraph, as Canada hasn't had reserve requirements for about thirty years now: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reserve_requirement#Canada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reserve_requirement#Canada
- eru 5y ago> It's interesting that you bring up fractional reserve banking and Canada in the same paragraph, as Canada hasn't had reserve requirements for about thirty years now: Yes, exactly! In the heyday of Canada's gold standard and privately issued notes, they didn't have a reserve requirement either. Minimum reserve requirements are bad for the financial system! (Sorry, not enough time to respond to the rest. Have a look at George Sergin's work, if you are interested. The reasons that countries moved off the gold standard were mostly bad, actually. However, I don't think it's realistic these days to move back onto a gold standard.)
- pyuser583 5y agoHow does the greater number of nations (and therefore currencies) affect things? For example, when Sudan splits in half, there are now two currencies that need gold reserves.
- eru 5y agoPresumably they'd need only roughly half the amount each?