8 ms·
Was China Betting on Russian Defeat All Along?
- somewhereoutth 5y agoIts' I remain reassured, and indeed confident, in the idea of western civilization.
- myko 5y agoIt's interesting that Putin asked Xi for permission before invading. Putin seems set on trying to make Russia into a world power but with this move he seems to have completely neutered that possibility in the near term, and cemented Russia's reliance on China as a "big brother" on the world stage. Just incredible miscalculations on his part.
- _8j50 5y agoMaybe he cares less about perception than practical effect? Militarily, their nukes will always be a thing. Economically, neither putin nor anyone else serious was under the assumption that Russia's economy was great. Is him asking Xi all that different than Bush asking Tony Blair before Iraq? At the UN security council, Russia and China are always vetoeing measures and they like to back each other up. It's not that Putin asked for permission but that he did not want complete isolation. On China's part, their espionage operations in the west are very telling in that it reveals their strategy a bit. They want dirt on everyone and they want to understand the west to achieve long term victory. Whether russia wins or loses, China wins because they get to observe who does what. When it comes time to invade taiwan or south china sea, they will be well prepared and they will know which pressure points to press in the west. The greatest geopolitical mistake the west made was to take on both Russia and China at the same time. At any time one of them have to be your friend if you want to overpower the other. Putin or not Russia will not be friendly to the west. Their nukes and largest land mass of any country bordering america, europe and china means the west cannot afford to fight China on any front anytime soon.
- cinntaile 5y ago> Is him asking Xi all that different than Bush asking Tony Blair before Iraq? Big guy asking small guy suggests a very different power game compared to small guy asking big guy?
- _8j50 5y agoTo the public it seems that way but in reality US,Russia and China having all those nukes and huge land mass theit leaders always see themselves as the big guy. Have you seen Putin at G11? He has to be at the center when they take pictures because of his ego. Hard to believe him considering himself lesser than Xi.
- myko 5y ago> Is him asking Xi all that different than Bush asking Tony Blair before Iraq? I would argue yes. Bush was looking for a "coalition of the willing" to go along with his lies about why it was necessary to invade. AFAICT Putin wasn't trying to get China to join in the war on Ukraine. He moved the war to accommodate China. Bush would have invaded either way, it seems, given allies like France called him out and refused. > At the UN security council, Russia and China are always vetoeing measures and they like to back each other up. The link mentions China's reticence to back Russia up on the world stage here, specifically by abstaining from relevant votes at the UN instead of voting with Russia. Putin misjudged this as well. > It's not that Putin asked for permission but that he did not want complete isolation. This is reasonable, but it seems like Xi set Putin's timeline for invasion here to after the olympics, so there was some level of getting permission / obsequiousness to China. It seems like Putin expected more help and is not getting it. > Whether russia wins or loses, China wins Yes, I agree here. Russia has been completely marginalized by Putin's decisions. China comes out looking very reasonable. > The greatest geopolitical mistake the west made was to take on both Russia and China at the same time. I might be naive but I don't see that happening at the moment? > the west cannot afford to fight China on any front anytime soon. I don't really think this was on the table, barring an invasion of Taiwan. In any case most folks place Russia's military above China's in capability, and Russia's military seems extremely ill-prepared to wage modern combat.
- zamalek 5y agoIt's time for the west to offer Russia a very attractive way out; becoming part of NATO and favorable trade agreements, for example.
- downvotetruth 5y agoFor all those who have and will suffer from this conflict, at least know the eight-point Russian demands, specifically that NATO rule out further expansion; given those demands NATO should be expecting either the unacceptable Russian demands to be withdrawn or preparing many ballistic missile interceptors, i.e. SM-3.
- nayaketo 5y agoRussia demands neutrality to be enshrined in Ukrainian constitution which will disallow Ukraine from joining EU as well. Basically they want Ukraine to remain like Belarus: poor and subservient.
- ejanus 5y agoSo, all non-EU states are poor? And Greeces and Italy are a classic examples of nations making it big under EU cover. GUY, come on.
- dane-pgp 5y ago> So, all non-EU states are poor? No, but the ones oppressed by Russia tend to be. > And Greeces and Italy are a classic examples of nations making it big under EU cover. GDP (US$ PPP) per capita (IMF 2021 estimate): Italy 43,376 Greece 30,495 Belarus 20,578 Moldova 13,879 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28PPP%29_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28PP...
- ejanus 5y agoStack them where they were before entering EU and where they are now.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dirtyid 5y agoMore PRC will invade Siberia wank. In order of benefit for PRC: no invasion > russian victory > nuclear war in europe > russian defeat. There's no upside to RU defeat.
- netheril96 5y agoWhat I believe is that * China did not anticipate that Russia would launch a full invasion on Ukraine. If it had, it would have pulled Chinese citizens in Ukraine much earlier. * This quote "and two major Chinese banks, the Bank of China and the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China, have even refused to help Russia process export transactions." does not prove anything. China has a Kunlun Bank that specializes in dealing with US sanctioned entities so that other banks can work with the US normally.
- charles_f 5y ago> If it had, it would have pulled Chinese citizens in Ukraine much earlier. Sounds dubious that they would risk a partnership leak like that for a few people
- itake 5y agoUS closed their embassy on Feb 14 [0] and China didn't start pulling out their citizens until the 28th [1]. I don't think anyone would of suspected a partnership leak if the USA already announced their evacuation. > China evacuated the first batch of its citizens from Ukraine on February 28, including over 400 Chinese students from Odessa and 200 from Kiev, four days after militaries from Russia and Ukraine engaged in battle. [0] - https://www.cnn.com/2022/02/14/politics/us-embassy-kyiv-closure/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2022/02/14/politics/us-embassy-kyiv-clos... [1] - https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202203/1254447.shtml https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202203/1254447.shtml
- proofrock 5y agoIt’s. Its’. Even Its’s. I know that a native speaker doesn’t even see these, but for a second-language speaker it’s a nuisance, it really breaks the flow of reading.
- kkfx 5y agoIMVHO the article is just a bit of fantasy bolted with very superficial geopolitical analysis: China is clearly the winner so far, sanctions against Russia for China means far more Russian natural resources to them, far bigger access to weapons tech, far more negotiation power. Russia is not Soviet Union, it's far less powerful and so need a partner. EU was their first and best bet, they try many time to offer the olive branch to EU but USA/UK/NATO always manage to stop accepting it, only EU biggest (France, Germany and Italy) have part of gov/business interest since they are not so blind, we are natural partner and needing each others make the partnership on par, while with the USA the partnership is definitively not on par. Anyway, since the west door remain close the other option was China, a historical enemy, but a stable partner that need Russia as much Russia need China. That's is. Since then China was the winner. Russian Far East/Siberia is already "substantially Chinese" without any special geopolitical maneuvering: Russia have not invested enough there, China have done, most local infrastructure are made by China to link China to Far east/Siberia, most locals buy and sell to China, go on holiday in China etc, China do not need more than that: they have full access to natural resources and thanks to the desperation of USA/UK that push the EU away from Russia to being able to still control EU they have secured the partnership for decades to come. Consider a thing: now Russia probably offer China nuke tech, something they have NEVER ever do before, with China industry and Russian tech and natural resources behind, China can overpower USA in few years. They do not need more than that. What I do not much understand is how desperate USA/UK can be to choose a so suicidal course.
- mike_k 5y agoDo you really think there is no difference for US/EU with what kind of regime to cooperate _now_? Purely economical short term gains proved to be too risky even for Germany. Moral and cultural aspects are still important enough. Regarding nuke and other hi tech: it might turn out Russia is not as good at it as many anticipated.
- kkfx 5y agoEU have the highest tech in the world despite it's big push toward finance, but lack natural resources and space, Russia do have an industrial system ready enough to benefit from EU tech and natural resources + space so yes, not only in purely economical terms but in practical terms such partnership is absolutely natural and with mutual benefit: Germany know that well, but since WWII they lost their sovereignty to the USA so they have had no choice, that's what happen. No special "risk". Regarding tech while Russia is not Soviet Union it's still have much of military research and for the little we know is already more effective than the USA since it's development is state-led, not private companies led like most of things in USA. So even if far behind for various aspects is far forward than China in tech terms and China have one of the most developed industrial system to mass produce almost anything. In moral and cultural aspect we EU Citizens have issues comprehending USA values and duplicity while have had even LESS issues with the Soviet. Morality is always a characteristic of the people to avoid social drifts, not much a government thing but in social terms we are more near Russian population than USA or UK ones, we are far more social than competing, just as an example. Essentially "Russian threat" is no threat for us EU citizens, it's at maximum a threat for the eastern Europe area where they switch from a Russian-led dictatorship to others planted by USA/UK after the cold war and even today many are nostalgic of the Soviet because they are less oppressive that current formal, not substantial, Democracies, just as a fresh example https://www.lrt.lt/en/news-in-english/19/1619050/post-socialist-transition-was-good-for-some-people-and-really-bad-for-many-others-interview-with-kristen-ghodsee https://www.lrt.lt/en/news-in-english/19/1619050/post-social... if you came from US/UK you probably simply never heard of but most nazi-alike and religious extremist that infest the east Europe are made by US/UK to counter the Soviet, do to so they start at the WWII time recycling original nazi and fascist, often letting them do their revenge business against their citizens, for instance while not formally Aldo Moro killing was a USA-made killing to stop Democrazia Cristiana party to reach an agreement with Partito Comunista Italiano, just to cite one. Criminal militia like Gladio where founded by USA and UK government, the same government that have founded nazi and fascist even after the start of WWII. Historical "Operation Unthinkable" and "Operation Dropshot" are other examples of criminal intent against us for the sake of UK and USA, the Soviet or the Russian never do something like that. Consider that USA and UK government are FAR different from their own people and they are not much more Democratic than China or Russian dictatorship, just smarter, they appear less deadly on their own Citizens than them, they master propaganda very well, but at heart they are the same. For them Citizens are not Citizens but sheep to be kept in like "for their own sake" and of course for the shepherd interests. UE government in that sense are far more moderate and more often than not just puppet regimes. The level of detachments between People and who really command is abysmal these days.