5 ms·
You seem to be shadowboxing an opponent that doesn't exist. People who discuss categories such as "white" are not making the claim that "race is all that matte
by whimsicalism 5y ago
You seem to be shadowboxing an opponent that doesn't exist.
People who discuss categories such as "white" are not making the claim that "race is all that matters for determining one's circumstance, class does not matter at all." This claim is a strawman that very few people actually believe.
But without race, you can't explain stuff like realtors discriminating against black homeowners in 50% of interactions [0]. Even the poor from Appalachia could pose as home buyers and get the "white" service experience from the realtor.
[0]: https://projects.newsday.com/long-island/real-estate-agents-investigation/ https://projects.newsday.com/long-island/real-estate-agents-...
- rayiner 5y agoOf course people recognize that white people come from different classes—that’s not what I’m talking about. What people don’t recognize is that those class differences among white people also map onto ethnicity. “White people” aren’t a single ethnic group any more than “brown people” (south Asians) or “black people” (Africans) are a single ethnic group. And when you look at the different subgroups of “white people” the story becomes much more nuanced. As to your hypothetical—that may be true but is also mostly irrelevant. It’s pretty uncontroversial among people who study these disparities that economic and other differences between subgroups is caused by structural issues, not prejudice. That’s why, for example, incomes for second-generation Nigerian Americans exceeds those of third+ generation whites even when adjusted for age and education: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/23780231211001971 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/23780231211001.... And as to your larger point, that’s true in theory but not in practice. In practice, one division dominates the others. In the current political environment, race is given the highest emphasis. Thus as a “person of color” I fall into the “oppressed” camp (despite being from a wealthy family back home) while my wife’s family falls into the “oppressor” camp (despite being poor the entire time since they came here 350 years ago).
- ProfessorLayton 5y ago> It’s pretty uncontroversial among people who study these disparities that economic and other differences between subgroups is caused by structural issues, not prejudice And what do you suppose much of those structural issues are rooted in here in the U.S.? Housing makes a very substantial portion of family wealth, which is the biggest indicator of educational attainment.
- jollybean 5y agoMigrants of all races come to America with zero generational wealth and attain middle class status very quickly. I suggest mindset/culture/behaviour is actually more predictive than 'how much inheritance' people get form their parents home ownership.
- ProfessorLayton 5y agoPeople that uproot their entire lives and move to a new country is a very high filter, so it's no surprise that those same people and their children tend to be more successful overall. Things aren't as rosy when including non-immigrants. Your mindset/culture/behavior suggestion isn't backed up by a study, however, family wealth is https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5993612/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5993612/ "family wealth may have become even more important to support direct investments in educational opportunity—in the form of good neighborhoods, secondary schools, and colleges" One need not inherit anything from their parents to reap the benefits of family wealth.
- rayiner 5y ago> Housing makes a very substantial portion of family wealth, which is the biggest indicator of educational attainment. That explains a little—Black people whose parents were redlined into neighborhoods with low property values will inherit a lot less on average than white people. But that only explains so much—few immigrants will ever inherit property in America yet nearly every immigrant group has similar or higher income mobility compared to white Americans: https://academic.oup.com/qje/article/135/2/711/5687353 https://academic.oup.com/qje/article/135/2/711/5687353. Hispanic immigrants, who typically come here at the bottom of the totem pole, reach near parity with whites within three generations. Vietnamese came here as refugees and attained parity with whites within a generation. The only groups which aren’t converging with whites is Black people and Indians (native Americans). But to circle back to my point, we’re glossing over something important—the “median white income” is illusory! Italian Americans lapped Appalachian Americans despite coming here later and suffering much more discrimination. If you want to understand what causes structural economic disparities you’re doing yourself a disservice by white American communities that exhibit similar structural and generation economic disparities. Why are Appalachians poor? Why are coastal Oregonians poor?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 5y agoI don't understand the argument here. You yourself just cited Chapter 3 of Color of Law, which makes a persuasive case that the United States remains under a system of de jure racial segregation, in which a specific animus against Black families undergirds essentially all our zoning laws.
- rayiner 5y agoAs I read the argument, it doesn’t point to continuing racial animus in the present as being the explanation for continuing disparities. I.e. racial wealth inequality isn’t the result of realtors being racist against Black people in 2022. It is focused on the present effects of past prejudice that segregated Black families into less desirable neighborhoods with low property values. The characteristics of these neighborhoods is what perpetuates income and wealth disparities. Lower property values alone can’t be the explanation, because many waves of immigrants have come here with no wealth at all but have economically converged nonetheless. Hispanics continue to do so. It’s not just that these neighborhoods have lower property values, but there are things about those neighborhoods that keeps people poor. My point is that communities that trap people in generational poverty aren’t unique to inner city Black neighborhoods. There are many white people who aren’t just poor, but who are in communities with generational poverty, and where that poverty lines up with ethnic groups. My further point is that different structurally impoverished communities may have similar mechanics. Appalachian Americans weren’t redlined into where they live, but those communities seem to be just as hostile to upward mobility as inner city Baltimore.
- tedunangst 5y agoAnd yet property values go up very substantially when you "unblack" your house by having a white person answer the door. https://amp.usatoday.com/amp/8316884002 https://amp.usatoday.com/amp/8316884002 https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/19/homes/black-homeowner-home-appraisal-feseries/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/19/homes/black-homeowner-home-ap... https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2021/12/09/business/black-homeowners-appraisal-discrimination-lawsuit/index.html https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2021/12/09/business/black-homeowners...
- 5y ago