2 ms·

Sure. Does every sentence in a discussion of X really require a disclaimer that the thing mentioned is not necessarily unique to X and can also be the case for

by detaro 5y ago

Sure. Does every sentence in a discussion of X really require a disclaimer that the thing mentioned is not necessarily unique to X and can also be the case for not-X?

alephnan 5y ago
Sure. Does saying "China has a border." add value then? It's not necessarily unique to China and can also be the case for not-China?
- detaro 5y ago
  Depends if it's relevant to the topic at hand or not.
  - alephnan 5y ago
    So you concede that it's about relevancy and not logical structure then.
    - detaro 5y ago
      I've never claimed otherwise, since you didn't claim that it wasn't relevant to Chinese markets, but only attacked an imagined claim about it not being relevant to other markets.