3 ms·
How is what you are describing different than what Uber is doing? Personally, under the circumstances when I take Uber, I don’t care about how much they charge
by scarface74 5y ago
How is what you are describing different than what Uber is doing?
Personally, under the circumstances when I take Uber, I don’t care about how much they charge and I tip the maximum amount allowed by our guidelines - 20%.
90% of the time when I take Uber, it’s for business travel and I’m getting reimbursed (consulting). The other 10% of the time I’m on vacation where I expect to spend stupidly or going into town from the burbs for “date night” and we don’t want to worry about parking or DUIs.
I live in a very car dependent metro area so I don’t have a clear picture of when most people use Uber for day to day use.
Well, I guess there was the couple of years we were spending $350/month on Uber for our son to get back and forth to work and go friends because it was cheaper than car+insurance.
- Ekaros 5y agoUber dictates the price and hides the ride details. It is not the driver seeing the mass they need to transport and from where to where. Two clear details that should affect pricing. In system I am describing the driver could make offer after the rider has provided pick-up location, the drop location and how much mass or passengers they want to move. They could include in offer terms like cancelation fees, per kilometer cost, per time cost. Or just lump sum offer. And potential penalty fees if the rider doesn't provide all information, or miss represents something. Also could be included any fees such as cleanup. I see no reason why Uber should have anything to say about how the drivers price their service. And it is up to rider to either accept these terms, wait for better terms or use alternative transport such as walking.
- scarface74 5y agoThere are a few issues with that. 1. What if I want to be picked up from or go to a “bad neighborhood” - ie a “neighborhood with too many Black people that don’t tip well”? Uber drivers would cancel just like taxi drivers use to refuse to service the area. 2. That’s way too complicated compared to “choose my pick up spot and choose my destination “. Two other comments. Before the woke police downvote me or flag me for being racist because of the first comment, I am Black. If drivers are complaining about the distance/time/cost, Uber has enough people on the road to tell drivers how long a trip will probably take based on the time it will take to get to the pick up spot, traffic patterns, and the time it will take to get to the destination. But telling them those two spots will automatically make it more expensive for minorities to get an Uber. The driver shouldn’t care where they are going, just how long will it take them to make the trip. The algorithm will price the rides based on supply and demand. I do feel bad when a driver has to come way up north to pick me up and take me to the airport on the other side of town. I schedule my rides in advance so they know going in before they accept. Sources: https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2015/07/23/as-a-black-man-its-hard-to-catch-a-cab-research-shows-even-white-people-know-that/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2015/07/23/... https://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/ny-metro-cabbies-fines-refusing-fares-20180705-story.html https://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/ny-metro-cabbies-fines-...
- Ekaros 5y ago1. Then you pay more. Someone will eventually set a price at level they are willing to provide this service. Nothing wrong with free markets operating as they are intended. 2. Contracts are inherently complicated. In the end you probably only need to check the total price or ask for such offer. Drivers absolutely care where they are going. And have all the rights to set price accordingly risk on their lives and livelihoods they perceive. After all there should be risk premium for going to areas where they might have to risk their vehicles or lives.
- scarface74 5y agoReally? Let Black people pay more because of racism? I just cited two articles where Black business men in the middle of the city have a hard time catching a cab because of their color. Isn’t that the same thing people said about segregation and Jim Crow laws? Before you think that is ancient history. My still living parents grew up in the Jim Crow south. I travel for business across the US as a consultant. I work for a company worth $1.6 trillion dollars last time I checked. My expense reimbursements can easily go to over two grand for a week trip. I’m glad I know I can just click a button to be guaranteed a ride in 2021, instead of the dealing with taxis the first time I went to NYC in 2012 for a vacation. And to your second point. This is why engineers make horrible product designers.
- Ekaros 5y agoSo you are saying that someone should not be able to set higher price to let's say move goods to eastern Ukraine? But would be mandate to go there at same price level as let's say Spain? Or they should make delivery of goods to remote place in Alaska for same price as between two highly interconnected hubs? Taking that distance between is the same...
- scarface74 5y agoNo, I specifically said that the drivers should be able to choose a ride based solely on cost/benefits - how much in time and money will the ride cost - distance to the pick up spot, distance to the destination, and traffic congestion. You can determine all of that in aggregate based on gps. If you want to add another variable - rider ratings - that’s fine. Judge people based on their individual behavior - shocking I know. And despite all of the fear. The chance of a random Uber driver being harmed in a “bad neighborhood” are infinitesimal. Most of the reports of people being harmed on Uber rides was on the part of the driver directed at the passenger.