3 ms·
The first 2 papers indicated by you refer indeed to the same thing as the article that started this thread, but they explain the possible method. The principle
by adrian_b 5y ago
The first 2 papers indicated by you refer indeed to the same thing as the article that started this thread, but they explain the possible method.
The principle is very similar with the sources of deep ultraviolet light used for photolithography. The laser pulses are used to produce hot plasma and to accelerate the electrons from plasma, which hit then a target, like in the traditional X-ray tubes. The interaction of the accelerated electrons with the target produces gamma rays. Finally, the gamma rays can be used to transmute the nuclear waste.
There are 2 problems with this approach. As everybody knows, improving the deep UV sources to have an intensity great enough to be usable in the production of integrated circuits took several decades and many billions of dollars.
The gamma ray sources that would be needed for waste treatment are significantly more complex and the output intensity must be much higher, so it is impossible to guess how much time and money would be needed, but certainly much more than for photolithography.
The second much more serious problem is that already mentioned in another post. If these gamma-ray sources would have a global efficiency of 1%, starting from the electrical input power, passing through pump diodes for lasers, then solid-state lasers for pulse generation, then heating plasma, accelerating electrons, radiation from the electron target and finally absorption in the nuclear waste, that would be an amazing achievement.
Actually a global efficiency of less than 1 per ten thousand would be more likely today.
The energy required to transmute all the waste from a nuclear reactor might be of 10% or more of the output energy of the reactor. Multiplied with a factor between 100 and 10000, the result is that a nuclear reactor would not be a net producer of energy, but a huge consumer of energy, making it useless.
A little more realistic would be to not treat all the nuclear waste, but only 1 or a few especially dangerous isotopes, e.g. only the radioactive iodine.
While this would reduce a lot the energy required for transmutation, a lot of additional energy would be needed for the separation of the desired isotopes from the radioactive waste.
Maybe transmuting only the iodine could be done in a distant future with a little less energy than the nuclear reactor produces.
However that would not solve the problem with the storage of the nuclear waste. Consuming a huge amount of energy with the elimination of the iodine would only lessen the danger of what would happen if the storage of the waste would be compromised and the waste would be dispersed into the environment (because the vertebrates extract the iodine from the environment and concentrate it into the thyroid, so radioactive iodine is dangerous even at smaller concentrations than the rest of the waste).