4 ms·
> 20,000 cubic meters isn't a significant amount of space 20,000 m3 of water is not the same as 20,000 m3 material that is seriously toxic to the cellular bond
by mistrial9 5y ago
> 20,000 cubic meters isn't a significant amount of space
20,000 m3 of water is not the same as 20,000 m3 material that is seriously toxic to the cellular bonds that form life in one teaspoon of material.. each teaspoon of material can be further subdivided into .. the air in your lungs, the fresh water that frogs depend on, or the bio-accumulating food chain of vegetable-deer-predator
factual responses welcome and encouraged
- bell-cot 5y agoConsider the vastly larger quantities of naturally-occurring arsenic, lead, mercury, etc. in the world, and how - in spite of our seeming efforts to expose billions of people to them in their most dangerous forms - they aren't exactly wiping out humanity.
- mistrial9 5y ago"Although heavy metals are naturally occurring elements that are found throughout the earth’s crust, most environmental contamination and human exposure result from anthropogenic activities such as mining and smelting operations, industrial production and use, and domestic and agricultural use of metals and metal-containing compounds" why? because previous to life as we know it today, the Earth's geologic evolution included phases that were literally toxic heavy metals-filled oceans, air and land surface. It was only after millennia of "encasement" that basic modern life forms could start to evolve. Modern humans have famously reversed that encasement process, first and foremost with fossil fuel activity. Ever-more powerful sources of energy are readily found in ever-more powerfully toxic compounds occurring within that encasement, with enriched Uranium as a crown-royalty member of that club. Why do few care? because few have experienced real poisoning, or prolonged poisoning through the reproduction cycle that they know of.
- twofornone 5y agoThe amount of "powerfully toxic substances" necessary to power the world off of uranium fission is many orders of magnitude lower than whatever we're producing now off of fossil fuels alone. Few should care because in the grand scheme of things mining, refining, and storing spent nuclear fuel is really not a big deal.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ch4s3 5y agoMost of the material isn’t readily water soluble and a lot of the radiation is alpha particles which aren’t very dangerous. The really dangerous stuff has a half life on the order of minutes/days/months. It’s also hard to breath in the particles unless they’re attached to something like smoke. Uranium miners in the 50s who didn’t smoke had cancer rates no higher than the general population.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lazide 5y agoHuh? The volume of toxic solvents, gasoline byproducts, carcinogenic substances emitted every second by cars trundling around dwarf this. That amount could be baked into glass and stored in sets of giant steel casks and would never meaningfully interact with humans ever again.
- Maursault 5y ago> and would never meaningfully interact with humans ever again. Four years ago, you let your keys sit for a few hours. Where was that? The problem with this half of your statement is that it is entirely unknowable. If you can't remember where your keys were four years ago, what makes you think our species will remember any event occurring within the last 50 years 2000 years from now? 10,000 years from now? 5M years from now?
- lazide 5y agoWhat makes you think it will meaningfully matter? Radiation sources decrease their radioactivity significantly as they decay. The more radioactive, the more rapidly they decay. Some elements have significant energy in their decay chains, but those also tend to stabilize after awhile or be so valuable it’s pretty ridiculous making them ‘waste’ instead of fuel. They also aren’t a large volume of these wastes. The amount of actual plutonium in this waste is small, for instance. You can see this even around Chernobyl, where before the recent war it was fine giving tours. The trinity test site has given tours for decades. I’m not downplaying everything here as being fine - you wouldn’t want to lick it. And, like the area surrounding a lead smelter, maybe don’t do camping trips with the kids or build a house outside Chernobyl for awhile. But if someone builds more houses there in a couple hundred years, it’s VERY unlikely to be a problem. The scale of the problem is minuscule compared to the scale of mercury poisoning and toxic waste from mining even a tiny fraction of the stuff used for equivalent energy production. The amount of toxic airborne mercury released from cement production (baking the cement) to build the buildings for the reactors almost certainly has killed more people than any nuclear accidents. I’m saying the idea that even 100 years from now it will be some kind of dangerous glowing mass is fantasy. Even the elephants foot is likely to be safe to approach with basic safeguards (like washing your hands afterwards) pretty soon. The story that 10k years from now a society will be wiped out because they dug up some huge ball of nasty nuclear waste is much more likely to be a story about how people built a society in an area around an old lead smelter and all their kids got lead poisoning, or mercury poisoning from built up metallic mercury, or any number of other problems. The long term dangers tend to get exaggerated by many folks for their own reasons (including the planners for long term retention/storage and politicians), but aren’t really realistic. Edit: also, unlike my car keys, if the waste IS actually radioactive, it’s easy to find even in microscopic quantities using technology and skills available to any high schooler. It’s VERY unlikely that humanity would forget how to build a cloud chamber detector if this was even a passing concern. Unlike say dioxin contamination, or any of a dozen types of long lived industrial poisoning/contamination you’ll find near any major population centers or industrial areas literally right now that are a bigger risk.