2 ms·
> A company is a complex web of self-interested individuals maximizing their own value functions within the constraints of the overall function of maximizing sh
by wolverine876 5y ago
> A company is a complex web of self-interested individuals maximizing their own value functions within the constraints of the overall function of maximizing shareholder value.
Maximising shareholder value is just one philosophy, popular mostly in the US and UK, and no longer so popular. It's not some universal truth or natural law. My other comment goes into more detail:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30646400 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30646400
> self-interested individuals maximizing their own value functions
The rational self-interested econo-human is just a simplified abstraction useful for easily modeling economics. It's not meant to describe real people or be a normative recommendation for living.
Real humans are much more than self-interested; we are social beings who are defined - who experience the world - by caring (trigger word!), cooperating, or just giving. The theory of selfishness is provocative and widely repeated, but doesn't hold up to even a little scrutiny. Most of what humans do is for others. Humanity has supported almost no religious or moral philosophy that preaches self-interest rather than duty to others. People support Ukraine right now with little self-interest; the whole democratic and free world - the most successful political philosophy in history, with no competitors - is built on freedom for others (everyone always believed in freedom for themselves!). Scientists, soldiers, teachers, open source software ... so much is done by people not maximizing their personal value function, but because they naturally care about the others. Anyone who has really made love knows, beyond a doubt, that it is about the other person's joy. That is the psychologically normal, healthy state.
It's good news - great news! It's really that good. But it's threatening to worldviews and that's why always some people have rejected gospel[0].
[0] gos spell - good spell - 'good news', and yes meant here as double entendre.
- bitshiftfaced 5y ago> Real humans are much more than self-interested; we are social beings who are defined - who experience the world - by caring (trigger word!), cooperating, or just giving. The theory of selfishness is provocative and widely repeated, but doesn't hold up to even a little scrutiny. Most of what humans do is for others. Yeah this is where we disagree philosophically. I'm in the egoism camp. That is to say that when people care, cooperate, and give, it's really about them seeing that these actions result in the most benefit for themselves in the long run. We live in a society where if you're seen as selfish and uncaring, people can make your life miserable, and will no longer cooperate with you. Or they'll straight up attack you. There's also painful feelings of regret and guilt when we fail to act in a way we've learned is the right, good way. And perhaps some of those emotions were ingrained into us from millennia of evolution, since groups that help one another are more likely to survive. The point is that avoiding these feelings of guilt is a powerful motivation, but it's still about how I will feel if I help someone.