4 ms·
There are a good few pumped storage sites in the world, here's the one most convenient for me to visit (now that COVID-19 precautions have eased) in Scotland:
by tialaramex 5y ago
There are a good few pumped storage sites in the world, here's the one most convenient for me to visit (now that COVID-19 precautions have eased) in Scotland:
https://www.visitcruachan.co.uk/ https://www.visitcruachan.co.uk/
It isn't practical to build mountains, so you need to find some natural mountains you don't mind cutting a big hole into, with a pre-existing lake at the top, at the bottom, or ideally both, and then spend a lot of money building the storage system, plus hook it up to the grid.
The US does have lots of spare mountains, but they aren't exactly in the middle of cities where it would be convenient, so the infrastructure cost is very large.
In the UK one rationale for these sites is that they have Black Start capability. In the event of a complete network failure, there is no grid power, most power stations can't be started from this situation, they need the grid first. At suitably equipped pumped storage sites a relatively modest amount of local electrical power (e.g. from a portable diesel generator) is enough to get the site running with no outside help, whereupon it can produce, for a few hours, a great deal of electrical power for the grid, and other generators on the grid can use that power to start themselves up safely. By the time the reservoir is empty, lots of other generators are back online. Black Start justified paying them money to exist even back when they weren't regularly used. Today cheap wind power means pumped storage is economic anyway, fill it up at night with cheap power (sometimes at negative cost) and then generate electricity in the early evening peak with all that water.
- idiotsecant 5y agoThe infrastructure cost is not nearly the burden that the regulatory process is. Building any kind of hydroelectric in the United States is a massive political and bureaucratic undertaking. If you plan on building pumped storage you better set aside a decade or two of constant effort to get through that process. Once you have that part done the actual building of it is comparatively simple. I am an engineer in hydro and would absolutely love the chance to be involved in more pumped storage projects but they are quite rare for that reason, despite being a perfect match for what our grid currently needs (much more storage!)
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoPumped hydro is cool, but we already have more storage than we need, its called "not burning gas". And until we run out of opportunities to not burn gas, theres no real demand for storage. Hopefully well get there soon, but the more people say "we can't build more renewables until we have storage", the longer that is going to take.
- replygirl 5y agoeurope came within weeks of consumer energy rationing this winter because it almost ran out of natural gas. in the us, our natural gas infrastructure is such that if you build a new building in new york city, you can't get a gas hookup.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI'm not sure you understood my comment. Europe has lots of gas heaters, and gas electrical generation. Which means they can build lots of renewables without any need for storage. They just store the gas they would have burned when it's windy and sunny, and burn it when it's not. Every gas heater replaced with a heat pump, increases this 'storage' capacity. Until that stops being true, they have no real need for storage, just more renewables. One cheap and effective way to do this, is to ban new gas hookups on newly built or refurbished buildings. This saves a lot of money. It sounds like NY is doing this, so good for them. Smart move New York.
- idiotsecant 5y agoI don't know how to respond to this comment. You seem to be saying that not burning natural gas would somehow negate the need for electrical storage on the grid? If that's what you're trying to say you're definitely incorrect, there's no real argument to be made otherwise. Not burning natural gas means that we need to supply more electricity for heating loads, typically at times that solar is less able to serve that load. This increases the need for storage if your assumption is that the load will be served by renewable sources and not, for example, by natural gas thermal generation. The physics of this are pretty simple and obvious, I'm not sure what you're getting at.
- s0rce 5y agoThe US already has tons of reservoirs in the mountains. I think California does do some pumped hydro energy storage at the moment. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helms_Pumped_Storage_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helms_Pumped_Storage_Plant https://www.sdcwa.org/projects/san-vicente-pumping-facilities/ https://www.sdcwa.org/projects/san-vicente-pumping-facilitie...
- danans 5y ago> It isn't practical to build mountains, so you need to find some natural mountains you don't mind cutting a big hole into You don't even need a mountain. A hill will do: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludington_Pumped_Storage_Power_Plant https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludington_Pumped_Storage_Pow...
- Manuel_D 5y agoWhen including inflation, it's delivered at a cost of 2 billion dollars for 19 GWh of storage. $200 per KWh isn't exactly good, it's not even on par with lithium ion batteries.
- Lascaille 5y ago2016 generation: -752 GW/h
- amscanne 5y agoBut since it’s not a generation facility and has a 70% efficiency, that implies it stored and returned 2506 GWh of electricity. At peak retail prices where I am in California (absurdly expensive) that’s worth over 1.5 billion dollars. Obviously you won’t have retail pricing, the market is different and you have transmission costs, etc. but the economics are still surprising. 200 $/kWh might be perfectly fine for a safe, low-maintenance, environment friendly storage that can be used with no time constraints.