I think you're right. I have 2 points worth considering in this case: 1. If something hits the front page, shouldn't it immediately be moderated? As it has mo

I think you're right. I have 2 points worth considering in this case: 1. If something hits the front page, shouldn't it immediately be moderated? As it has more visibility? 2. About the community moderating itself - that's a risk of populism and echo-chamber. By definition, HN works by popular vote. Letting the community decide to overcome guidelines by popular vote is what can lead to community to a dark populism point.