6 ms·
Tangentially related: New York is home to NYPA[1], the largest public power utility/authority in the United States. NYPA is entirely owned by the public, produc
by woodruffw 5y ago
Tangentially related: New York is home to NYPA[1], the largest public power utility/authority in the United States. NYPA is entirely owned by the public, produces some of the cheapest (and greenest) power in the country, and is funded in perpetuity by bonds instead of taxes.
Edit: This bond announcement[2] document claims that NYPA provides over 25% of NY's electricity and owns over 30% of the physical delivery infrastructure in the state.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Power_Authority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Power_Authority
[2]: https://www.nypa.gov/-/media/nypa/documents/document-library/financials/nypa-green-bond-framework.pdf https://www.nypa.gov/-/media/nypa/documents/document-library...
- Spooky23 5y agoI grew up near this NYPA facility, which is a really interesting energy storage idea: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blenheim%E2%80%93Gilboa_Hydroelectric_Power_Station?wprov=sfti1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blenheim%E2%80%93Gilboa_Hydroe... Basically, they built a reservoir on top of a mountain, and pump water up there during off peak times. When NYC hits peak demand, they let the water flow down. Essentially a giant water battery!
- woodruffw 5y agoPumped storage is an incredible technology. I’m glad that chemical battery technology is advancing, but I would love to see more construction of this sort!
- cinntaile 5y agoThere are some projects that want to repurpose old mines for pumped storage.
- woodruffw 5y agoI'm curious how that would work, given that mines are usually below ground. Or do you mean mountaintop mines?
- cinntaile 5y agoIt works the same in both ways, you just need the height difference and two reservoirs. When you need the electricity, the water flows downstream into the mine reservoir. Then it gets pumped up again when it's cheap. I do wonder about the economic feasability, but maybe I'm underestimating the amount of empty volume available in a mine.
- klenwell 5y agoI found myself talking randomly to an Enron engineer years ago right around the time they were imploding. He described working on a similar project. Pump the water up in the dead of night. Let it flow down the next day. Then, well, certain facts came to light and the project got halted. At the time we were talking, he was reporting to an empty office to search for a new job.
- boringg 5y agoPumped storage - always interesting highly doubt it will be realized in any real meaningful way (might be some interesting one off projectS). We've stopped building dams and its too difficult to site close to markets.
- idiotsecant 5y agoWhether it's close to markets or not is not particularly relevant. I am a engineer at a utility whose power mix is primarily hydroelectric and whose customer base is primarily not at the top of a mountain in a steep canyon river. That's what transmission lines are for! With the increasing role of regional ISO likes the subject of this article those transmission networks only get more efficient.
- boringg 5y agoProximity matters to minimize losses and lower transmissions costs for economic viability of the plant. Obviously Im not talking about the population being at the top of the mountain I'm talking about geological formations that are viable that are close to the marke in order for the value prop of energy storage from pumped storage to realized
- pydry 5y agoChina just finished the largest one in the world. It produces more power than a nuclear power plant. UK is building a huge one too.
- chasd00 5y agois there enough difference in price to actually turn a profit doing that?
- tialaramex 5y agoIt depends, but in some cases certainly. https://www.bmreports.com/bmrs/?q=eds/main https://www.bmreports.com/bmrs/?q=eds/main That top left graph is showing you the (notional) system price for grid electricity in the UK. The x axis is settlement periods, which are 30 minutes long, thus period 14 on that graph ends 0700 local time, before many people are awake, system price was £0 per MWh. You want it? Have it. The evening peak a few hours ago was £327 per MWh. So if you bought 2GWh of electricity this morning and sold just 50% of it back this evening (accounting for losses) you made over £300 000 on that transaction. Now, those sites aren't free, I'm sure you need a dozen or more specialist engineers who aren't paid minimum wage to run a plant like that, and the spares are doubtless expensive, it's not as though everybody has a spare 100MW turbine/ pump sat around you could buy. But you can do that most days and sometimes twice a day, so it's potentially a nice earner. Once upon a time all the ones in the UK were owned by the government but today they are owned by for-profit corporations.
- dahfizz 5y agoAdmittedly, this is in the UK where electricity is ~10x more expensive at peak.
- jodrellblank 5y agoIs it possible to scale that trade down to something one could do at home, without much equipment and therefore not require much in the way of planning permission? Scale that transaction down 1/3000th to get £100 for the trade. If you could do that every day it would set you up for a yearly pre-tax income of £36k; instead of trading 1GWh the trade would be 333KWh, equivalent to 1.2 Gigajoules. Solve the Pumped Hydro storage equation E = mgh (Energy = mass * gravitational acceleration * height) for 1.2e9 = mass * 9.81 * 2 meter lift => 60 Megagrams of water => 60 tons of water lifted 2 meters will do it. Water is ~1 ton per cubic meter, that's 60 cubic meters, about a 4x4x4 meter cube. Twice the volume of a small outdoor pool. And it would need enough pumping power to move it two meters in half an hour for one settlement period. One millimeter per second. That seems infeasibly huge. (Even scaling it down another 1/10th is 6 tons of water which is large. maybe if it could be lifting a cubic meter of Iron, 8 tons, by one meter, it could be £5/day or £1500/year. A tenth the size again it would never pay for itself, and now I'm almost at the systems of dragging lumps of rock on rails up a slope to store energy and letting them roll down to release it).
- tialaramex 5y agoThere are a good few pumped storage sites in the world, here's the one most convenient for me to visit (now that COVID-19 precautions have eased) in Scotland: https://www.visitcruachan.co.uk/ https://www.visitcruachan.co.uk/ It isn't practical to build mountains, so you need to find some natural mountains you don't mind cutting a big hole into, with a pre-existing lake at the top, at the bottom, or ideally both, and then spend a lot of money building the storage system, plus hook it up to the grid. The US does have lots of spare mountains, but they aren't exactly in the middle of cities where it would be convenient, so the infrastructure cost is very large. In the UK one rationale for these sites is that they have Black Start capability. In the event of a complete network failure, there is no grid power, most power stations can't be started from this situation, they need the grid first. At suitably equipped pumped storage sites a relatively modest amount of local electrical power (e.g. from a portable diesel generator) is enough to get the site running with no outside help, whereupon it can produce, for a few hours, a great deal of electrical power for the grid, and other generators on the grid can use that power to start themselves up safely. By the time the reservoir is empty, lots of other generators are back online. Black Start justified paying them money to exist even back when they weren't regularly used. Today cheap wind power means pumped storage is economic anyway, fill it up at night with cheap power (sometimes at negative cost) and then generate electricity in the early evening peak with all that water.
- idiotsecant 5y agoThe infrastructure cost is not nearly the burden that the regulatory process is. Building any kind of hydroelectric in the United States is a massive political and bureaucratic undertaking. If you plan on building pumped storage you better set aside a decade or two of constant effort to get through that process. Once you have that part done the actual building of it is comparatively simple. I am an engineer in hydro and would absolutely love the chance to be involved in more pumped storage projects but they are quite rare for that reason, despite being a perfect match for what our grid currently needs (much more storage!)
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoPumped hydro is cool, but we already have more storage than we need, its called "not burning gas". And until we run out of opportunities to not burn gas, theres no real demand for storage. Hopefully well get there soon, but the more people say "we can't build more renewables until we have storage", the longer that is going to take.
- nickt 5y agoThere's a similar facility at Dinorwig in Wales. It's important not only to handle the load of all the kettles being switched on at half-time (what they refer to as "TV pickup", an almost 3GW increase in demand), but it's also a "black start" site. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dinorwig_Power_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dinorwig_Power_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_start https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_start
- jodrellblank 5y agoIt used to be, but not anymore, according to a Tom Scott video and interview with people working there. The National Grid used to look at the TV listings and put Dinorwig on standby for busy times, but there's so many TV channels and streaming options now that there isn't so much of a coordinated sharp spike of the whole country doing something at the same time. Its main use now is in balancing calm moments of solar and wind power generation, apparently. Source: - https://youtu.be/6Jx_bJgIFhI?t=210 https://youtu.be/6Jx_bJgIFhI?t=210
- nsomani 5y agoYeah it's actually very common, it's called pumped storage. Many power pricing models will treat them identically to batteries given they also bid into what's called the "ancillary services market," which exists for reliability purposes to balance the grid when supply and demand don't perfectly match up. You can read about other types of storage on the PJM ISO website: https://learn.pjm.com/energy-innovations/energy-storage https://learn.pjm.com/energy-innovations/energy-storage
- smrz 5y agoAnother random cool thing about Gilboa is it's host to fossils of the oldest forests on Earth: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilboa_Fossil_Forest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilboa_Fossil_Forest
- stevenhubertron 5y agoHey I did as well. I always thought it cool and as kids wondered if we swam in there if we get sucked up the hill at night. Had loads of fun at the community pool there as well.
- dillondoyle 5y agoI wish we had more of this. Read an article from my state today about a local utility that was created specifically to get local control and more sustainable energy. But their proposed large scale solar farm was denied a zoning change because some town thought it was bad idea to remove ( a tiny amount of ) farm land. The util contractor even said they would still water the land (dumb this is a desert) and have sheep. https://coloradosun.com/2022/03/08/delta-county-rejects-dmea-solar-project/ https://coloradosun.com/2022/03/08/delta-county-rejects-dmea... Insane to me. Is there any proof that for profit incentives actually lower costs without effecting safety, reliability, and sustainability? Texas stands out as proof it doesn't. And even when it's semi-regulated when the profit is fixed % it just incentivizes the wrong thing when we need to scale down/build more sustainable.
- matdehaast 5y agoWe in South Africa have a single state owned energy producer, Eskom. We consistently have power cuts (load shedding) to prevent grid collapse, it has the highest head count per MWH produced and is in total disarray. I definitely believe having multiple independent producers makes a huge difference for competition and ensuring energy stability
- 0xy 5y agoEskom is in disarray because of affirmative action policies that prevent the hiring of qualified engineers, and ensure the creation of corrupt suppliers that do things like charge USD$18,000 for a broom. [1] [2] It has little to do with actual infrastructure and is more related to huge knowledge gaps and political corruption. [1] https://www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/eskom-must-suspend-affirmative-action-356581 https://www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/eskom-must-suspend-a... [2] https://www.biznews.com/undictated/2021/11/16/eskom-bee-affirmative-action https://www.biznews.com/undictated/2021/11/16/eskom-bee-affi...
- drak0n1c 5y agoNYPA is unfortunately not green where it counts - their anti-nuclear stance in lockstep with Cuomo has led to NY needing to build three new natural gas power plants to compensate for losses from shuttering nuclear. https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=47776 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=47776 https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/12/nyregion/indian-point-power-plant-closing.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/12/nyregion/indian-point-pow... https://www.reuters.com/article/us-utilities-nypa-energy-indianpoint/nypa-says-entergy-indian-point-power-contract-to-end-in-2013-idUSBRE88B1C020120912 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-utilities-nypa-energy-ind... NYPA hasn't been very cheap in recent years either - 45% more expensive than the national average with rates ranging around 18-20 cents/kwh. https://www.nyserda.ny.gov/Researchers-and-Policymakers/Energy-Prices/Electricity/Monthly-Avg-Electricity-Residential https://www.nyserda.ny.gov/Researchers-and-Policymakers/Ener...
- woodruffw 5y agoCertainly. I wish they would build more nuclear power, invest in more offshore wind farms (NY has plenty of eligible coastline), and all around do just about anything other than build more natural gas plants.
- tamaharbor 5y agoYou’re not building a windmill on MY coastline.
- woodruffw 5y agoFortunately, it's not your decision[1]. [1]: https://www.nyserda.ny.gov/All-Programs/Offshore-Wind/Focus-Areas/NY-Offshore-Wind-Projects https://www.nyserda.ny.gov/All-Programs/Offshore-Wind/Focus-...