3 ms·
One of my kids got into vinyl a few years ago and that triggered me to get my CD collection out of the attic and I started buying CDs again. I really enjoy list
by criddell 5y ago
One of my kids got into vinyl a few years ago and that triggered me to get my CD collection out of the attic and I started buying CDs again. I really enjoy listening to entire albums.
Lately though, I've been using Apple Music because I got a free trial and found I really like their spatial audio and ATMOS tracks. Just about everything I stream is lossless and most that I listen to are higher than CD quality.
The big question is (ignoring spatial audio), can I tell a difference between 16 bit / 44 kHz (CD) and 24 bit / 192 kHz (studio master)? The answer seems to be maybe. I've tried A-B tests where I switch between the two and I can never notice any differences. But after listening to an entire album I can often say that the album was CD or studio master quality. I wonder if maybe the two formats are mixed differently?
The CD format is trapped in amber and the world is moving on (esp. with spatial audio) and I think that's too bad for people who like to buy music.
- digisign 5y agoI don't find the extra resolution helps at all at playback time, although I have older ears now. What it significant is a quality master in the first place. With that I downsample to 16/48, I personally can't tell the difference at that point from higher-res. For example, I've made mp3/opus from a quality remaster, that sound better than the 80s CD, simply because the new master was scanned on better equipment.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoIt is not a good A/B test unless you are blind to which test is CD and which is not. Have you done that? (You need the help of another person)
- pier25 5y ago> can I tell a difference between 16 bit / 44 kHz (CD) and 24 bit / 192 kHz (studio master)? Even under perfect listening conditions (which are very rare) 99.99% of people won't be able to tell the difference. The vast majority of people can't tell the difference between a 44.1Khz/16 bits .wav and a 128kbps MP3.
- boc 5y agoThat's not true. If you said 320kbps MP3 then maybe I'd agree. 128 sounds crushed as hell on most decent setups.
- pier25 5y agoHave you done a proper AB blind test to verify that? I studied sound engineering and we did that test. Most people failed and it was in a studio environment. I couldn't imagine regular people not interested in audio with consumer gear. Edit: If you do the AB test, you really need to get pretty close to 100% success to claim you can hear the difference. Anything closer to 50% is just random luck.
- lostgame 5y ago>> The vast majority of people can't tell the difference between a 44.1Khz/16 bits .wav and a 128kbps MP3. ...are you kidding? I think most people could easily tell the difference between a CD and a 128kbps MP3 if asked to listen to it hard enough. That, or play it in a club loud enough - and watch everyone cringe. As the other commenter said - 320kbps - alright, sure. But 128kbps? Come on.
- zbuf 5y agoWith a modern encoder, I think that's virtually guaranteed, yes. Most peoples idea of "horrible" 128kbps seems to be skewed by the early days of MP3 -- which does mean there are horrible files and encoders out there, yes. But a modern LAME encoder is streets ahead at 128kbps.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- saila 5y ago> The big question is (ignoring spatial audio), can I tell a difference between 16 bit / 44 kHz (CD) and 24 bit / 192 kHz (studio master)? Unless there's something different about the mix (as you note), it's unlikely that most people in most circumstances could hear a meaningful difference. If someone has high end equipment & speakers and the speakers are placed correctly in an ideal room or if you've got high end headphones, then maybe, but otherwise I'm skeptical.
- aidenn0 5y agoNo, you cannot tell the difference between 16/44 and 24/192, unless the 24/192 has enough high frequency content to cause non-linear distortions in your speakers. 24/192 makes sense for recording because the extra bits give you more headroom to prevent clipping and the higher sampling rate means you can use less aggressive analog low-pass filters on your input. I should also note that your playback solution likely has higher THD+N than the floor imposed by 16 bits. 16 bits implies a noise floor of -96dB which would be a THD+N of about 0.002%. Your playback equipment is probably 11-14 bits equivalent for the noise floor (-66 to -84dB). With 16 bits of depth you probably won't even be able to tell between a properly and improperly dithered CD that was normalized before down-sampling. I agree that spatial audio is long overdue. IMO, Ambisonics had the right idea in the 1970s, though it was at least 20 years to early for actual adoption.
- IYasha 5y agoMaybe it's just better mastering, but I mostly hear the difference between 44 and 48KHz. And because of this, I'd love to see more DVD audio selling too :)
- neverartful 5y ago> get my CD collection out of the attic Yes, please get your CDs out of the attic. Same is true for your photographs, cameras, paintings, and many other things.