3 ms·
I think any automated vehicle, no matter how advanced, should always have a big red button to make it stop whatever it's doing. Kind of like the emergency brake
by HPsquared 5y ago
I think any automated vehicle, no matter how advanced, should always have a big red button to make it stop whatever it's doing. Kind of like the emergency brake on a passenger train.
- hef19898 5y agoYou mean like machinery in factories? Sounds like a revolutionary idea!
- asah 5y agothat would be two hands on the wheel and pulled them away stops the device. https://www.google.com/search?q=machinery+two+hand+control https://www.google.com/search?q=machinery+two+hand+control
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- awb 5y agoMaybe a “stop gracefully” mode? If you hit the big red button going 65mph on the center lane of a crowded highway, it could be bad. Especially if the tech starts to feel safe enough that cars can travel close enough to use the draft from cars ahead. I think an emergency brake works for trains because they’re isolated.
- ra7 5y agoThey do have a "pull over" physical button. You can see them on Waymo vehicles. The car finds a safe spot to pull over when you hit it.
- hackernewds 5y agoCould be an absurd idea, but could require a licensed driver with experience taking over the wheel instead to steer the car with human logic, instead of trusting the failing AI to park it Oh wait..
- a9h74j 5y agoSome high-power industrial systems have both a "controlled shutdown" emergency button and a "remove all power" emergency button, by whatever names.
- oneoff786 5y agoLogically there needs to be a way to control the car at all times, otherwise you could be locked into a long trip you don’t want to take. The difference is just that it’s higher level controls than a steering wheel.
- cj 5y agoI'm pretty sure this was an episode on HBO's Silicon Valley. The character's Tesla drove itself onto a container ship with the driver stuck inside, unable to get out of the car.
- phoe18 5y agoYes, source for anyone interested in (re)watching: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-trd_f6j3eI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-trd_f6j3eI
- quest88 5y agoMakes sense. This is what we have in planes. We can also pull the autopilot circuit breaker.
- mLuby 5y agoI'd like to imagine we'd have "manual override" controls like I, Robot (2004) showed: https://youtube.com/shorts/46-EGyn7rwc https://youtube.com/shorts/46-EGyn7rwc As implied in the clip, after a few years of self-driving cars, most passengers won't know how to drive well enough for it to be safe and other autonomous vehicles might not coordinate well with a manual driver. A "pull over" button could work, but still relies on the automated driving capabilities. A third option would be to dial an "expert driver" who takes remote control of the car to get you to safety, bypassing both the automated driver and the passengers' inability to drive. Lack of connectivity could be an issue, and it opens the door wider for hackers (already an issue though). However I have to imagine that in-transit connectivity will be increasing dramatically once people want to work or watch Netflix during their commute.
- visarga 5y agoPull overs are much easier to automate than driving, their automated version will probably be much safer than regular automated driving.
- natch 5y agoSo if it was already in the midst of slowing down to pull over safely, pushing this big red button would do what, stop it suddenly in the middle of the road?
- TameAntelope 5y agoYeah, in case the "safe pull over" spot is made of lava, or something.
- peteradio 5y agoA sufficiently autonomous vehicle might just ignore you. Are pedal brakes in passenger driven vehicles reliant on computer at all, what about electrical transmission?