8 ms·
Apple's Tim Cook raises concern over LGBTQ laws in the U.S.
- krasicki 5y agoNever mentions his concern. Devolves into identity politic opinion piece.
- TrispusAttucks 5y agoThe way this (4-page) bill is being spun is completely insane. We are no longer grounded in reality. This bill basically says: - If something happens to your kid at school parents must be informed - Teachers can not say "Don't tell your parents." to children - Classes shouldn't be discussing sexual content in grades K-2. Those seem incredibly common sense! You can see House Bill 1557 here [1] [1] https://www.flsenate.gov/Session/Bill/2022/1557/BillText/Filed/PDF https://www.flsenate.gov/Session/Bill/2022/1557/BillText/Fil...
- caiob 5y ago
- RobertDeNiro 5y agoYou conveniently left out the part that says : "A school district may not encourage classroom discussion about sexual orientation or gender identity in primary grade levels or in a manner that is not age-appropriate or developmentally appropriate for students." And that parents may sue a school over it.
- dontcare007 5y agoseems good to me. kids at that age are too young for those kinds of discussions, and could be mentally warped by them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ghiculescu 5y agoThat rule seems common sense too. I’d want that at my kids school. As a non American I don’t understand your collective love of suing, what would a better recourse here be?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- TrispusAttucks 5y agoI did not. If you believe discussing sexual content to kindergarteners is acceptable then we fundamentally disagree at a moral level.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoIt's not clear if you're intentionally trying to conflate kindergartners, with all school children. There's a lot of things in life that are not suitable for kindergartners, but are suitable and appropriate for other school age children, I believe driving trucks is one such thing in America. If your only argument against those things is "well its not appropriate for kindergarten" when the law is not only covering kindergarten, then it feels like you're confused about what this law you support says. Maybe thats why you can't understand people's reactions to it?
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> conflate kindergartners, with all school children It appears the bill is concerned with K through 2 and has the caveat of age and developmental appropriateness. I don’t think it bans a teacher reading a storybook with a gay couple doing dishes together. (EDIT: never mind, it bans “discussion about sexual orientation or gender identity in primary grade levels or in a manner that is not age-appropriate or developmentally appropriate” [1].) [1] https://m.flsenate.gov/session/bill/2022/1557/billtext/filed/pdf https://m.flsenate.gov/session/bill/2022/1557/billtext/filed... 1001.42 § 8(c)(3)
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThe bill specifically says no mention of sex or gender in primary 'or' no age inappropriateness with no year specified. If you're not allowed to talk about it at all K-2 then the next sentence would be redundant unless it applies more widely. My reading is that they want this vague ban to apply to older kids.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago
- pensatoio 5y ago> that is not age-appropriate or developmentally appropriate for students You're quoting it like it's an issue, but I'm not seeing one. Teaching sexuality to young children is tantamount to abuse, in my opinion. Obviously that sentiment is not shared by everyone, but that's why it shouldn't be forced on kids without their parent's consent.
- mcphage 5y agoWhat does "Teaching sexuality to children" mean to you? Is talking about marriage "teaching sexuality"?
- bryanlarsen 5y agoWTF do you think they teach? Sexuality at that age group is mostly stuff like "if somebody touches you there or takes pictures of you without your clothes on, tell somebody".
- stby 5y agoThat's ridiculous. Kids start asking questions about sex as soon as they or one of their friends mother gets pregnant and they deserve honest answers and they can handle it, probably better than many grown-ups. That doesn't mean they need to know about all or even most aspects of sexuality, but some basic and factual knowledge doesn't hurt.
- lp0_on_fire 5y agoand you're conveniently leaving out the ages of the students this is targeting: 3rd grade and below. 8 years or younger. There's no reason students that age should be taught about sexuality's and gender by anyone other than their parents and I'm continually creeped out by the ever-larger contingent of teachers who _insist they must_ be able to talk to my 5 year old nephew about sex.
- bendergender 5y agoGender? If a kid has a friend who is non binary, or has a trans friend, and asks their teachers about it you think it's inappropriate for the teacher to say, "well, some people are boys, some people are girls, some people are neither, and we try to make sure we respect each other."
- slowmovintarget 5y agoThe problem is, that's science-denial, so yes, it would be inappropriate for the teacher to say that. Unpacking the accurate phrase "some people feel they are neither and their views should be respected" for a five year old or even an eight year old is not reasonable territory for a primary school teacher whose only training on the matter is political.
- drewbug01 5y agoTeaching children to respect other's views is very much something that I want schools to do. What's the legitimate alternative? What should the teacher say there? > The problem is, that's science-denial, so yes, it would be inappropriate for the teacher to say that. So - imagine that little Timmy has religious parents, and thus believes that God created the heavens and the earth in six literal days (a not-uncommon belief held in the fundamentalist Christian community). Suppose then that little Susie overhears it and asks the teacher about why her parents told her that life evolved gradually over the course of eons. In my mind, an appropriate response could be "some people believe that the universe was created by a deity, and their views should be respected." But you've indicated that "some people believe <x> and their views should be respected" is in fact inappropriate. What would you suggest be done, otherwise?
- dontcare007 5y agoThe same thing was done with the GA voter laws. Reality left the building...
- candiddevmike 5y agoPrimary grade in the US isn't K-2, it could mean anything from K-4, or even K-7. Not sure why the bill isn't more specific.
- mgkimsal 5y agoit might have a specific meaning in Florida, where the bill will take effect?
- candiddevmike 5y agoYou're right, it's through grade 3 per this site: https://www.fldoe.org/teaching/certification/certificate-subjects/ https://www.fldoe.org/teaching/certification/certificate-sub...
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI know nothing about this issue, but can tell from a quick read through, that that's a bad summary. It's fairly unusual for CEOs to get involved like this which suggests it's a bad law or the whole world has gone crazy. I'm going to go with 'its a bad law' as my prior on this.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>It's fairly unusual for CEOs to get involved like this which suggests it's a bad law or the whole world has gone crazy. Or all the people briefing the CEO live in the same filter bubble and have advised them that this is a fight worth picking. Cook has kept his mouth shut on a lot of adjacent, sometimes even more egregious, issues over the past few years so I think it's a bit foolish to think that the advice these guys are getting plays no role.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI did mention the "world has gone crazy" option that the person I replied to seems to believe. I'd file "CEOs of both Apple and Disney wading into a Florida political battle about sexuality and education by mistake because they didn't bother to read the text of the law they're protesting about" under that same "world has gone crazy" heading. Luckily for us, it seems that it's just Republicans being intentionally vague in order to pass laws that wouldn't pass if they spelled out what they actually mean.
- bendergender 5y agoIt also forbids discussing gender identity in primary school, which is completely reactionary. Discussing gender is fine for kids, and it's totally developmentally appropriate for primary school kids to know that there are boys, girls, and non binary people. It also requires disclosing any emotional or mental health changes to parents. If a kid tells a teacher, "I've realized I'm gay, and that is making me depressed/hard to concentrate" the school needs to inform the parents. That's a huge problem in some parts of the country where being gay can result in neglect, abuse, abandonment, being sent to conversion therapy, or more subtle discrimination and outing. You've really given this law a very surface reading, and not thought about, "how could this be used adversarially to hurt people." (I'm about as lefty as they come, but I'm generally against gun control laws, for instance, because I believe they will be enforced in a way that hurts people.)
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> seem incredibly common sense The word “or” in 1001.42 § 8(c)(3) [1], which bans “discussion about sexual orientation or gender identity in primary grade levels or in a manner that is not age-appropriate or developmentally appropriate,” looks problematic. (Emphasis mine.) Nix that word and the statute is fine. With it, a teacher can’t say anything if a 2nd grader, a 7 or 8 year old, asks what it means to be gay. They can’t read a storybook about two married men or women doing dishes. That seems excessive. [1] https://m.flsenate.gov/session/bill/2022/1557/billtext/filed/pdf https://m.flsenate.gov/session/bill/2022/1557/billtext/filed... top of page 3
- moltke 5y ago> With it, a teacher can’t say anything if a 2nd grader, a 7 or 8 year old, asks what it means to be gay. I would expect them to say nothing other than "ask your parents" and I don't know why anyone would think anything else makes sense.
- NoSorryCannot 5y agoI have a problem with it being taboo. It's not a talk about the birds and the bees and can absolutely be addressed in an age-appropriate manner.
- JohnTHaller 5y agoLeaving out the ambiguous and vague language seems to be a huge GOP talking point. K-2 "or in a manner that is not age-appropriate or developmentally appropriate". It's purposely and needlessly vague. If it applied to ONLY K-2 that would be an entirely different story.
- pensatoio 5y ago
- mcphage 5y agoSo if you ask a little boy if she likes a girl in her class, that's abuse?
- mgkimsal 5y agothat may not be 'sexuality' in a strict sense, and might also be considered 'age appropriate'. but then again, it might not be. seems to be very much in the eye-of-the-beholder-preparing-to-bring-legal-action.
- mcphage 5y ago> seems to be very much in the eye-of-the-beholder-preparing-to-bring-legal-action. That's why people are concerned about this law.
- mgkimsal 5y agoI kinda feel the same way about parents having 5 year olds sing about "round yon virgin".
- moltke 5y agoThe word "virgin" doesn't get explained to the children, it's just another one of those "old bible things" for them until they're old enough.
- bendergender 5y agoDiscussing sexuality: "some boys like boys" or "if someone touches you in a swimsuit area, tell a grown up right away", or "many families have mommies and daddies, but some families have two mommies and some have just one parent" Teaching kids that we should acknowledge and respect each other, even if our families are different, and protect themselves from predators is not abuse. No one is talking about graphic penises and vaginas, sexuality education at this development age is about recognizing that families are different and that's ok.
- jimbob45 5y agohttps://archive.ph/rmWTB https://archive.ph/rmWTB
- bendergender 5y agoThe responses in this thread are deeply disappointing. Every law we have, just like every piece of tech we have, needs to be considered not only in the context of what words are on the paper but also how could it be deployed maliciously. How could this law be used to hurt or discriminate should be on someone's mind, just like we ask how could this API be misused. Seeing so many reactionary comments from folks who jump in to defend them because it aligns with their (in this case, right wing) political tribe is antithetical to the rational, deep thinking nature this place usually shows.
- andrew_ 5y agoI'm curious why you chose to reply throughout the comments here using a burner account, rather than your main. Are you at risk of retaliation? Genuinely curious.
- bendergender 5y agoI don't have a main. No risk of retaliation. Just a topic I'm informed on and it drives me up the wall to have people claim "reason" and "science" and then ignore the fact that science and reason widely agree with the idea that gender and sex aren't binary.
- andrew_ 5y agoUse of "widely" suggests bias, so I'd recommend being careful with that use. There is definitely a concensus among many scientists of that hypothesis, but it's disingenuous to pretend that there isn't the presence of a significant number of scientists that argue the opposite. Objectivity is incredibly important in science, and it breeds credibility. This topic has social and ideological components, both of which cloud objectivity when speaking of the science. If you believe that science evolves, it's paramount that we treat hypotheses objectively rather than through the lens of absolutism
- bendergender 5y agoI'm suggesting it's the majority opinion. Yes, there exist minority opinions as well, but generally we don't consider agreeing with the majority/consensus to be "ignoring the science".
- djohnston 5y agoNeat, he's cool with the situation in his suppliers countries still right? Until these people grow spines and start to advocate where there is actually risk for doing so they can stfu.
- drewbug01 5y agoI'm disappointed that this story is already flagged - while it may not be immediately relevant to the tech industry in some ways, consider that many of your LGBTQ+ colleagues in the US are deeply, deeply worried about these anti-LGBTQ laws popping up all over the US. It's difficult to focus on your job when you're being slowly legislated into a second-class citizen in much of the country. These things are on our minds constantly, and deserve discussion in our field. We, as an industry, wield enormous power in the US economy - and what we do or do not say as a field has tremendous impact on the way these events unfold. It should be relevant for discussion here, even if it's uncomfortable for some.