3 ms·
> Do we really need organisations like Thawte to be a moral judge of what website deserves to be visited securely? I'm not sure how you got to that question fr
by viraptor 5y ago
> Do we really need organisations like Thawte to be a moral judge of what website deserves to be visited securely?
I'm not sure how you got to that question from Thawte establishing they can't legally do business with a given customer. There's lots of other providers, many of them domestic for that bank - there's nothing about them "deserving" secure connections.
One of the CAB rules for revocation seems to apply perfectly too:
> The CA is made aware that a Subscriber has violated one or more of its material obligations under the Subscriber Agreement or Terms of Use
I'm sure "legally can work with you" is one of conditions listed in those two. (Or will be soon)
Edit: I realised there's also a practical reason why the bank would want the revocation - if Thawte can't work with them anymore, they could have issues reporting a key compromise / triggering revocation themselves.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago> Subscriber has violated one or more of its material obligations under the Subscriber Agreement I don't see the relevance - what has the bank violated? If someone introduces sanctions agaonst you, that's your not action or inaction, so this clause can't apply. Ofcourse sanctions override contracts, I am not clear if revoking certificates was legally nessesary but I don't think it's right. Suppose your money was in that bank and you need to buy insulin - should you die because of what the government did? Suppose you are an immigrant from Kazakhstan, it's not even your government. I don't think this 'press sanctions on ordinary people and hope for regime change' ever worked, dictatorships from Iran to North Korea seem to survive under sanctions
- manofmanysmiles 5y ago> Suppose your money was in that bank and you need to buy insulin - should you die because of what the government did? At some point, more people will realize that governments do not exists, and actions done in the name of “authority” are inherently wrong. > Ofcourse sanctions override contracts, I am not clear if revoking certificates was legally nessesary but I don't think it's right. What makes you so sure of this? Why should the decisions of a few people (the government) be able to affect private agreement between two other people?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- viraptor 5y agoThere are alternative services for certificates. Serious institutions often hold multiple certificates from different sources so there's no extra waiting time to switch in an emergency. I'm not arguing anything political / moral here. If they can't recover from this situation quickly, they should not be trusted with money or relied on in emergency the first place. Your card payments don't go through the bank's pubic website, so the emergency payment situation is not realistic either Thawte's TOS specifically includes: compliance with local laws, with export controls, and allows dropping the agreement in case of force majeure which includes war, armed conflict, terrorism, etc. So they have multiple reasons to drop the bank.
- cpach 5y ago“There's lots of other providers” Are you sure about that? I took a look at the root certificates that are included in Firefox[0], and AFAICT none of them are located in Russia. There are some Chinese CAs there though, so perhaps the Russian banks could use them instead. [0] https://wiki.mozilla.org/CA/Included_Certificates https://wiki.mozilla.org/CA/Included_Certificates
- zamadatix 5y agoPrecisely, having plenty of providers doesn't mean there is one in each country and most countries get by fine without a local provider. If a country finds itself commercially banned by so many countries it can't get a certificate from any of them and by the time this has happened it hasn't been able to get a domestic CA vetted by the international community then trust is broken on a deeper level than the CA system is designed to handle and is going to fall apart for that region either way.