11 ms·
An expensive game of pretend, while it lasts. TBD whether the end will be some real nation running out of patience with their antics, or a hurricane sweeping o
by bell-cot 5y ago
An expensive game of pretend, while it lasts. TBD whether the end will be some real nation running out of patience with their antics, or a hurricane sweeping over the tiny (1.2 acre) island, or some drug lord sending a few of his toughs to take over, or ...
- leros 5y agoYep it's all fun and games until someone invades.
- logicalmonster 5y agoI can totally understand not being optimistic about such a small island succeeding in creating a lasting paradise on Earth, but I think it's pretty incorrect and demeaning to view this as a game of pretend when they're actually attempting what they set out to do. Whatever else you want to say about these people, unlike some "real nation", none of them are using coercion and force to get people to organize as they see fit. That in and of itself should be lauded.
- hanniabu 5y ago> when they're actually attempting what they set out to do. Buying the land is the easiest step in this process. It's like dreaming of being a star athlete and going to the store to pick up some athletic shoes. But then buying them and not being sure what the next step is.
- cma 5y agoBuying land is still using state coercion (in a mild and accepted way) to deprive everyone else of it, it's a natural resource.
- simulate-me 5y agoThey have the option of using state coercion should someone contest their ownership, but they're not using it right now. Even with that pedantry aside, saying that property rights leverage "state coercion" is not a good take.
- ada1981 5y agoThat is what property rights are though. It’s a promise from the violence monopoly to keep people off your land.
- simulate-me 5y agoI don't think the government has a monopoly on violence in many places in Central America.
- ada1981 5y agoHow are the property rights there? The strength of a government, and thus, the property rights it “grants” people, is the degree to which it has been successful in establishing a violence monopoly.
- eesmith 5y agoNo, it isn't. People in countries like Finland have a 'freedom to roam', showing that property rights don't need to include the right to control who can enter a piece of land. This dates from a time when people recognized property ownership, but there was no government monopoly on violence. (See especially the Icelandic Commonwealth and the Icelandic sagas.)
- Animats 5y agoYes, and it's also too small. There have been at least two "crypto island" schemes.[1][2] Those are, at least, on bigger islands. Cryptoland didn't make the payment to acquire their island.[2] Not that you'd know this from their web site. Crypto Island is really a time-sharing condo scheme. Both islands are too small for the number of people they want to cram on them. And the plans show no infrastructure. No water, power, sewerage, docks, maintenance facilities, or warehouses. For comparison, see Great Stirrup Cay, which is owned by Norwegian Cruise Lines and is a tourist stopover. It's 268 acres, and about half luxury hotel and half support facilities.[4] Something that size could be a viable mini-state. [1] https://cryptoland.is/ https://cryptoland.is/ [2] https://www.cryptoisland.com/ https://www.cryptoisland.com/ [3] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/jan/16/cryptoland-runs-aground-as-12m-bid-to-buy-fiji-island-for-resort-falls-through https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/jan/16/cryptolan... [4] https://www.google.com/maps/@25.8251893,-77.9123977,1132m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/@25.8251893,-77.9123977,1132m/da...