6 ms·
A lot of that rings pretty true. Stephen Kotkin's own biography that I have been reading his some of the same points. Because of the new archives you can reall
by panick21_ 5y ago
A lot of that rings pretty true. Stephen Kotkin's own biography that I have been reading his some of the same points.
Because of the new archives you can really get an insight into the day to day operation of an empire that combined the power and function of New York, Washington, LA, Detroit and SF into one centrally run from an office. Its a a baffling process where Stalin moves between editing movies, deciding how many tanks to build and what kind, who would lead what part of the local bureaucracy and how to respond to an inquiry from a major foreign state and those meeting might be on the same day.
I highly recommend Kotkin two volumes on Stalin!
Being interested in WW1-WW2 timeframe what always struck me is the difference between Hitler and Stalin based on their basic outlook.
Hitler world-view was basically pessimistic, all races were in a global struggle for dominance, and its either win now or lose everything for ever. Low chance of success, no matter, its not or never. Germans were simply not close to the largest ethnic group.
Stalin on the other hand was fundamentally a Communist. Being in the end successful was not really a question, the global revolution was coming and they would win. Its really only a question of how long it would take. History would inevitably push in their direction.
Stalin foreign policy (not unlike Chamberlains) was to pull Germany to his side, because his fundamental Geo-strategic believe was that the global communist revolution would happen when the Capitalist were fighting in war against each other. But this time, the 'right reactionaries' would find the Red Army supporting the revolutionary.
German attack on France/Britain was everything Stalin had dreamed about for 2 decades. Decades of work leading him to the promised land, the Great Capitalistic War. And his plan very well might have worked, it was a decent strategy. Germans invaded with tanks using Soviet fuel and many other materials. But, French Army and Nation were not as they were in WW1 and they collapsed like a house of cards within weeks. Germany had landed into total continental power and most nations of Eastern Europe preferred them to the Soviets.
Stalin plan turned from mopping up weak regimes into being opposed by major very aggressive continental power. The Blowback of this strategy was gigantic, with 50+ million Soviets dying until it was over.
I despise Stalin and all the Bolsheviks, but Russian history is endlessly fascinating.
- bsedlm 5y agowow, I can't help but imagine a similar scenario but replacing Germany with Russia and Russia with China but maybe I'm just squinting my 'eyes' too hard
- recuter 5y agoOr if you ask a Russian, they'd say replacing Germany with the Ukraine and Russia with the USA in your analogy. I don't think you are squinting too hard, there is a common view in geopolitics as Russia being a peer (super)power and future tie breaker between the US and China. Or at least there was until two weeks ago. One explanation for recent events is China letting Putin stick his head out and by literally sitting back and doing nothing they'll essentially get to own Russia now. Which fits their style of doing things historically.
- hutzlibu 5y ago"by literally sitting back and doing nothing they'll essentially get to own Russia now." That would be Taoism, but overall, I do not see modern china as a non interfering power. Also, it is not settled yet, how all of this will play out.
- recuter 5y agoSure it is. He can't climb down from the military debacle without getting overthrown. Similarly, the politicians in countries that so publicly imposed sanctions on him won't be able to backpedal either. Short of a coup d'etat, a new iron curtain, a fire sale on Russian raw materials and companies. Ultimately, economic subjection to China and atrocities in Ukraine.
- hutzlibu 5y ago"He can't climb down from the military debacle without getting overthrown" You name it: this is a very possible outcome. Putin is only the tsar, as long he is succesful. The russian oligarchy is likely not happy about the state of things. And it would be hard to unwind things, but without Putin new diplomatic solutions might be possible.
- recuter 5y agoThe Russian oligarchy is of no consequence these days, he has spent 25 years consolidating power. A popular uprising is the only chance of Putin not dying on the throne and that doesn't appear to be happening. The protests now are a fraction of what they were last year for Navalny. In retrospect that was probably his dry run. Weeks into this the majority of the Russian population either supports this "special operation" or is too scared to say anything. Same difference, this is the new normal for them just like the good old days.
- narrator 5y agoOften times there's a lot of controversy about if a leader is really in charge, or if they are merely a figurehead for some group of masterminds behind the scenes. The thing I like about studying Russia under Stalin is that Stalin was the one actually in charge. More than any other leader of the 19th or 20th century, he held the whole thing together almost singlehandedly. He had to because he got rid of people so regularly that there was no one else who had been there long enough to even know how to run things. The other interesting thing about studying Stalin is that very few people liked him enough to hide his dirty laundry after he died. There are very few secrets about him and all the little awful details of his life are freely available to his biographers.
- hutzlibu 5y ago"The other interesting thing about studying Stalin is that very few people liked him enough to hide his dirty laundry after he died." I think that comes naturally, if everyone important around him, had to fear for their life for years. One wrong look, or just one bad mood of the great leader - and someone gone again. They never knew what to expect, when being summoned, praise or prison - and that was intentional. Absolute power. Reign of terror. And always in paranoid fear, of a plot against the great leader. I think there was a great relief in the inner circles, with his death.
- narrator 5y agoMikoyan, the guy who started the aircraft design bureau, was the only one in Stalin's inner circle to stay there the whole time, not get executed and have a good career in the next administration after Stalin died. He was the ultimate political survivor.
- sn41 5y ago"The First Circle" by Solzhenitzyn is a great read. The caricature of Stalin in that book is absurd, I am not talking about that. There is a historical character Abakumov [1], and in one of his reflections, (from my memory) he rues the fact that he was inducted into the inner circle of Stalin. One moment of displeasure, and he could be gone. And there is no way out of the inner circle other than perhaps, death. A truly frightening, strangling, situation. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Abakumov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Abakumov
- VictorPath 5y ago> Stalin foreign policy (not unlike Chamberlains) was to pull Germany to his side Sort of. Prior to 1933 was the Third Period where the Comintern was antagonistic in Germany even to socialists ("social fascists"). From 1934 to the end of 1938 the USSR was looking for a self-defense pact with France, or the UK, neither country of which was interested (Blum in France was not for complex reasons). In 1939 the USSR and Germany signed a peace treaty, which Germany would break within two years, but it gave the Soviet Union enough time to prepare for invasion. Also Germany having a western front helped the Soviet Union. Stalin was initially unsupportive of Lenin's plan for a socialist government in Russia in 1917. Then again, neither were most Bolsheviks. Lenin did not have global goals with himself at the center, and Stalin's goals were even more modest. Of course they made the most of whatever foreign good will they had.
- bnralt 5y agoIndeed, it's worth pointing out that the Soviet Union offered to defend Czechoslovakia from Germany in 1938, but other countries opposed this. In general, I get the impression that European powers in the 1930's couldn't make up their mind between countering Germany or countering the Soviet Union.
- panick21_ 5y agoWell they didn't just 'offer' that for nothing. This had conditions attached. And would have basically used it to take much of eastern Europe.
- barry-cotter 5y agoEvil or Evil? Which do you choose?
- panick21_ 5y agoStarting from the Treaty of Rapallo in 1922 there was cooperation between Germany and Soviets. Recent archival research has reviled that this cooperation was far deep then initially assumed. Until a short while ago we mostly looked at diplomatic treaties. However the reality is, German Army was basically operating as a shadow government in Germany and they very intensively interact with Russia on a massive scale. There certainty were rough patches in the relationship and the didn't like each other, but strategically from 1922 on Russia was mostly supportive of Germany. And of course Stalin hated the SPD and he thought they were more dangerous then the Rightists. But that doesn't mean that the core relationship was always that Germany had to be support as long as they were aggressive towards the other 'capitalist powers'. > France, or the UK, neither country of which was interested They were interested. But the cost of such an agreement was basically to give Stalin power over pretty much all of Eastern and Southern Europe. And such an agreement would only have been a tool in Stalin attempt to create war between France and Germany that he could stay out off. The French were very suspicious of Soviet intentions (far more so then they used to be of Imperial Russia) and that is why the French never came even close to such an agreement. > In 1939 the USSR and Germany signed a peace treaty, which Germany would break within two years, but it gave the Soviet Union enough time to prepare for invasion. Also Germany having a western front helped the Soviet Union. Yeah sure it helped that Germany spent resources fighting Britain. But not getting invaded by 1.5 million Germans at all would have helped far more. The reality is, Germany can't invaded Soviet Union without Soviet Union or Britain support. They likely couldn't even have invaded France without Soviet Support. So had Stalin adopted a different strategy, Germany would have never seriously invaded the Soviet Union. > Lenin did not have global goals with himself at the center Sure. Until the moment he has the option to be. > Stalin's goals were even more modest No they weren't. Both of their goals was global revolution and Soviet Leadership of global communism.