4 ms·
I've been pondering carpool lanes and wonder why we have them at all. - they are very unsafe. pretty much danger is proportional to the speed difference betwe
by m463 5y ago
I've been pondering carpool lanes and wonder why we have them at all.
- they are very unsafe. pretty much danger is proportional to the speed difference between stopped traffic and the carpool lane.
- people pay extremely high taxes to use the roads in the first place, why monetize further?
- just opening the lane would decrease congestion for everyone
- all that new infrastructure to track and charge people costs money, how much overhead is there?
- lkbm 5y ago> - people pay extremely high taxes to use the roads in the first place, why monetize further? Monetize further = reduce needed taxes. > - just opening the lane would decrease congestion for everyone This is true iff they don't incentivize carpooling.
- matthewfcarlson 5y agoI think carpool lanes are for public transportation. We just don’t have have volume to justify a whole lane so we let in other yahoos. It makes a huge diffidence in Seattle knowing the bus takes an hour and driving by myself would take an hour and a half. However, if I paid 15$ in tolls I could get there in 30 minutes.
- vgel 5y ago> It makes a huge diffidence in Seattle knowing the bus takes an hour and driving by myself would take an hour and a half. Where in Seattle is that true? I used to take the bus all the time before I got a car, but now it's hard to justify since the bus is usually 1.5-2x longer than by car... For example from my apartment to Pike Place Market, Google Maps currently estimates 20 minutes by car and 37 minutes (if you don't miss any transfers!) by bus.
- uoaei 5y ago> just opening the lane would decrease congestion for everyone Adding lanes adds demand, and you get just as much (usually more!) congestion as before.
- anonymousiam 5y agoReducing lanes does not reduce demand, it just reduces transportation options and increases costs, indirectly damaging the economy. The passengers are trading time for money in the sense that a single car/van/bus is more cost efficient, but takes more time per passenger. It's true that some work can be done while on the road, but it's not a great work environment. Also, it's not always possible to align the schedules of all passengers.
- nwallin 5y ago> Adding lanes adds demand, The demand is constant and does not change. You can only shuffle it around. You have a few choices: 1. Add lanes. This gives people the option to move to the suburbs with a long commute. 2. Build housing in urban areas. This gives people the option to live close to work without a commute. 3. Add public transportation connects the suburbs to the cities. 4. Massive homeless problem. This is because people cannot commute from the suburbs and cannot pay rent in the cities. The government has the power to add lanes at the expense of smaller, more dangerous shoulders and medians. But the ability to add lanes only extends as far as the shoulders. For the most part, California has run out of shoulder in urban areas. The government does not have the power to build housing because of NIMBYs. Buses don't solve the problem of commuting between the suburbs and the cities. If you have to sit in traffic anyway, people will sit in traffic in their car. The government doesn't have the power to build light rail because that means tearing town existing structures, and again -- NIMBYs. So massive homeless problem it is.
- uoaei 5y agoDemand is not constant. Demand fluctuates relative to amenities, jobs, goods, services available on either end of a thoroughfare. If people like the offerings in one metro area vs another, or in a suburb vs a larger city, more people travel to and from that place. If they have things they want to do in their own backyard, they do not do that. The distribution of all of those things changes over time because of course it does. Thus the law of conservation of traffic flux is violated and none of your conclusions are sound. Sure sounds like public transit design is a red herring, no? :o)
- 5y ago
- bduerst 5y agoSeveral of your questions can be answered here on the San Mateo county page: https://ccag.ca.gov/us-101-express-lanes-project/ https://ccag.ca.gov/us-101-express-lanes-project/ There's an effect called induced demand where adding more free lanes to a road actually increases congestion, not decrease. Traffic engineers in the bay area have studied this and found it would be the effect if they just opened the HOV lanes up to all traffic. A toll expressway allows for relieving congestion on normal lanes without increasing road demand, and will pay for itself over time.
- anonymousiam 5y agoThis sounds like the same sort of silly logic that claims a "road diet" will reduce traffic. Lots of California cities are reducing the number of traffic lanes for no sane reason.
- jrockway 5y agoUnfortunately it's hard data and not silly logic. I get the complaint, "we'll make roads worse to get cars to use them less". If it takes 1 minute to drive to the grocery store but 15 minutes to walk, nobody is ever going to walk. If it takes 15 minutes to drive and 15 minutes to walk, though, people will start walking. The problem with adding lanes to roads is not that people want you to work out instead of sitting in your car. Nobody really cares. The problems is that it doesn't scale, there isn't space to add enough lanes to get everyone into a car. Additional lanes come at the cost of making the road less suitable for walking and biking, further pushing people into their cars unnecessarily. Hence road diets; use expensive urban land for something other than holding slow-moving cars for 3 hours a day. Car-centric suburbs were an interesting experiment that didn't work out. Unfortunately, half of America owns equity in the failed experiment, so it's going to be a rough couple decades while we adjust to something more sustainable. (Self-driving electric cars aren't going to save them.)
- listenallyall 5y agoLol. Not only have they worked out, but virtually every developing country is building their own suburbs. Is traffic an annoying inconvenience, sure. But I (and most people) love the freedom, the space, the variety granted by a car out in the burbs rather than being stuck in a cramped, super-expensive, single-window box in a city somewhere, and relying on public transportation to get anywhere beyond 10 blocks. Been there, done that, for far too long.
- cortesoft 5y agoSo the entire (original) purpose of carpool lanes is to reduce the number of cars on the road. The idea is that if three people are driving in one car instead of in three separate cars, that is two less cars on the road. In aggregate, this should speed up the commute for everyone, even people who don't use the carpool lane. Sure, you are giving up a lane, but in return you are removing 3x the number of vehicles from the remaining lanes for every car in the carpool lane. As for your speed difference issue, at least in Southern California, the carpool lane has a double yellow separating it from the regular lanes, hopefully giving some added safety since cars shouldn't move back and forth except at designated entry and exit sections. A lot of people think the purpose is to reduce pollution from the cars removed from the road (i.e. only one car's pollution instead of three), but in reality it should reduce pollution even MORE than that (because fewer cars on the road means everyone can drive faster, reducing the time spent with your car polluting while stuck in traffic). However, they messed this up by adding these other ways to drive in the carpool lane. Sure, an electric vehicle pollutes less, but letting them drive in the carpool lane eliminates the benefit of fewer cars on the road; three electric vehicles still take up the same amount of space on the road and cause the same traffic as three gas guzzlers. Then they added paying a toll, which does nothing to reduce pollution at all, and is simply a way to generate revenue. This is completely counter to the original purpose. So if they stuck to the original idea, I think it is worthwhile. In the original form, converting the carpool lane to a regular lane would not actually reduce the congestion for everyone, because while you are adding a lane, you are also increasing the number of cars on the road (of course there are a lot of factors that go into this... how many cars would carpool anyway, and how many cars are using the carpool lane at any one time). Here in Southern California, however, the carpool lanes are almost pointless. During high traffic times, they are just as congested as the regular lanes. In fact, they are often times slower than the regular lanes when congestion is medium... since they are only one lane and you can't switch lanes during most sections, you can end up with one slower car holding back everyone.
- CalRobert 5y agoA monetized lane is a godsend when you're late and need to get where you're going as fast as possible.