3 ms·
These three can in fact be all true at once, so the arguments are consistent, unlike kettle logic. "Didn't mean to pull the trigger" does not imply the defenda
by danuker 5y ago
These three can in fact be all true at once, so the arguments are consistent, unlike kettle logic.
"Didn't mean to pull the trigger" does not imply the defendant could pull the trigger.
- ambrozk 5y agoThe three incompatible scenarios are: 1. The accused was nowhere near the scene of the murder 2. The accused was at the scene of the murder, and in fact committed the murder, but on accident 3. The accused committed the murder on purpose, because the victim had it coming.
- danuker 5y agoI got the joke. But it is arguable whether the wording implies "the accused was at the scene of the murder" or "the accused committed the murder on purpose".