3 ms·
Vigilante warfare is very dangerous. What happens when there is a ceasefire or peace agreement, and some vigilante violates it? What if a vigilante unwittingly
by wolverine876 5y ago
Vigilante warfare is very dangerous. What happens when there is a ceasefire or peace agreement, and some vigilante violates it? What if a vigilante unwittingly interferes with an actual operation by their side (e.g., by exposing an exploit their side was using), or ignorantly destroys a resource the good guys needed? What happens if a vigilante crosses the line and conducts what the Russians think is an attack, requiring a military response? For example, what if a vigilante finds an exploit at a Russian nuclear weapons facility (maybe without even realizing what they are attacking)? NATO intelligence agencies can claim it wasn't them, but of course they would - why would the Russians believe that?
Warfare is coordinated, controlled violence, not indiscriminate violence. The vigilante stuff is very dangerous and probably achieves little. Leave it to the NSA, CIA, etc.
- eproxus 5y ago> Warfare is coordinated, controlled violence, not indiscriminate violence. I doubt Ukrainian civilians see it that way right now.
- lostmsu 5y agoThe NSA, the agency, that unlawfully collected my and yours private phone data?
- wolverine876 5y agoI agree about the problems, but who else?
- lostmsu 5y agoI think vigilantes are fine in this particular case.
- archagon 5y agoI don't think finger-wagging is going to stop determined hackers. This is something we will just have to accept in future wars.
- wolverine876 5y agoI don't know that anyone suggested finger-wagging, and there have always been independent actors in wars. Authorities can persuade vigilantes, including with some of the points I made above ('you don't want to be responsible for people - including allied soldiers or private citizens - dying'), deter them ('it's illegal, a threat to national security, and we'll prosecute you; also, you will never work professionally again', which will deter anyone with a family, serious career, etc.), co-opt them, and also not encourage them, which Zelensky did.
- archagon 5y agoZelensky wants his nation to survive at all costs.
- wolverine876 5y agoOf course. Desperation moves - like engaging vigilantes - do more harm to Zelensky's purpose than good; it's a signal of failing, panicked leadership (though most signals demostrate otherwise for Zelensky). For example, when engaging independent soldiers Zelensky did not engage them as vigilantes: the Ukrainian government requires volunteers to have prior military service, to serve in uniform in the Ukrainian military and under Ukrainian command, and to use weapons issued by the Ukrainian military. Zelensky didn't say, 'whoever wants to help, start shooting!'. It's a mistake to think that Internet cyber operations are different.