3 ms·
I'm not sure what failure to reliably discriminate between real pictures of people I don't know and therefore wouldn't be able to recognize and (what are basica
by pessimizer 5y ago
I'm not sure what failure to reliably discriminate between real pictures of people I don't know and therefore wouldn't be able to recognize and (what are basically composite) computer-generated people who don't exist is supposed to prove. Artists who can paint a picture of someone who doesn't exist that I can't tell from pictures of people who do exist, and I could probably piece together somebody who doesn't exist in photoshop from pieces of people who do.
Also, a weird-ass set of conclusions here:
> People are also excellent at incorporating context and background knowledge into their judgments in ways that computers mostly aren’t, and in ways that the sorts of tasks in these studies mostly don’t assess. One exception is a pair of deepfake videos of Vladimir Putin and Kim Jong-un included in the video study. People were much better than the model at classifying these videos. Whereas a majority of participants correctly spotted these fakes, the model was way off, highly confident that they were real.
> Here, people may have taken into account factors like their memories of previous statements made by these leaders, or knowledge of what their voices sound like, or the likelihood that they would say the sorts of things shown in the video: all things not included in the model at all.
Couldn't it just be because they were bad imitations of people they recognized? Isn't the entire ominous point of "deepfakes" to deceive people by presenting them with people the recognize doing things they didn't do? Looks like people still don't have a problem recognizing those as false.
The only good "deepfakes" I've seen are ones that have been extensively touched up manually, using the automatic part as raw material. New techniques have certainly made that a lot cheaper.