4 ms·
My sense is that conventional dietary wisdom comes from an agricultural heritage — where we spent all damn day working the fields. Without that intensive labor,
by JKCalhoun 5y ago
My sense is that conventional dietary wisdom comes from an agricultural heritage — where we spent all damn day working the fields. Without that intensive labor, three meals seems to make less sense.
- nicoburns 5y agoIndeed. I often skip breakfast without issues, but I once attempted to do this on a cycling holiday where my morning consisted of cycling at a moderate pace for several hours and I ended up collapsing asleep at the side of the road for about half an hour, then continued very slowly until I could find some food. What you're doing can have a big impact on how much food you need.
- cyberpunk 5y agoAh yes, a bonk. Horrible experience. Happened to me once or twice, I never actually slept, but I had to essentially walk the rest of the way back. Always carry some gels, and fuel up properly at the start!
- nicoburns 5y ago> Always carry some gels, and fuel up properly at the start! Yes, lesson learnt! A friend I was with actually realised they had glucose tablets with them for exactly this purpose, but unfortunately they didn't remember until past the time where they were needed.
- idontknowifican 5y agobonking for the first time is bizzare. i’ve been doing fat training because of sugar processing issues with the gels, and with focused effort and pacing i can bike through a bonk, but it is a delicate procedure
- sasawpg 5y agoIt is a lesson to be learned for sure! As my cycling ramps up so does my eating. I couldn't imagine surviving on anything less than 3 meals a day and copious snacking. Then again, I burn 6000-7000+kCal in a standard week of training which can be hard (for me) to replace. Your body will like you much more if you keep feeding it while riding!
- 01100011 5y agoI think you can train your body to deal with it. I used to hike a lot. I realized I felt a lot better while hiking if I didn't eat. I'd get up at say 5am, hike, and not need food until around noon before I bonked. It took work to get there. When I was younger, I'd get hypoglycemia if I didn't snack every hour or so. When I started hiking, I could go about an hour before I'd feel lightheaded. I got sick of it and started pushing through the wall. It was rough, then things started to change. After that, my eating habits changed even when I wasn't hiking. I got down to my ideal weight for the first time in my life at 40 years old. That weight and the shape I was in allowed me to meet my wife. Unfortunately we like to eat garbage and now I'm back where I started at 47. It was a healthy 5 years though.
- vidarh 5y agoIt was eye-opening once I started tracking my calorie intact and adjusting until I was in balance to realise just how far off typical dietary advice was for me. Especially as I was actively powerlifting at the time, and forums were full of advice about the massive amounts of food I "needed". UK NHS still say 2000kcal for women and 2500 for men, but for me after actually counting and tracking my weight at different intake, the balance was ~1800-2000 when exercising 5 times a week including 3x1 hour long weightlifting sessions. Of course for some men 2500 is fine, if you're actually active. But I've found most people overestimate how active they actually are because they do some sports outside of work. Without actually being in a physically demanding job, odds are you're not "active" in any meaningful sense (of course there are exceptions). 2500kcal was on the high end of my bulking intake when I wanted to add weight for my lifting.
- sasawpg 5y ago> Without actually being in a physically demanding job, odds are you're not "active" in any meaningful sense (of course there are exceptions). That's a curious conclusion. I and most others in my circle of friends are active in a meaningful sense, at least based on my definition of "meaningfully active". Most of us are in desk jobs, and none that I know have what I would define as a "physically demanding" job.
- vidarh 5y agoIn the context of calories burned, most people in office jobs will fit firmly within ranges usually given for sedentary people. It takes a lot of physical activity outside of working hours to make up for an office job. E.g. for me, an hour of high intensity exercise five days a week still placed me firmly in the sedentary range. Part of the issue is that we tend to "forget" about the hours spent at work when evaluating if we consider ourselves active.
- sasawpg 5y agoI haven't really looked at sedentary ranges, can you point me to the guideline you reference? Are they based on calories burned during an activity, amount of activity, time in HR zones? As for intensity exercises, unless you actually measure your activity it will be difficult to estimate exactly how much time you're active inside of your hour exercise. I would guess a lot of people will over-estimate how much active time they really had. For example, weight lifting would be on the low side, HIIT classes somewhere in the middle and running/rowing/cycling on the high side.
- rsync 5y agoI would go even further and suggest that most of the social ills we deal with in the United States are a slow, painful, halting transition from rural to urban life. These modes of living require very different heuristics and patterns and it’s not surprising that we encounter all manner of pathology as we transition.
- aYsY4dDQ2NrcNzA 5y agoWhen I was a teenager, my family went to a family reunion and stayed with some relatives who had a farm. They ate four meals a day.
- tails4e 5y agoDiet, and wisdom are hard to put in a sentence together with a straight face. It seems this area is fraught with misinformation and disinformation. We're told to eat small amounts regularly, were told to fast intermittently, we're told to avoid carbs and eat fats, avoid fat (OK that's old), calorie count, and calories don't really matter insulin does. It's very very confusing. Is the jury still out on this? is it too subjective? what is the reason that explains why if you ask 10 people you get 10 answers for what you should do to have a good diet and keep weight down?