4 ms·
Wouldn't this be a good thing? The money would come back into the US, and if the tax break isn't given then it won't be coming back. I'm as cynical about corpo
by nl 15y ago
Wouldn't this be a good thing? The money would come back into the US, and if the tax break isn't given then it won't be coming back.
I'm as cynical about corporations as anyone, but in this case.. they use 100% legal means to reduce their tax, behaving exactly how anyone would expect them.
Some argue that it is an ethical issue, but that neglects the fact that these companies make a large proportion of their profits offshore, and bringing that money gets taxed too. Ethics in this argument are much more subtle than some would have you believe.
- tomelders 15y agoThey use 100% legal means to keep money off shore. True. But then they ask for a Tax Holiday when that arrangement no longer suits them. One way or another, that money will return to the US, and the tax will be paid accordingly. This will happen over a long period of time. If the US allows this tax holiday to happen, it will be throwing away billions of dollars in the long term with no real short term advantage, whilst sending a very dangerous message to people who use tax avoidance as a long term fiscal strategy. It's corporate Americas job to make try and make the system work for them. It's the governments job to try and make the system work for everyone.
- nl 15y agoOne way or another, that money will return to the US, and the tax will be paid accordingly. See, that's where I disagree. All those companies can easily invest that money offshore, either in financial institutions or in building new facilities. Both seem to be worse outcomes for the US than this. To be clear: I don't believe in the "trickle down effect" - I think a progressive system is the only sensible one. BUT I do think any trickle down is better than nothing. sending a very dangerous message to people who use tax avoidance as a long term fiscal strategy It's not tax avoidance, it's tax minimization. There is a big difference. The message I see at the moment is "shift your profits and investment offshore, because it is cheaper". I'm not convinced that is beneficial. It's the governments job to try and make the system work for everyone. I agree with this completely.
- justincormack 15y agoOr they can invest it offshore by buying Skype, like Microsoft did. Some were saying that they were keen to buy as they couldnt repatriate the money.
- lsc 15y ago>It's not tax avoidance, it's tax minimization. There is a big difference. I thought "Tax avoidance" was the legal term for legally minimizing your tax burden, so "avoidance" and "minimization" would be largely synonymous. "Tax evasion" I thought, was the term for avoiding taxes through illegal means.
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoThe idea does have a downside as well. These recurring tax holidays amount to a selective corporation tax cut for large international corporations. Smaller domestic companies do not benefit from it. Wouldn't it be simpler, fairer and more effective to cut the corporation tax rate?
- lubos 15y agoIt's a bad thing because it would create dangerous precedence for the future when every rich corporation would start blackmailing US government as to avoid to pay their fair share of tax. this would hurt US economy far more in long-term, you don't want to encourage this practice Also, who cares about their trillion dollars... who gives guarantees this money will actually end up in national economy and not invested overseas with profits tied up in some off-shore country once again. if America needs more liquidity in economy, ring FED. they will print just as much.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- georgefox 15y agoNot really. They did the same thing in 2004, and it didn't do much of anything. And if we keep doing this every time big businesses push for it, they're only going to bring money back during predictable tax holidays. See http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/ezra-klein/post/the-worst-tax-cut-in-washington/2011/05/19/AGPE1xcH_blog.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/ezra-klein/post/the-wors....
- nl 15y agoYes, I did read the article, and I do understand the money mostly went straight into shareholder pockets. I don't have a great solution for that, but I would note: (a) The money is at least in the US, and (b) any dividend payments are (should be?) taxable.
- lawnchair_larry 15y agoWhy do you think they put it overseas in the first place? They've planned to take it back under these terms all along. They're betting on a tax holiday at some point. Exactly what they did in 2004. Give them this one, and rest assured, every company will take this bet and let the cash sit and rot until they can bring it back again. The backstory, and why this is a terrible idea: http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/blogs/taibblog/evil-corporate-tax-holiday-gains-bipartisan-support-20110726 http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/blogs/taibblog/evil-cor...