5 ms·
That's the main issue here; the EU mandated consent and gave guidelines on what that consent might look like, but they left implementation down to the industry,
by Cthulhu_ 5y ago
That's the main issue here; the EU mandated consent and gave guidelines on what that consent might look like, but they left implementation down to the industry, which decided to do it themselves (often using dark patterns, for which some companies already got fined) instead of integrating it in browsers.
I remember 20 odd years ago now when Firefox came out with a popup blocker standard, built-in. Whatever happened to this "we need to reduce annoyances on the internet" movement? Why aren't the browsers themselves doing more against it?
I mean I know that Chrome and Firefox won't block ads by default because it affects their bottom line (Chrome through Google ads, Firefox through Google money), but what about GDPR consent forms and newsletter sign-up popups?
- radicalbyte 5y agoGoogle funded two of the three big browsers. That does a lot to kill innovation.
- danuker 5y agoI suppose they're making us suffer so we pressure politicians.
- josefx 5y agoI wouldn't be surprised if Googles consent form intentionally broke every GDPR rule. First time I saw it it didn't bombard me with dark patterns, it sent me down a rabbit hole of near infinite options where I couldn't even tell if any of them where relevant for Google search. They don't want to give users a quick and easy way to opt out, especially not while they are still working on replacement APIs that use sleight of hand, confusing technobabble and a decent amount of hand waving to not only avoid GDPR restrictions but make your browser track you for them. This isn't just Google, Mozilla seems to have sold out to Meta and is working on its own tracking API.
- andylynch 5y agoYou're not alone. This is why the French fined Google EOR 150M in January* . NOYB have started a second round of complaints this month so expect more. * https://www.cnil.fr/en/cookies-google-fined-150-million-euros https://www.cnil.fr/en/cookies-google-fined-150-million-euro...
- bodge5000 5y agoFacebooks (or I guess Meta, I noticed it on the Occulus website) approach is the worst I've seen, with no clear way to decline. At least google and the others give you the option, they just make you do a load of work for it (and then at the end present you with a blue "accept all" button and a grey "accept selected" button), Facebook literally just gives you an accept all button and, if I recall correctly, a small hyperlink to view their policy in which you have the option to go through all the settings and decline.
- ratww 5y ago> I remember 20 odd years ago now when Firefox came out with a popup blocker standard, built-in. Whatever happened to this "we need to reduce annoyances on the internet" movement? Why aren't the browsers themselves doing more against it? There was Do-Not-Track, but the industry decided it shouldn't be respected.
- MereInterest 5y agoI would love for an update to GDPR, stating that any automated form of refusal for consent, including the Do-Not-Track header, must be treated as an explicit refusal and may not result in additional requests.
- ratww 5y agoThat's a great idea and would be an amazing next step. Do-Not-Track can already be honoured by website operators. The issue is just that they choose not to do it.
- MiddleEndian 5y agoDo Not Track was always a joke. Without any legal teeth, why would people determined to spy on you stop spying on you because you say "Please"?
- ratww 5y agoGDPR for example gives it teeth. Grandparent post asked for a technical solution to hide cookie banners forever. A websites don't have to show any cookie banner whatsoever if they honor Do-Not-Track. If they don't show a banner but still track, they're breaking the law. The problem of cookie banners is easy to solve. All that's lacking is honesty from adware vendors and website operators.