3 ms·
> Let's assume that only a third of the 300 million vehicles convert to electric power in, say, 25 years. That means we need to increase our generation capacity
by vel0city 5y ago
> Let's assume that only a third of the 300 million vehicles convert to electric power in, say, 25 years. That means we need to increase our generation capacity by about 400 GW.
Can you point me to the actual math and not just a YouTube video of a guy habitually wrong about technology and talk of a spreadsheet model of probably inaccurate usages which really claims such needs? Because in practice I've got an EV in my garage tonight which doesn't increase our overall power demands at all. In fact, it's only finally using the negative generation costs that we've had in my area for years. That's right, right now as my EV charges the wholesale cost of energy in my area is negative USD. There's not enough load to meet the generation demand! My retail provider is making money buying power at negative cost on me charging my car at the moment. Adding more cars charging right now would only bring balance to that mismatch of generation to demand, not overload demand at all.
The model you've mentioned above has a lot of questionable assumptions baked into it. It didn't take a new transformer for my home to support an EV, nor my neighbor, nor the person next door to them. So when thinking of vehicles, and especially not miles or per pound of payload delivered, it's really not that crazy.
Please feel free to share your magical spreadsheet model which explains everything. I'd love to see it. It sounds like it makes a lot of assumptions which may or may not be realistic. But until you share that I'm going by my actual use cases I've actually seen in person with EVs, where it didn't increase my peak power at all, and between myself and my neighbors was absorbed by the grids capacity without any issue at all.
So let's take your example of building out a model based on usage I've actually experienced. How much peak load has my EV actually added to my home's usage? 0 additional kW peak? Cool, so we extrapolate that to all the other single family houses, so we can easily add over 15 million EVs to our fleet before we even need to upgrade a single line. Given we've only managed to produce a few hundred thousand EVs in several years it'll probably take many decades before we even each that 15 million figure, so we're probably fine to slowly roll out upgrades to our grid if we're really only targeting upgrading commuter vehicles at the moment.
- robomartin 5y ago> Please feel free to share your magical spreadsheet model which explains everything. And that is precisely how to put a violent end to an otherwise cordial conversation.