4 ms·
> a full migration to electrics is absolutely impossible I'm definitely not one to argue the full migration to electrics. As mentioned elsewhere I think diesel
by vel0city 5y ago
> a full migration to electrics is absolutely impossible
I'm definitely not one to argue the full migration to electrics. As mentioned elsewhere I think diesel/petrol/similar kind of fuel vehicles will be around in at least some capacity for quite some time. Its incredibly energy dense and the ability to just pump up gallons of it from pits in the ground is quite handy.
> Some would be hybrid: plug in at home every night and top-off with fast chargers during the week as needed.
I really can't imagine this would make up any large fraction of the EV fleet. If someone can charge from home, the extreme majority of their charging will be overnight or potentially during a weekend if they need to do some catch up. The vast majority of commute cars which can charge at home will not need this hybrid approach save for the extremely rare long road trip when comparing the total number of miles.
> percentage of the population would only drive 20 miles a day and would be happy slow charging over eight hours
That 20mi commute would generally use ~6kWh. Over 8 hours, that's 750W of power. During a time where power at people's homes is often at its lowest point. Delivering that power would barely be a blip. If our grid collapses because a few million people plug in a tiny 750W space heater overnight we've got some serious problems.
> If you feel you still need to argue against my claim that we need to double power generation and infrastructure, you need to argue against Elon Musk
I would, especially when it comes to long-haul trucks. Arguing against Elon is then easy in this regard, where's the long-haul driverless trucks which were going to revolutionize the entire trucking industry in 2017? EVs in this kind of capacity don't make sense without massive changes not only to the grid but also to our battery technology. Just making the batteries a little fatter isn't going to change the math on these kinds kinds of trucks. So you should pretty much just completely eliminate these kinds of vehicles from your model, its a moonshot to even think these kinds of things are really going to switch to EV-only anytime soon for many reasons.
I don't doubt we'll need to make a lot of changes to our grid. I agree it will take a lot of energy to make those changes and it will use a lot of petroleum based products to make those changes. There's oil in practically everything we touch, so I agree its short sighted to praise the idea of expensive oil. I also agree this won't be something that happens overnight, it'll be something that will take an effort over decades.
I agree moving to EVs is overly praised and there's quite a cult mindset of if we just put an EV in every garage we'll have solved some big problem. As you mentioned its often a question of power, and well at least down here in Texas overnight we often get to the point where there's not even enough load to match the generation available for free. On many grids there's already a good bit of slack in the power distribution in off-peak times, probably enough to support every average commuter car in every single family household. Note that term, average commuter car. Not the people which somehow are still sane after a 100+mi daily commute, they're extreme outliers and yeah it will probably take a lot of work to get to the point where all of those people are reasonably served with EVs.
I think there's a bit of a disconnect between us here. You're arguing about the full migration to EVs, while I mostly agree a full migration to EVs isn't really practical anytime soon. While a large part of the average commuter car and short haul vans can probably make the switch to EVs today, it seems there are plenty of use cases where EVs are still impractical vehicles. This is before even figuring in your grid arguments. So once you then eliminate those vehicles where EVs are currently a somewhat impractical case at the moment, the math of how reasonable grid upgrades get becomes a much more practical number.
Also, FWIW I do agree there will need to be some amount of an upgrade to the grid, and it will probably be a large one. Shifting all that energy which used to be handled by fluids running through pipes into cables overhead will inherently mean some amount of capacity upgrades. However, I think for average commuter cars, this really won't be that much of an impact. There are definitely cases where there will need to be a large change (DCFC corridors) but I doubt the average suburb would need some radical change. Its just adding load to a time of day that routinely experienced its lull.
- robomartin 5y ago> If our grid collapses because a few million people plug in a tiny 750W space heater overnight we've got some serious problems. Again, if you want to understand this well, I urge you to stop and create your own simulation model. This can be done in Excel. The point is that it is very easy to make statements such as your when one does not make an attempt to actually model reality and see what this might mean. When you do (if you do) I assure you there will be an "Oh. That's what he was talking about." moment. I very much understand that a full migration to EV's isn't likely to be possible for perhaps as long as fifty years, if not more. Yet, that's not the point here. What we are being asked to do to this nation and the world is motivated by the delusion of clean energy and pink unicorns. They are selling this delusion as if it were reality. It is not. Let's assume that only a third of the 300 million vehicles convert to electric power in, say, 25 years. That means we need to increase our generation capacity by about 400 GW. For context, that means 400 nuclear power plants, each operating at 1 GW. I use nuclear power plants because this is a good measure of the scale of things as well as the impossibility of achieving such a goal in just 25 years. We can't build one in 25 years, much less 400 of them. Even worse, the power distribution system, the "grid", would have to be rebuilt to at least double, if not triple, its power transport capacity. This due to a few realities, one of them being that you have to build it for present (once the upgraded version goes online) peak demand as well as future requirements. To be clear, I am not proposing that going electric is a bad idea or that we should not do it. In a very much for the transition. What I am saying is that the delusion we are selling does not describe a path to a reality where even one third of vehicles can be electrified. In order to get there we have to abandon ideology and focus on math and science. Then we can plan a path that will get us there. Whatever "there" means, whether that is 25% electrics or 75%. We can't get there without a stop to all this ideological nonsense. The perfect example of this is the insanity of our current oil production policies. Here in the US, the current government is doing all it can to kill our oil production and processing infrastructure. They hate it. Ideologically. They just hate it. Irrationally. Because they have all bought into the delusion. What's reality? Well, if we want, say, 25% of our vehicles to go electric in 25 years, we have a massive job ahead of us. We have to build a massive amount of additional power generation capacity. We have to execute a decidedly non-trivial upgrade of our entire power delivery infrastructure. We have to build somewhere between 50K and 100K charging stations throughout the nation. We have to manufacture batteries, solar panels, cables and all the materials and components that go into such systems. We also have to build nuclear power plants faster than ever in history. And more. I can't possibly list all the dependencies in the tree that leads to being ready for 25% of our vehicles becoming electrics. Not to mention actually manufacturing the vehicles. What do we need in order to accomplish the above? Cheap oil. What I mean by "cheap" is $20 oil, rather than $130 per barrel. Why? Because EVERYTHING we will have to make, move, install, manufacture requires oil. Everything. You can't build a power plant without a massive amount of fuel. The cables that move the electricity? You can't make them without oil. You can't install them without oil. Manufacturing parts, and structural materials (beams, etc.) out of steel and aluminum? You can't do it without oil. Plastics, electronic components, microprocessors, displays, computers, motors, car bodies, etc. Everything is based on industrial processes that depend on oil. Humanity cannot exist in its current form without oil. And so, the paradox here is that, if we want a future where ground transportation is significantly less dependent on petroleum, we have to make petroleum as cheap as possible for somewhere around twenty five years, if not more. Only after making that kind of a monumental effort will we be able to start detaching from oil. We can't get there from here because, at $100+ per barrel these projects become insanely expensive and likely unattainable. We need a real plan of action based on real math and science. And then we do everything we must do to make it happen. We have to leave this delusion behind us in order to move forward. If we don't, electric vehicles will be doomed to being an oddity for decades upon decades.