5 ms·
When will Amazon executives be arrested? The way to deal with this is to arrest a whole group of Amazon execs, and offer the usual deal - the first one to make
by Animats 5y ago
When will Amazon executives be arrested?
The way to deal with this is to arrest a whole group of Amazon execs, and offer the usual deal - the first one to make a full confession and implicate others gets off, the others get prosecuted. This is official DOJ policy.[1]
[1] https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/sometimes-confession-is-good-for-the-83824/ https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/sometimes-confession-is-go...
- nathanyz 5y agoAgreed, nothing sort of holding executives accountable with actual threat of prison time fixes this. Fines don’t matter once you are the winner in the market. Have to set an example and stop individuals from feeling safe when lying for companies.
- nickff 5y agoFines against individuals, with a prohibition on further compensation/employment by the company/organization would likely be sufficient to discourage this behavior. There is widespread disagreement as to whether prison should be used as a punitive tool, and it would serve no other purpose in a case like this. Corporate fines seem ineffective and almost useless , especially because these sorts of actions will often benefit the individuals undertaking them (principal agent problem). I suspect the motivation behind corporate fines is that they can be large monetary amounts, and look good for the investigator/agent/attorney.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- onemoresoop 5y agoThey could game that and take turns when they want to retire. Fines are not enough. Prison time would make a better deterrent.
- nickff 5y agoPaying a huge fine will likely disrupt a retirement plan.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- trillic 5y agoNot if the company pays it.
- nickff 5y ago>"Not if the company pays it. " That's why I included the "... prohibition on further compensation/employment by the company/organization...".
- bogwog 5y agoPeople gamble money all the time, even when the odds are terrible. Less people are willing to gamble their lives. The threat of prison is more effective than the threat of losing some money.
- nickff 5y ago>"Less people are willing to gamble their lives. The threat of prison is more effective than the threat of losing some money." Since you brought it up... reductio ad absurdum: The threat of execution is even effective than prison, shouldn't we 'spring for' that instead? As per my sibling comment: I think that a fine which meaningfully reduces an individual's means is possible, and preferable to using prison sentences to instill fear. My view is that the extreme sentences provided for in legislation are causing many non-guilty people to plead to lesser offenses, which is a real problem. I also think that we shouldn't be crowding jails and prisons with people who have committed civil offenses.
- salawat 5y ago
- bostonsre 5y agoGoing to jail is a lot scarier than getting a bonus clawed back and losing your job when you have enough to retire on already. Personal fines and no prison time just tweak the risk/reward calculation a little bit. These executives make a lot of money, and I would guess if they are the type to do illegal behavior they wouldn't mind gambling if the reward is great enough. I could even see it making this behavior more likely to happen if it's clear that they won't go to jail for illegal behavior and all they have to worry about is a fine and losing their job.
- nickff 5y ago>"Going to jail is a lot scarier than getting a bonus clawed back and losing your job when you have enough to retire on already." Reductio ad absurdum: Getting executed is even scarier than prison, shouldn't we 'spring for' that instead? I think that a fine which meaningfully reduces an individual's means is possible, and preferable to using prison sentences to instill fear. My view is that the extreme sentences provided for in legislation are causing many non-guilty people to plead to lesser offenses, which is a real problem. I also think that we shouldn't be crowding jails and prisons with people who have committed civil offenses. What do you believe prison is for? Do you think it works?
- justinpowers 5y agoI’d agree if I believed they could/would take money out of their retirement accounts and somehow disallow benefitting from trusts, but that seems highly unlikely. Prison time allows for disincentivizing as well as rehabilitation. Death sentence on the other hand… Perhaps part of the problem are our prison conditions. And the minimal effort directed towards true rehabilitation. Fixing those might make prison time less ethically fraught.
- bostonsre 5y agoThe deterrent has to be enough of a deterrent to actually deter people, else it's a negligible downside risk (like a slap on the wrist fine and job loss for this case). Yes, execution would certainly put a stop to this behavior, even more so than jail time (and could also help with prison overcrowding), but I think to err is human and execution is a little too extreme and would cause society to be unhappy and scared. Yes, I think there are a lot of extreme prison sentences in this country and we incarcerate way too many people. But I think it is ridiculous to be so lopsided with punishments and only put people without means in jail. White collar crimes like this one have a larger negative impact on society than some guy caught stealing a car and they should not get off with a slap on the wrist. I don't think prison is for rehabilitation. Some humans act incredibly selfishly and if there are no consequences to bad actions, they will act selfishly and they will have a negative impact on society. Law enforcement and criminal justice is a balancing act with no perfect right answer. It is not tenable to be too far on either end of the spectrum and I think we need to try to strike that balance where crime is deterred enough but where we don't live in a police state dystopia that causes a depressed and miserable society. I don't really know where that point is, but I am all for equitable punishment of white collar criminals.
- onion2k 5y agoI can think of something that would work. If Amazon is found guilty of abusing it's the data it's trusted witb, for anything, the entire company should be banned from doing business with the government. No government purchases of goods, no services hosted on AWS, no logistics provided by Amazon's last mile services, etc. If Amazon are shown to be abusing data then they shouldn't be allowed to have any public data. Maybe even extend that to all government suppliers...
- 88840-8855 5y agoI agree.
- encryptluks2 5y agoIsn't that considered illegal as well, to arrest people without enough evidence and then demand they admit guilt to be released? I can see how this would hurt a case more than it would help one. Imagine if there is a jury trial and it comes out that people were forced to make confessions under duress.
- ruined 5y agoyou only need evidence at trial. cops and prosecutors coerce people into pleading guilty without any evidence every day.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 5y ago> you only need evidence at trial. False. > before then, cops and the prosecutor only need "probable cause" which is typically understood to allow that evidence may be gathered later. No, it isn't; probable cause must be based in evidence. For cases requiring indictment, this evidence is presented to a grand jury before charges can formally be filed; for cases where the conditions allowing warrantless arrest do not apply, it occurs in the presentation of evidence to support an arrest warrant; for other cases the evaluation (by hearing or otherwise) happens generally within 48 hours of arrest, and delay to gather evidence has specifically been ruled unconstitutional.
- ruined 5y agoah, you sniped my edit. there are a lot of details that vary state by state, but i'll say that not all charges require a grand jury, and 48 hours is clearly "later"
- Animats 5y agoIt's not hard to show probable cause. The issue in most corporate crime is not "did it happen", but "who knew about it" and "who authorized it". Prosecutors, to get an indictment, only have to show it happened, and that the people being prosecuted probably knew what was going on, or should have known. Sorting out exactly who said and did what when when comes out later.
- deutschew 5y agoNot when there are political ramifications to the beneficiaries of Amazon's generous "donations"
- chagaif 5y agoAren't they more afraid of violence and threats from the other execs? I would think that some violent threats are not off the table when there's so much on the line (jail time) and so much money involved.
- decebalus1 5y ago> Aren't they more afraid of violence and threats from the other execs? Is Amazon Cosa Nostra nowadays? I find it hard to believe they'd be more scared of other execs than the government..
- spaetzleesser 5y agoI think the DOJ and other agencies are way too addicted to getting fines. I don't think they want to interrupt that cashflow by actually going after people.
- vmception 5y agoThat's probably happening too but the bigger perverse incentive is that they don't want to actually debilitate market leading companies to ensure the monopoly of the remaining companies. It mostly just lacks inspiration.
- markdown 5y ago> This is official DOJ policy. * for poor people.
- la64710 5y ago
- IncandescentGas 5y ago> he first one to make a full confession and implicate others gets off, the others get prosecuted. This is how you get false confessions and wrongful convictions. Especially for conspiracy where burden of proof is he-said/she-said
- vkou 5y agoThe burden of proof in cases like this is actually carried by the mountains of emails, product design documents, and all other forms of internal documentation. Only the e-mails get regularly purged. This isn't a dope dealer growing weed in his car and having his buddies sell it for him. These sorts of operations produce a lot of paperwork. As an employee who is actually tasked with building/working with all of these systems/processess, you don't get inducted into the secret conspiracy with a nod, wink, handshake, and a secret decoder ring.