4 ms·
For context, McCarthy has been at the Santa Fe Institute since 2014 [1], and so in residence among accomplished scientists conducting serious research. For near
by brudgers 5y ago
For context, McCarthy has been at the Santa Fe Institute since 2014 [1], and so in residence among accomplished scientists conducting serious research. For nearly a decade, McCarthy's day job has been writer among scientists.
Which is to say, McCarthy doesn't merely have an opinion. McCarthy has an informed opinion. He's spent more time among better scientists than most people in the sciences. And of course, he's a better writer than just about anyone giving advice about science writing (and writing in general).
Most writing advice targets poor writers. McCarthy essay targets good writers. Maybe because good writers are good not just for technique but for having interesting things to say. Maybe because something not worth writing in an engaging way probably isn't worth writing.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santa_Fe_Institute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santa_Fe_Institute
- YeGoblynQueenne 5y agoYes, yes, I get it. Who am I to challegne an authority in scientific writing, that has so many scientist friends to boot. And what do I know about writing anyway, I don't even have a single best-seller under my belt. Clearly, challenging authorities is not the way of a true scientist.
- openknot 5y agoThough I see your point (that it's good practice to assess logical arguments independent of an author's credentials), brudgers's comment was still quite useful. I skimmed the comments before deciding to reading the article, and likely would have skipped on this submission if I didn't know about his work at Santa Fe (which was also mentioned in the article itself), as I associate McCarthy with his literary work. I had no previous awareness he has been working with scientists on technical writing.
- brudgers 5y agoMy point is that McCarthy has an expert opinion and is writing for people who are not struggling toward a first scientific journal publication. The advice that makes a poor writer acceptable differs from what makes a good writer better.
- YeGoblynQueenne 5y ago>> My point is that McCarthy has an expert opinion and is writing for people who are not struggling toward a first scientific journal publication. I don't understand what you mean. Do you mean that in the context of the article? Are you saying that the article above is aimed at people with some experience of writing? By the way, your original comment came across as a haughty attempt at a put-down by an appeal to authority, hence my reaction to it. My apologies if I misunderstood your intent.
- tptacek 5y agoYes, that's what he's saying. Scientists at the Santa Fe Institute tend already to have been published, since that's how you get to be a scientist at SFI. I didn't read their original comment as a put-down of any sort, for whatever that's worth to you. If you jump into an article like this just getting to the tips (a reasonable thing to do!) you might miss the fact that McCarthy has the expertise to back up what he's saying (and, for that matter, miss the audience of his tips, as you might have).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- YeGoblynQueenne 5y agoAnd now you're assuming I didn't read the article. Well done. I've read it, twice, once yesterday and once when it was posted on HN previously a while ago, when I made the same comment about that particular suggestion at the top of the thread. And you're trying to pull rank via proxy on me. I have the expertise to back up what I'm saying also. See my comment at the top.
- tptacek 5y agoThere's nothing personal about any of this. I don't even know who you are. But: your "rank" here is that you've taken a course in academic writing and gotten some journal articles accepted, and McCarthy's "rank" is that he's one of the greatest writers of the last 50 years and is in a kind of residency copyediting papers for the Santa Fe Institute. I'd take him seriously. But you do you.
- softwarebeware 5y agoSeriously! Reminds me of the famous story of an undergrad who used a text by Richard Feynman as a source for a college paper, and was graded down by her professor. She then contacted Feynman to obtain justification, but Feynman replied: "Your instructor was right not to give you any points, for your answer was wrong, as he demonstrated using Gauss’ law. You should, in science, believe logic and arguments, carefully drawn, and not authorities." https://www.wm.edu/news/stories/2020/feynmans-advice-to-wm-student-resonates-45-years-later.php https://www.wm.edu/news/stories/2020/feynmans-advice-to-wm-s...