3 ms·
One thing that I always thought would really help, which "senior developers" as a group seem to be largely against, would be a basic competency test like the me
by ryandrake 5y ago
One thing that I always thought would really help, which "senior developers" as a group seem to be largely against, would be a basic competency test like the medical board exam or law bar exam. Do it once, and demonstrate that you can know some minimum standard amount of knowledge and can do the bare minimum of software development. It wouldn't test every development skill out there. It wouldn't test particular language competency. It wouldn't test for business domain knowledge. And it would not replace the interview or prove that you were the right fit for any particular job. But it could weed out 90% of the fakers who literally cannot program or know nothing about software that all the hiring managers in these threads are complaining about. It would help to prevent our current mess where every company in the world has to waste time doing FizzBuzz again and again for every candidate.
I don't understand why we are against this basic, minimal gate. We have this unreasonable fear of regulation and gatekeeping in our profession, which is ultimately to everyone's collective detriment. I'm not calling for 20,000 pages of federal regulations on software engineering. A minimal gate. Nobody benefits from the current world where anyone with no knowledge or skills can simply claim to be a software engineer. Nobody except the fakers.
- tomc1985 5y agoWhile I'm also for some kind of standard competency, if it were an exam it would create a market for test-prep books that cover just the material and nothing else.
- JohnHaugeland 5y agothat market already exists
- MontyCarloHall 5y agoA certification scheme like this could work, but it would need to be regularly renewed (every 5 years?). Passing it a single time early in one’s career is no indication that coding proficiency still exists later in one’s career. In my experience, basic coding skills can really atrophy in senior developers who quit writing code years ago and are full-time architects/managers. I’ve interviewed more than a handful of highly accomplished people with decades of experience as developers and then engineering managers who couldn’t answer extremely basic coding questions (I’m not talking about Leetcode-esque BS, I mean stuff closer to FizzBuzz).
- ryandrake 5y agoI kind of like the system they have for pilots: 1. A major exam/hurdle at the very beginning (FAA checkride), and then 2. Basic proficiency checks every 24 months done by an instructor. Vary that period as appropriate for developers. You get the initial weed-out of people who have no business being developers, and then periodic checkpoints to make sure atrophy is not a concern.
- bmn__ 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27662804 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27662804