4 ms·
If they got decently paid, by allowing proprietary apps, one of the competing apps could stick around by virtue of actually making money. The ElementaryOS comp
by actionfromafar 5y ago
If they got decently paid, by allowing proprietary apps, one of the competing apps could stick around by virtue of actually making money.
The ElementaryOS company would also get more cash, and could, (like Apple!) improve a core set of apps.
A "kernel" of good quality Linux apps could also spread to other distributions, and hopefully slowly coalesce around GTK and "ElementaryOS" style GUI as a de-facto standard. (Since the other distros are more accepting of jumbled GUI styles anyway, why not make your app on ElementaryOS first, and distribute that version on the other Linux versions, too.)
Anyway, the hurdle is not technical - flatpaks or no flatpaks. The hurdle is strategy and ideology.
- gurkendoktor 5y agoI think that technical hurdles absolutely matter, even more so at the current scale of elementary. And offering apps that are neither sandboxed nor auditable sounds like a PR disaster waiting to happen once someone steals Bitcoin wallets. Thankfully, the kernel of apps that work across distributions is slowly coming together over at flathub, which is planning to add payment support: https://github.com/flathub/flathub/issues/680 https://github.com/flathub/flathub/issues/680 Even the KDE-based Steam Deck, on the opposite end of every spectrum from elementary, embraces flatpak (and flathub). It's exactly the piece of the puzzle that would have enabled what you suggest: write elementary-flavored apps, sell them everywhere. Given that elementary has already added the Sideload app, I'm not sure if they're as ideological about GTK FOSS purity as it sometimes seems.