5 ms·
I must have missed the post where a VC said "Guys, sorry, love your company but I couldn't in good conscience participate in a round where the rich people get p
by patio11 15y ago
I must have missed the post where a VC said "Guys, sorry, love your company but I couldn't in good conscience participate in a round where the rich people get paid and the poor people are told to wait for an exit." I must have missed that post quite frequently, because that describes every VC round ever.
A $120 million investment round means that about $2.4 million in cash money just moved from the limited partners (universities, pension funds, wealthy families) into the pockets of the VC firm's partners. Not stock, not options: cash money. This is the way the system has always worked, since time immemorial. VCs get paid a management fee (about 2%) win or lose, and a percentage of the profits when they win.
Just something to keep in mind when someone mentions their strong principles in the course of a discussion over how dang expensive butter is these days.
[Edit to add: My description of management fees is slightly simplified and ignores salient things like the fact that they recur annually.]
- credo 15y agoYou're correct. VCs play a game where they win with other people's money. They make good money regardless of performance (for example, 10-year VC returns seem to be trailing 10-year stock market returns). They make a killing if their portfolio companies do well. Are you suggesting that this VC pattern justifies the actions of founders who take $21M as dividends ? (to be more precise - founders of a young private company that is dependent on external investment for financing itself)
- patio11 15y agoAre you suggesting that this VC pattern justifies the actions of founders who take $21M as dividends ? I don't think that particularly requires moral justification, any more than an engineer saying "That offer is interesting but I would prefer $5,000 more and an extra week of vacation" requires moral justification. Capitalism happens. Sometimes, it even happens to rich people. Edit for context: "Capitalism happens" is shorthand I frequently use for "Sometimes one party in honest negotiation with another has leverage, perhaps because of how supply and demand for the product being sold shake out, and this is natural and not particularly noteworthy." I usually say it when rich people complain how much money they are paying for things like e.g. engineers or shares in a hot startup.
- jsnell 15y agoYou must be interpreting this article very differently from many others since you're trying to turn this into an example of VC greed, but I don't quite understand how. My reading is that the VCs for this round are not getting screwed in any way, they know exactly what they're getting (X% of the company for $Y, with $Z ending up in the company's accounts). For them it doesn't really matter whether all the shares they buy are newly issued or whether some are sold by existing shareholders, as long as X/Y/Z are the same. Any possible investors in earlier rounds are not particularly getting screwed, since they have shares that will now receive a dividend. But the employees with options are getting shafted, as they have been dilutied more than if the founders' cash-out had happened by them selling shares.
- patio11 15y agoThe delta between this deal and every other deal ever is not "Employees are uniquely getting screwed." Employees always get diluted. Three things you can count on: death, taxes, and employees getting diluted. You've got to come up with a fairly elaborate scenario to make this particular marginal dilution sound morally significant for me, since it is likely to be on the order of "We stopped stocking one particular brand of free soda" for most employees, since employees start out with wee little stakes and always get them progressively diluted over time anyway regardless of this micro-controversy. The delta between this deal and every other deal is that the founders are getting treated in a way typical for VCs, not in the way typical for employees. Here's some numbers about a hypothetical company FooCorp to make a point: assume that the employee option pool is 20% of the pre-market valuation of FooCorp when FooCorp raises $1 million on a $5 million valuation. (That pre-market bit is significant because putting it pre-market rather than post-market is a easy way for VCs to change the price of the deal without changing the price of the deal, which is a theme we will be returning to shortly.) Prior to the first round, employees (present and future) own or will eventually own 20% of the company, and the founders own or will eventually own 80% of the company. (We'll pretend there are no angels to keep the math easy.) After the first round, employees own 16% of the company. Wait, didn't we say 20% literally on the piece of paper we signed the deal on? Yes, but some 20%s are better than others, for example 20%s which are written by people who do this for a living. This is garden-variety VC screwage and only tangentially related to the point. Anyhow, say we raise $3 million on a $15 post for Series B. Employees get diluted again, with the founders, and they now own 12.8%. We'll stipulate that the company goes red hot and the numbers around Series C are getting thrown about in the neighborhood of a billion dollars. They want to raise $80 million for business use. If the founders negotiate a post-money valuation of a billion, the employees get diluted to about 11.8%. If the founders instead raise $100 million and return $20 million of it to themselves, the employees are instead diluted to about 11.5%. But wait. That is exactly equivalent to the founders raising $80 million (i.e. taking no money) but just not negotiating quite as well: if the VCs wheedle them down to $800 post, then employees end up with 11.5% anyhow. (That's a perfectly reasonable outcome for the negotiation because valuations for non-public companies are set by slicing opening a goat's entrails and successfully arguing that they look more or less auspicious than the other guy thinks while insinuating that if he doesn't like it he can go cut a different goat with other people.) This (the OP) is a discussion about the price of the deal (and, secondarily, about the diminished leverage a hypothetical VC would have for subsequent deals if he had to deal with a counterparty who was already rich). It just doesn't sound like one, because we have invented a rich vocabulary under which people who understand money can manipulate the price paid to people who understand computers without ever saying the word "price." Returning back to tangible reality of possible interest to HN readers, an early engineer promised .5% of the company when he joined waaaay back before they were famous is looking at this discussion and going "Honestly, guys, why do you care?", because the differential is between him ending up with 0.295% of the company (that's 2.95 million per billion if they should take no money and then exit) and 0.2875% of the company (that's 2.875 million per billion if they should take no money and exit). i.e. In the still-quite-unlikely event that he receives a pot of gold at the end of his rainbow, it is not a meaningfully different pot of gold than he would have otherwise gotten.
- fleitz 15y agoNo kidding, I think we all forget the philanthropic mission of every VC out there. I think the primary problem is the insult of putting the VCs in the same class as the employees. I will agree that dividends should generally be used when the investors are able to invest the money better than the company can. eg. If an putting the cash into ops will generate a 6% return and investors are able to earn 8% then a dividend should be issued. If you can fill out your round, get cash and not have to dilute as a CEO why wouldn't you? That would be like a VC turning down free equity.
- jack7890 15y agoNo, that money doesn't go directly into the partners' pockets. It also goes to pay the VC firm's rent, travel cost, salaries of associates and support staff, legal/accounting costs associated with the deal, and a bunch of other things. It is generally accepted that a vast majority of a VC partner's income comes from their share of the fund's return, not from the management fee. It is not unheard of for a VC firm's costs exceed the management fee, such that the partners loose money unless the fund has a positive return.
- patio11 15y agolegal/accounting costs associated with the deal Industry standard practice is that startups pay for costs associated with deals, not capitalists. That one is virtually universal. The grapevine tells me that it is not uncommon to see VCs travelling as board members. Some of them don't exactly fly coach.
- staunch 15y agoThe management fees do pay for the swanky offices, assistants, expensive meals, strippers, golf, computers, very significant travel expenses (unrelated to board meetings), etc. And fees are not necessarily split equally across partners. One senior partner might take 20-50% in some cases.
- trevelyan 15y agoHonestly, why should anyone here care that the VC has to pay rent or salary expenses? Are they eating ramen or living in the office? As a founder, I'm delighted the AirBNB guys are charging for admission to their equity sale. Call the payout back wages paid at market rates and call it a day. And if investors are reacting in shock to the sticker price they can get out of the showroom. Sorry you won't be joining us - perhaps there is a cheaper model you can lease somewhere else?
- philwelch 15y agoAt 20 million dollars, that would be a rather significant premium above market rates.
- vladd 15y agoVCs are guys handling money, they need entrepreneurs (guys getting things done) and vice-versa. They sign a contract which mainly defines how each gets to profit from the other one and the boundaries of their interactions afterwards. It's well-known and the web is full of articles about preferred stock, liquidation preference, convertible debt and similar topics. But this article is about something new - a dividend that mainly goes only to the founders. It's about entrepreneurs screwing early-employees, entities that until now I've always considered as been in the same bucket. You can rightfully claim that the messenger sucks (which might be well-known) but that doesn't imply anything on the message itself (or its novelty).
- sunnydaynow 15y ago>It's about entrepreneurs screwing early-employees, Yes, that surprised me a lot! Especially from founders that are somewhat "famous" and are connected to YC. I expected they don't play these tricks. Greed? Anyone knows how their employees reacted to this news? If I would have worked 50+ hours for year(s) and then read this... :(
- keeptrying 15y agoBut the employees are getting salary and have been for the last 3-4 years. Infact all those employees have been making more than the founders for the last 3-4 years. And if on joining, you were told about 2 classes of stocks - one for the founders and one for the employees then you should have understood that this was a distinct possibility. This VC is just using this small soapbox to warn Airbnb not to eff with him. And to try to stem the tide in Silicon Valley where successful founders are compensated for getting a company upto a $1 billion valution WITH revenue. If an employee had written this, I would have been a little (tiny) bit sympathetic but for a VC to act like he cares for the employees -- you HAVE TO BE KIDDING ME!!!
- rdouble 15y agoBut the employees are getting salary and have been for the last 3-4 years. They've only had employees for about 2 years. /pedantic http://blog.airbnb.com/hiring-really-smart-software-engineer http://blog.airbnb.com/hiring-really-smart-software-engineer
- mikebo 15y agoThe way I read it, Chamath doesn't think the company will be as successful if this is the way employees are treated. That's a perfectly valid reason to pass -- it doesn't seem like a right vs. wrong stance.
- 0x12 15y agoI'll buy that if Chamath is willing to forego his management fee on this and future deals. A VC arguing the ethics of this deal with respect to early employees is more than a bit disingenuous, at first glance it looks as if they are doing this to protect the little guy but that is only because for once they are treated the same as the little guy.
- iamelgringo 15y ago$120 million fund. 2% management fee = $2.4 Million a year. $2.4 Million a year sounds like a lot initially, but when you consider local salaries and costs associated with this. You might think that VC's make tons of money, but when you consider that the $2.4 Million has to fund their entire business, and when you look at how the costs break down, it starts to look a bit more reasonable. Here's how those costs break down: Office space on Sand Hill Road: 5000 sq ft @ $60sq ft / year = $300,000 3 exec admins @ $ $80k / year = $240,000 2 Associates @ $150k / year = $300,000 2 Analysts @ $100k / year = $200k 4 partners @ $300k / year = $1.2M Marketing / sponsoring events @ $100k / year Legal fees @ $300k / year Now, when you exclaim that a $300k salary is exorbitant, consider that most engineering managers in Silicon Valley make about that much. $300k will allow you to purchase a house in San Jose ($500k for an average house in the burbs), but it won't let you purchase anything in Palo Alto (over $1M, easy. Monthly payments are around $7k). Nurses working the night shift in Silicon Valley make around $150k a year without working tons of overtime. Firemen and policemen make about the same. An ER tech at a hospital makes about $70k. Add to that, that most partners and associates at VC firms will end up working 80 to 100 hours a week. So, partners will end up having an hourly wage of about $75 an hour, which is what PHP contractor will make in the area. A decent Rails contractor will bill about $150. So, when you break it down, the greedy blood sucking vampire VC's... really don't make as much as it's made out to be. A number of them are actually pretty nice, and great people to have a beer with. And, it's actually a pretty hard job. Full Disclosure: I haven't made a penny from VC's. I've had a couple sponsor events for Hackers & Founders, and a number of them have been really helpful in teaching me the ropes of Silicon Valley.
- ootachi 15y agoA $300k salary is absolutely not necessary to live in Silicon Valley. Also, a $1M house is affordable if you earn 300k a year. Why would you think it's not? You could probably pay that off in 10 years, far short of the 30 year time span on most mortgages.