3 ms·
The special one-time-dividend to vested early stockholders seemed a little fishy when I noticed in Groupon's S-1... but maybe it's just an efficient way to rewa
by gojomo 15y ago
The special one-time-dividend to vested early stockholders seemed a little fishy when I noticed in Groupon's S-1... but maybe it's just an efficient way to reward existing value without larger dilution/valuation.
If employees with unexercised but vested options were given a heads-up that such an unusual early dividend was coming – so that they too could choose to qualify – that might address much of Palihapitiya's concern about fairness.
- canistr 15y agoI'm probably wrong or misunderstanding the whole issue, but if it is true that new investors are simply paying early stockholders a special dividend, then wouldn't that make this a Ponzi Scheme?
- michaelchisari 15y agoWhile we could argue back and forth about whether it technically is a Ponzi scheme, whether that definition fits or not, it's profoundly problematic. We already exist in a relatively volatile industry that has seen it's fair shares of bubbles and busts. We don't need to add another unethical and chaotic variable to the pile.
- ssx 15y agoThis is not the definition of a Ponzi Scheme, you should probably look it up on wikipedia. But I do agree with the article, dividend's like this are not the spirit of building a good company. Just founders who want a huge pay-day. I would have understood 1m-4m, but not 21m, thats a huge percentage of their investment.
- gojomo 15y agoNo, it's not a huge percentage of their stake. They still retain massive stakes in a risky private company with a $1.2B+ valuation. They're just diversifying a little. You wouldn't ask an investor to prove their commitment by putting 100% of their net worth in a single venture. Investors are diversified. Smart founders should be, too, as soon as they are able.
- ssx 15y agoIt is a huge percentage of their funding, around 1/6th. If a company where to raise 6m and the founders got 1m not by equity, but by dividends! That just doesn't happen. If the founder's want to sell some of their equity, I'm fine with that, but that is NOT what happened here. This is purely a pay-day. If I knew my company was going to be the next eBay for realestate, why would you hamper your company by taking 21m off the table. This signals greed and/or being unsure of your future success.
- gojomo 15y agoIf the founders retain a majority, this is less than 4% of their stake — that percentage is more relevant in analyzing the confidence signalling and motivations than a superficially large "$21 million" figure.
- ssx 15y agoClearly you still don't understand. They didn't sell 4% of their stake. If they did that, it would be somewhat reasonable. What they got was a dividend. In other words a bonus. And yes the figure is still "large" because it is 1/6th of their funding that goes to their pockets, rather than the company.
- sunir 15y agoIt would be completely reasonable if they sold equity to take money from the round. Alternatively they could offer a retention bonus to everyone based on current salary.
- jtbigwoo 15y agoThe difference here is that the founders are somehow diversifying without actually parting with any of their investment. This is simply a massive bonus to the founders treated as a dividend (probably for tax-avoidance purposes.) The fact that it's not available to most employees, even those with stock options, if problematic, if you ask me.
- sunir 15y agoNot really. I am not a lawyer but it seems to me that is not the case. Employee stock options are meant not to be exercised until they are saleable. When you can them early in a private company your capital is locked up in a dead asset yet you have to pay capital gains taxes. The dividend would have to be huge. Further watch out for insider trading. The value of the stock when the option was struck has to price in the promised dividend.
- gojomo 15y agoMy hunch is that for early-enough employees the dividend value could dwarf the exercise price, making the decision to exercise a no-brainer.
- JoachimSchipper 15y agoHence the mention of capital gains taxes.
- gojomo 15y agoThis is probably a 'qualified dividend' already taxed at same rate as long-term cap gains.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- gojomo 15y agoNot sure what you're disputing. 'Qualified dividend' treatment only requires a 60 day holding period. Also, those with founders shares have almost certainly held (via an 83b election) the shares long enough for long-term capital-gains treatment, as well. If you're saying that yes, the dividend treatment may save them on taxes (or at least be no worse) than other approaches, we agree. For employees who might have to exercise vested nonqualified options to collect the dividend, other ordinary income taxes may apply... but shares that were early enough could still be in a dividend-is-more-than-all-exercise-and-tax-costs situation, again making the participation a riskless no-brainer... in fact helping them set an earlier start date for future capital-gains calculations. If they're not in the no-brainer situation, they'd have to decide whether the dividend and early-holding-period-start was worth the cost/risk of converting to actual equity. That's a matter of tax law and risk-affinity... any dilemmas created by having a new range of possible choices aren't a knock against the offer of a dividend.