12 ms·
Internet Backbone Giant Lumen Shuns .RU
- daxuak 5y agoThe Russian government will only take advantage of denied accesses and doubledown with any domestic propaganda they have in the pocket, aren't they? I still don't get what other expectations are on the table when the western world talks about cutting Russians off the internet.
- agumonkey 5y agoIt has a limit. A lot of these regimes needs the west to point at them as bad agents and bad cultures. In full silence you're only left with cult of personality .. it might dry off quickly.
- martimarkov 5y agoTrue but look at North Korea. No external info and it’s a complete human rights shit show. Maybe slow down the traffic so ppl just get frustrated things are slow. Maybe even get gov.ru to redirect to images from Ukraine… something that shows the ppl what is happening (although I feel even if they are in Ukraine right now - they will still deny it)
- adamcharnock 5y agoI think North Korea is a materially different situation though. They are three generations deep into dictatorial/dynastic rule. The Kim family managed to keep one generation sufficiently oppressed that they could raise all the children to believe leader to be a god. Then they had a sufficiently clear line of succession (ie it’s a dynasty) that they could continue to build upon the foundation laid in that first generation rather than engage in power struggles. I think the sanctions and isolation then came later. Could Putin pull that out of the hat? It doesn’t seem likely to me in this day and age. I think North Korea is very much an outlier and has a unique set of circumstances.
- daxuak 5y agoQuick in the scale of historical timeline. For people living in the shitshow or us watching, that might well take a whole lifetime to process.
- ivan90210 5y ago>I still don't get what other expectations are on the table when the western world talks about cutting Russians off the internet. based on my observations over the last two weeks, it's unironically something along the lines of "zoomers throwing molotovs at the police over being deprived of fortnite", because the people who come up with these fantasies project their character traits upon a radically different population. something akin to expecting the Afghani to take up arms against the Taliban over that one McDonald's shutting down in Kabul.
- ecmascript 5y agoPutting a country with a lot of nukes in a corner and even disconnecting them from the internet seems like a bad move to me if I read the article correctly. This will only make it harder if not impossible for russians to know what is going on and they kind of have no other choice than to consume state propaganda for news. I believe internet is a great force for democracy and cutting a whole country of it will probably not lead to anything good.
- epolanski 5y ago
- propagandist 5y agoIt's the logical end to the social media arc.
- B1FF_PSUVM 5y agoYou know that mic-speaker feedback loop that yields a loud yowl? That's what we're getting now. (Back in the old days you had a lowpass filter - the "letters to the editor" written in paper. Now it's unfiltered, and it shows.)
- trhway 5y ago>Back in the old days you had a lowpass filter - the "letters to the editor" written in paper. Now it's unfiltered, and it shows. In the old days such slaughter of Ukrainians would have been going for months before anyone would get to do anything. These days the whole world acted in a matter of days. The speed of ratcheting of the pressure on Russia is an important factor which adds to the stress and not allows Russia to adjust and adapt. So, the faster/deeper/wider "cancel Russia" gets the less lives will be lost.
- epolanski 5y agoThat's naive and shows a huge dose of racism and double standards. 183'000 civilians died by american hands in Iraq. Who did anything to pressure companies providing services to us citizens so less lives would be lost? Who boycotts Israel for its apartheid, or Saudis for killing thousands and founding international terror. What about Uighurs or Rohingya? The world is showing nothing but double standards and hysteria.
- aneutron 5y agoOne the one hand, it's a sad day for Russians whoes only outlook on the world was the Internet, as this seems to be one of the main connectivity providers. On the other hand, I really have a hard time believing that they exited because of the moral aspect. I'm suspecting that there is more to the story. They cite heightened security risks. But I wouldn't be surprised if it was also economic issues (i e. they would no longer be paid for their services). I would genuinely like to see a more educated guess on the matter.
- Karrot_Kream 5y agoAs it becomes harder/more expensive to do business in Russia I suspect IP transit will raise in price or just stop being offered altogether.
- joenathanone 5y agoYou would know why they left if you read the article.
- throwaway22032 5y agoI don't really understand what the endgame of the sanctions and various actions are here. The idea that the populace will rise up seems like a super high risk maneuver - it's like going all in. Like let's say it's X% Putin isn't in power next year. What happens in the other 100-X% case now they have nothing left to lose? Is the idea that we just say "right, that's it, Russia is isolated forever now" and there we are? e.g. "we" showed that trade doesn't work, so instead we go for a kind of indefinite containment strategy? It just feels like a really stupid path to go down in my view because once you eliminate interdependence via trade you've now removed another barrier to Russia just deciding to take another country. Sure, NATO, MAD and all of that - but all of that was already there anyway. Once you get to the point at which the Russian state sees loss of their own territory as being a declaration of war, I don't see anything other than full blown WW3 being on the table. If anyone tries to reclaim Crimea, the Donbass, or in a few weeks maybe other parts of Ukraine-now-Russia by force, SHTF. I feel like all of this is getting lost in accusations of propaganda or being on the right side of history or whatever else. There seems to be no realistic climbdown being presented, if Russia fully pull out tomorrow, what do they get back and when? Are governments even in control of this any more or has Moloch taken it and gone for a run?
- bydo 5y agoThis is going to be a really out-there take on this, but what if, instead of pride and posturing, the Russian government changed their course because they realized what an awful thing this is for the Russian civilians they purportedly represent?
- anonporridge 5y agoReplace Russia with North Korea and ask the same question. Autocrats can hold power for a very long time with the asymmetric tools of oppression and control we have that are only getting more advanced with each passing version upgrade. And the more we cut a country and its people off from the rest of the world, the easier it is for the autocrat to maintain control.
- 5y ago
- leonixyz 5y agoThis is simply ridicolous. The urgency to do anything, just to show the others you're doing something looks so stupid to me. I think these kind of moves only help making things worse.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- robbedpeter 5y agoThe Afghanistan withdrawal was what is known as a "foreshadowing." Zelensky should do his best not to rely on anything the United States does or promises. The time things could have ended well was over about a week ago. The only question now is how hard we hit rock bottom.
- istjohn 5y agoGood. Russia is shelling unarmed men, women, and children in Ukraine. If we are unwilling to directly intervene with our military for fear of nuclear war, we should do everything else in our power to cut Russia down at the knees.
- 0xbadcafebee 5y agoTwo thoughts: - You couldn't get a better argument for totalitarian "We should have our own internet" than "Hey, look, if we don't, the whole world will just cut us off from the Internet like they did Russia". Expect more banking, business, communication silos from nationalist/dictatorial governments. - Russia's propaganda is eerily similar to the propaganda the USA pushed out during its wars on Iraq and Afghanistan. They call it a "special military operation". We called the Iraq War "Operation Iraqi Freedom", and the Afghanistan War "Operation Enduring Freedom". We never officially declare as war (haven't since WWII), even when we kill over a million people[1]. (we killed hundreds of thousands in both Iraq[2] and Afghanistan[3] respectively) We also falsified evidence to go to war, despite in-country and worldwide protests. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vietnam_War_casualties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vietnam_War_casualties [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casualties_of_the_Iraq_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casualties_of_the_Iraq_War [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_casualties_in_the_war_in_Afghanistan_(2001%E2%80%932021) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_casualties_in_the_war...
- sneak 5y agoI think another major consideration is that Iraq was an unvarnished dictatorship, is far away, and wasn't very industralized. Mostly nobody inside or outside of Iraq had any problem with the US or anyone else killing Saddam Hussein and toppling that government. International law aside, he seemed like a total asshole, a fact corroborated by my many Iraqi friends in Michigan who fled his government in the 80s and 90s. The story is quite a bit different for a fully industrialized democratic country with nominal rule of law and a fairly elected head of state, directly adjacent to our political and military allies in Europe. The fact that Ukraine is industrialized and proximate in Europe probably counts for a lot more than the fact that Ukranians are ~100% white and christian. I think the racism narrative is more than slightly overblown (but not entirely without merit).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zelon88 5y agoCurious to see how this will reduce global spam, malware, botnets, and ransomware.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoIt won't.
- nikolay 5y agoThis new "me too" movement is disgusting and sets dangerous precedents and copy cat behavior that will hurt us all eventually! I'm not sure what problem they are solving with this except publicity! We don't learn from history and the censorship in the Soviet Bloc! What American companies are doing now is exactly what the Commies have been doing back then!
- shrubble 5y agoSo how would you determine, that Russia hasn't just bought a huge amount of bandwidth from China and got out onto the Internet that way? I mean the local delivery (last mile) infrastructure is still present, right? Since a lot of traffic is encrypted, you couldn't even do deep packet inspection, could you?
- anonporridge 5y agoWell yeah. Ultimately no one can block Russia from the internet completely. But you can add a lot of friction and severely limit the bandwidth and latency the average person experiences.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoThese doesn't make any sense. I understand banking sanctions on oligarchs. Blocking regular .ru addresses is a really bad idea and smells of censorship and anti-democracy.
- mulmen 5y agoThis isn’t a DNS block on a country level TLD. Lumen is just no longer providing Internet access to customers in Russia.
- null0pointer 5y agoThis is getting fucking stupid. Honestly. Companies should not be escalating the situation like this. Leave the geopolitics to the diplomats who are at the negotiating table. Being required to do things like this via sanctions is one thing, getting involved voluntarily is another. At what point do we consider companies full blown belligerents in the war? If nukes start flying, then all these virtue signaling companies will not be without blame.
- mulmen 5y agoThey are ceasing operations because it’s no longer feasible to continue. Putin changed the business climate in Russia. Lumen is adapting to this new reality.
- Dracophoenix 5y agoWhere was this supposed "bravery" from Centurylink when China occupied over the last few years Hong Kong? Not that such a decision would have been effective even then, or even undesirable by Xi. But I'm curious what it would take for CenturyLink to disconnect Xi.