12 ms·
Statement from Poland on providing airplanes to Ukraine
- awb 5y agoFunny that they wanted the MIGs to go to Germany first and then given to the USA, in exchange for replacement jets. It looks like a very thinly veiled attempt at denying direct involvement. Everyone knows those MIGs are going to be given to Ukraine.
- Arnt 5y agoYou can also interpret it as a way of saying "we're either in this together, or not".
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 5y agoThey come from Germany in the first place, Germany wanted to get rid of migs in early 2000s so they donated them to Poland for 1€.
- jwilk 5y agohttps://defence24.pl/technologie/kto-przekaze-ukrainie-swoje-migi-29-analiza https://defence24.pl/technologie/kto-przekaze-ukrainie-swoje... says Poland is not going to give away the German ones: > The former German planes are not only the most worn out, but also have been adapted by the Luftwaffe to the western standard, so it would be more difficult for Ukrainian pilots to control
- mindslight 5y agoScenario: Previously-Polish now-Ukrainian MIGs sitting at an airbase in eastern Poland waiting to be picked up by Ukrainian pilots. Russia sends a few longer range cruise missiles at the base, destroying the Ukrainian planes. What is NATO's next move? Putin wants to test boundaries to find spongy contours. The more clear cut a situation is, the better.
- karpierz 5y ago> Russia sends a few longer range cruise missiles at the base, to destroy the planes that were already part of the war. And kill NATO personnel in the airbase. Russia has now murdered American and Polish soldiers on Polish soil. It's pretty clear cut what happens next.
- mindslight 5y ago> It's pretty clear cut what happens next. No, it's not. Does NATO let the ICBMs fly? Does NATO switch to conventional war mobilization and march into Ukraine? Shoot some conventional missiles at Russian targets in Ukraine? How about if Russia issues a statement that the strikes were against legitimate Ukrainian targets, they do not intend to attack any more NATO territory, and they will pay reparations for Polish casualties? If Russian military activity demonstrates an adherence to that statement, it technically renders article 5 mutual self defense less applicable. To avoid escalation, there is give and take at any level of aggression, just as when a fighter jet violates airspace. A posteri the destruction of Ukrainian jets at a Polish airfield, the desire to avoid nuclear war remains the same. The best thing is to avoid getting into the situation in the first place - by making attacking the in-transit Ukrainian jets a direct attack on the largest NATO power, the US.
- 323 5y ago> desire to avoid nuclear war remains the same If we apply this logic fully, Russia can invade Poland, Germany, France, all of Europe, and nobody will dare defend out of fear of nuclear war.
- mindslight 5y agoIf you shoehorn the scenario into binary reasoning, you can justify either extreme, yes.
- 323 5y agoAssuming that Putin will start nuclear war over 30 planes is also binary reasoning.
- david422 5y agoThat and the fact that the US statement was that it was a Polish decision as a sovereign nation to donate planes if they so choose, but the US would support whichever decision they took. Nobody wants to technically be the excuse Putin needs to use his nukes or whatever he's going to do next. But what difference does it make, Putin is going to do whatever he wants, trying to tiptoe around these lines drawn in the sand isn't going to change things.
- rasz 5y agoPoland learned how to deal with weasel US diplomacy. Nothing is set in stone, not even a signed piece of paper (Budapest Memorandum anyone?). Actions, not words matter. When you read https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/biden-admin-talks-poland-provide-warplanes-ukraine-rcna18876 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/biden-admin-talks-polan... >The Biden administration is holding talks with Poland about a possible deal to help provide Soviet-era fighter jets to Ukraine, a White House spokesperson said. >The deal would involve Poland donating its old Russian-made MiG fighters to Ukraine, and then replacing them with the purchase of U.S.-made F-16 jets. >“We are working with the Poles on this issue and consulting with the rest of our NATO allies,” a White House spokesperson said. >Secretary of State Antony Blinken on Sunday confirmed that the discussions are underway but said the timing is still unclear. and at the same time those very "talks" are Blinken merely suggesting the possibility of working something later down the road "but we must act now", and you already got screwed by US to the tune of $10B on military deals (initial F-16 purchase), then you know to tread carefully. Not to mention surprised pikachu face https://mobile.twitter.com/ak_mack/status/1501292504007720962 https://mobile.twitter.com/ak_mack/status/150129250400772096... >Undersecretary of State Toria Nuland, testifying before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, just said this statement was not pre-consulted with the U.S. Seems to have come as a bit of a surprise." So Biden officials leak "advanced talks" to the press while Undersecretary of State doesnt know anything about it and is not in the loop. EDIT: And there it is https://www.defense.gov/News/Releases/Release/Article/2960180/statement-by-pentagon-press-secretary-john-f-kirby-on-security-assistance-to-uk/ https://www.defense.gov/News/Releases/Release/Article/296018... here come the weasel words: "We will continue consulting with our Allies and partners about our ongoing security assistance to Ukraine, because, in fact, Poland's proposal shows just some of the complexities this issue presents. We will continue to consult with Poland and our other NATO allies about this issue and the difficult logistical challenges it presents, but we do not believe Poland's proposal is a tenable one." Typical US goading others to do the dirty work, but when push comes to shove "its complicated and untenable"
- sidewndr46 5y agoThis seems like a win-win for them. Support the enemy of their enemy and get rid of hardware they can't really maintain any longer. Russia isn't going to be maintaining those fighter jets now that it knows all of Europe considers it a hostile power. They need to buy fighters not dependent on Russia and the US is a logical place to turn to. The F-16 is likely to be well within their budget today, since they plan to purchase F-35s in the future anyways.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 5y agoF-16 is the only other type of fighters that Poland has, but giving up on those MIGs will reduce the number of active fighters to just around 50, that's a nearly 30% reduction and fewer than Ukraine had before the war. Given the delays in F-16 deliveries to other NATO countries, it would likely take some time for replacement to come in.
- ilamont 5y agoThe U.S. is selling F-16s that will shortly be delivered to Taiwan ... but those reportedly are not going to be diverted to Poland. https://focustaiwan.tw/politics/202203070023 https://focustaiwan.tw/politics/202203070023
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe US has hundreds of F-16s mothballed in Arizona. I'd expect they're about to be busy reactivating a few dozen in the next couple of weeks.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 5y agoThe question is if they can be given, all F-16 sold by the US were export models, not domestic.
- ceejayoz 5y agoIt's been done before. https://www.janes.com/defence-news/news-detail/bulgaria-to-receive-surplus-f-16s-from-us-ahead-of-block-70-delivery https://www.janes.com/defence-news/news-detail/bulgaria-to-r...
- dantyti 5y agoSeems reasonable, considering how US officials have 'green lit' giving the planes to Ukraine. The reluctance of Poland to do this directly is completely understandable, as it borders both Belarus and Russia,̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶l̶a̶t̶t̶e̶r̶ ̶h̶a̶v̶i̶n̶g̶ ̶s̶t̶a̶t̶e̶d̶ ̶t̶h̶a̶t̶ ̶i̶t̶ ̶w̶o̶u̶l̶d̶ ̶c̶o̶n̶s̶i̶d̶e̶r̶ ̶t̶h̶i̶s̶ ̶a̶n̶ ̶a̶c̶t̶ ̶o̶f̶ ̶w̶a̶r̶ ̶(̶w̶h̶i̶c̶h̶ ̶c̶a̶n̶n̶o̶t̶ ̶b̶e̶ ̶i̶g̶n̶o̶r̶e̶d̶,̶ ̶e̶v̶e̶n̶ ̶i̶f̶ ̶R̶u̶s̶s̶i̶a̶'̶s̶ ̶o̶f̶f̶i̶c̶i̶a̶l̶ ̶s̶t̶a̶t̶e̶m̶e̶n̶t̶s̶ ̶s̶e̶e̶m̶ ̶l̶i̶t̶t̶l̶e̶ ̶m̶o̶r̶e̶ ̶t̶h̶a̶n̶ ̶i̶n̶c̶o̶h̶e̶r̶e̶n̶t̶ ̶r̶a̶m̶b̶l̶i̶n̶g̶s̶ ̶a̶t̶ ̶t̶h̶i̶s̶ ̶p̶o̶i̶n̶t̶)̶. Getting some replacement F-16s out of all this is also important: who in their right mind would want to reduce the air force just as three of your neighbors are at war?
- brimble 5y ago> The reluctance of Poland to do this directly is completely understandable, as it borders both Belarus and Russia, the latter having stated that it would consider this an act of war (which cannot be ignored, even if Russia's official statements seem little more than incoherent ramblings at this point). The relevant statement I'd read had to do with letting Ukraine operate from air bases in other countries, not with supplying aircraft, which seemed to be a carefully crafted statement to avoid calling aircraft transfers an act of war, since it came out right around the (second) time this started to be talked about. Was there another?
- 323 5y agoNobody yet sold heavy weapon systems to Ukraine, stuff like Patriot or Iron Dome anti aircraft systems. Or tanks/planes.
- brimble 5y agoI think early reluctance had a lot to do with expecting anything advanced or large that was sent to be destroyed, or to be irrelevant by the time it could be brought into use (time to get it there, training time, then time to move it into a useful position). That they think Ukraine will still be able to field aircraft by the time this transfer is done, is itself interesting.
- lwneal 5y agoPoland has 23 flyable MiG-29s, some of which are trainer aircraft. Other EU operators of the MiG-29 are Bulgaria and Slovakia, who have another 15-20 combined. For comparison, at the start of the conflict Ukraine had about 70 fighters and Russia about 900. [1] https://defence24.pl/technologie/kto-przekaze-ukrainie-swoje-migi-29-analiza https://defence24.pl/technologie/kto-przekaze-ukrainie-swoje... [2] https://twitter.com/komadovsky/status/1498403101258231830 https://twitter.com/komadovsky/status/1498403101258231830 [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_active_Russian_military_aircraft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_active_Russian_militar...
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y ago> Ukraine started the conflict Let's be precise here...
- Isinlor 5y agoAs Pole - finally!
- toomanyrichies 5y agoHopefully this means the Ukranian air force can start attacking the 60-mile-long Russian convoy that's backed up on the road to Kyiv. As has been mentioned in other comment threads elsewhere on HN, it seems like that backup would be both a high-value target and (currently) a turkey shoot, until it resumes moving.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 5y agoThey can't attack it due to heavy Russian air defense, not due to lack of fighters.
- toomanyrichies 5y agoGood to know, thanks!
- riskneutral 5y agoSurely some surface-to-surface missiles or long range artillery could reach the Russian column and break through the air defenses? It seems to me like both sides are holding back from unleashing the full fury of their power, for good reason.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 5y agoUkraine might get handheld anti-tank or anti-air missiles, but they don't get heavy equipment like long-range surface-to-surface or SAM missiles. If they use artillery, they risk counter-battery fire or air attacks.
- mywittyname 5y agoUkraine is pushing for a NATO-led no fly zone specifically for this reason. They can't attack this column without exposing their troops to counter-attacks from Russian aircraft. For now, there is no functional difference between destroyed equipment and disabled equipment. Turning this disabled equipment into destroyed equipment carries risks for no immediate gains. (Granted, this might look like a poor decision in hindsight)
- trzy 5y agoBad move. This opens up Polish airbases to retaliation by Russian ballistic and cruise missiles. If push comes to shove, NATO Article 5 will not be invoked for Poland’s sake (Western European nations, the UK, and the US will not be willing to risk WWIII for country east of Germany and Poland should understand this by now). Poland will foolishly be left smarting while Germany and the UK press for rational dialog.
- Maakuth 5y agoWhy do you consider it certain that NATO guarantees would not apply? Ukraine is not in the alliance.
- pxtail 5y agoThis could be difficult to understand but in Poland due to the history there is sentiment that country was betrayed or abandoned, not helped by allies at the start of WWII by Britain, France. Of course it's not certainty as you wrote but the thought at the back of the head about history repeating itself and possibility of being considered as just the buffer zone and potential battle ground for western europe countries is there for many people - and that's why in addition to having borders with countries at war Poland may be perceived as treading twice as carefully in this situation.
- alangibson 5y agoAFAIK any NATO nation can invoke article 5. However, the other nations have latitude in how they respond
- aaomidi 5y agoIf Poland gets attacked over this, and NATO doesn't step in, then that's the end of NATO. This is a really smart move to finally solidify the power of NATO - or get rid of it if it doesn't actually have that power.
- gnulinux 5y agoI find this thought of mine hard to explain to people because obviously no one including me wants WW3 and likely annihilation of our species. However, please note that in a hypothetical future where NATO doesn't even protect NATO soil (e.g. Poland) there will be no reason for Russia not to invade Baltic States, Poland, Romania etc. This effectively makes NATO non-existent and gives all the leverage and power to Russia. I understand this is a very sensitive issue, but from this perspective I believe NATO should immediately retaliate if Russia even dares to attack Poland.
- riskneutral 5y agoI wonder how they solved the problem with the NATO MIGs having completely different systems than the Ukrainian air force? They must have either magically retrofitted the MIGs back with old Soviet tech, or they're transferring more than just jets to Ukraine.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoYes, this is a problem if they're to be delivered immediately, but there are a couple of machines (around 10 I think) that haven't been equipped with NATO systems plus some that are used for spare parts but are in a good condition. SO these could be sent soon, and the remaining part depends on the decision of the USA - if they want it, the NATO systems could be removed (it will take some weeks at least).
- CrzyLngPwd 5y agoHow will these fighter jets will get into battle? Won't Russia see any aircraft entering Ukrainian airspace as hostile and 1) Attack it 2) Attack wherever the aircraft came from? Seems such a risky thing that really won't have much impact on the outcvome of the conflict :-(
- ksherlock 5y ago"A ship in harbor is safe, but that is not what ships are built for."
- IanDrake 5y ago
- cft 5y agoLooks like there's a significant US lobby that want a hot war with Russia now
- CrzyLngPwd 5y agoThats horrifying if true :-(
- xdennis 5y agoDoesn't it make sense to fight them before they eat up more countries and get stronger?
- reed1234 5y agoRussia doesn’t control Ukrainian airspace
- CrzyLngPwd 5y agoI am sure you are right, but unless these aircraft are radar invisible or they put them in trucks won't Russia just see them and the country they come from as hostile?
- yuppie_scum 5y agoI’m curious if UKR has enough pilots for these?
- 323 5y agoThey don't need to take them all at once.
- brimble 5y agoMaybe better if they don't, if they don't have the capacity to put them all to use immediately. A plane that isn't on the ground in a war zone... won't be destroyed on the ground.
- DoingIsLearning 5y agoFighter jets are expensive beasts more so for smaller economies. Small Air forces normally have multiple pilots on a training rota for each jet, the multiple can be several times over depending on how tight your air force budget is. So yes between active pilots and reservists they will most likely have pilots for all of them.
- 323 5y agoPretty brilliant donating them to the USA airbase in Germany.
- xdennis 5y agoI wish my country, Romania, would do the same, but we're always last to do the right thing. We were the last eastern European country to close our airspace to the Russians.
- akmarinov 5y agoTurkey still hasn’t closed their airspace, so you’re not the last, Bromania. Also you guys only have MiG 21s and I think they’re looking for 29s.
- petre 5y agoThey need MiG-29 or Su-27s. Romania only has MiG-21s but are doing maintenance on 14 Ukrainian helicopters.
- Ancapistani 5y agoYou're probably aware, but others might not be - while the MiG-21 is an _ancient_ design by military standards, it's more of a "chassis" than a "design". The MiG-21 was introduced in 1955, manufactured until 1985, and upgrades and modifications are still being done. The first MiG-21 that came off the assembly line isn't really comparable to the variants being flown by Romania today. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Mikoyan-Gurevich_MiG-21_variants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Mikoyan-Gurevich_MiG-2...
- petre 5y agoYes, it has been modified by Elbit Systems to use NATO equipment. However, in addition to being ancient their flight capacity has been almost entirely used.
- rich_sasha 5y agoI’d imagine Poland’s motivation, certainly by the current government standards, are mostly to stick it to the Russians, maybe also swap some Migs for Fs. As honourable as the current Polish support for Ukrainians is, I’m almost sure it would be different if they weren’t fighting Russia and instead, say, were affected by a famine.
- zelon88 5y agoIt would be interesting to hear reports of them being used. "Two American MIG-29's intercepted a Russian bomber and escorted it out of NATO airspace today." Just has a strange ring to it.
- ericmay 5y agoCouple of notes: 1. This is kind of funny when you think about it. I mean is Russia going to all of a sudden be very confused and think that the Americans gave Ukraine MIG-29s? No. Poland did. What's the point of the roundabout way of doing this? Maybe Poland is worried about intermediate range missiles targeting Polish airbases. But that seems like an escalation that Russia isn't interested in, unless they're in it for all the marbles. 2. This is further severing of ties between Russia and NATO-aligned countries. I expect other former Soviet Union states to follow and also acquire U.S. aircraft. They don't want to be reliant on Russian parts or technical know-how, and this further strengthens NATO around common aircraft and components. Expect American defense contractors (and some European ones as well) go get more business from countries such as Poland. As I am thinking about this I think #2 is really what this is all about, but that Poland doesn't want to deal with transferring the aircraft to Ukraine and the Americans are glad to do it.
- ldoughty 5y agoMy understanding is: 1. Ukraine forces know how to pilot MIG29s 2. Poland has MIG-29s, USA does not 3. Poland has time to retrain on newer equipment, Ukraine does not 4. Poland doesn't want to be defenseless, if it gives aircraft to Ukraine. So Poland gives Ukraine exactly what they need right now... USA agrees to aid Poland in replacement aircraft. This isn't about "USA didn't give Ukraine aircraft", Poland did! It's about getting Ukraine the aircraft they know how to use right now
- ckozlowski 5y agoTo add to this and the comment above: Poland also flies the F-16. There'd been some commentary earlier in which Poland said they'd be willing to divest themselves of their MiGs if they can get F-16s to replace them in order to maintain their force level requirements. My guess is that this transfer of the MiGs to the U.S. is to facilitate this exchange in a rapid manner that would take too long through regular procurement processes.
- glfharris 5y agoThis is how I see it too. It'll be obvious to anyone where those aircraft have come from. Poland isn't going to deflect responsibility this way. Poland can't afford to donate it's air power so readily, but the USA allows them to with this move. It will also shift their military to be more on spec with other NATO countries.
- david422 5y agoI recently read an article that stated that Russian anti-air can basically reach all over Ukraine. I wonder how effective these planes can be if they can be targeted from anywhere.
- melling 5y agoThat’s why “low-cost” drones would be useful. Ukraine needs more than a couple dozen MIGs. Dozens of UAV’s in the air at all times would be beneficial
- topspin 5y agoRussia is operating their Buk S-300/400 anti-air system in Ukraine. Unfortunately for Russia the Ukrainians have been prioritizing the destruction of these systems and they've destroyed a significant number. Here is an example: https://youtu.be/TdTGT1dLSKA?t=73 https://youtu.be/TdTGT1dLSKA?t=73
- nuccy 5y agoBuk and S300/S400 are different things. Buk is self propelled all-in-one system, which has four rockets and integrated radar [1]. Buk's rockets range is about 50km. While S300/S400 have mich bigger rockets thus range, 300 and 400km respectively [2]. 1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buk_missile_system https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buk_missile_system 2. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/S-400_missile_system https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/S-400_missile_system
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AYBABTME 5y agoI'm gonna guess that this is only true for the higher altitudes, simply due to the curvature of the earth and the inability of radars to target below a certain angle above the horizon.
- munk-a 5y agoThis feels an awfully lot like the US taking advantage of the current war to sell some more guns and, while I definitely don't want people to be left defenseless, I dislike how exploitative the whole thing feels.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoNot really, it feels like the US trying to help Ukraine get some planes but Poland doesn't want to give up its stuff so the US is promising more planes to replace the old Migs.
- munk-a 5y agoAt least, given the statement, they're currently being redirected to Ramstein though - I wonder if that is for servicing before forwarding them to Ukraine.
- ardit33 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dang 5y agoAttacking another user like this, or like you did at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30611769 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30611769, is egregiously against the site guidelines, regardless of how wrong someone else is or you feel they are. Someone else having different views than you on a divisive and emotional topic is not evidence of anything but that the topic is indeed divisive. People with different backgrounds inevitably have different views. If you think you're seeing manipulation or abuse on HN, you're welcome to email us at hn@ycombinator.com as the site guidelines say. But you're absolutely not welcome to use this as a bludgeon to attack other users with. I've spent years poring over the data about this kind of thing on HN and I can tell you for a fact that internet users' perceptions about this are, overwhelmingly, figments of pure imagination. If you or anyone wants more explanation, there is years' worth at https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comment&storyText=false&prefix=true&page=0&query=by:dang%20astroturf https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme.... One long example is https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27398725 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27398725.
- CodeWriter23 5y agoI think a lot of people here didn’t comprehend this last paragraph: “ The authorities of the Republic of Poland, after consultations between the President and the Government, are ready to deploy – immediately and free of charge – all their MIG-29 jets to the Ramstein Air Base and place them at the disposal of the Government of the United States of America.”
- ardit33 5y agoSo, Poland is giving the Jets to the US, and they are hosted in a German airfield, and probably be delivered to Ukraine from there. If Russia wants to retribute, it will have to attack the US and Germany, which it ends up in ww3 territory. Basically, any additional move, will end up being such escalatory, that it will have to think twice about it. Especially the lower level troops that will be ordered to carry any such attacks.
- netsharc 5y agoIf Putin attacks Germany it'll probably not involve lower level troops, but a inter-continental missile.
- logifail 5y ago> Basically, any additional move, will end up being such escalatory [..] Deploying one single NATO aircraft from NATO territory into Ukraine is escalatory. It doesn't make any difference if it's a Mig or an F16, or whether it flew from an airbase in Germany or Poland.
- blagie 5y agoThere is an almost paranoid fear of escalation. I understand nukes and all, but Russia started this war, and escalated many times. There ought to be a line somewhere. Russia is shelling civilian buildings. I'm concerned that the line will be drawn at some point after the genocide starts. That's too late.
- akmarinov 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- awb 5y agoMight not be a done deal after all: https://twitter.com/phildstewart/status/1501334216851828737 https://twitter.com/phildstewart/status/1501334216851828737 > BREAKING - Pentagon response to Poland's proposal on jets: "We will continue to consult with Poland and our other NATO allies about this issue and the difficult logistical challenges it presents, but we do not believe Poland’s proposal is a tenable one.” - Phil Stewart (Military & Intelligence Correspondent@Reuters)
- rasz 5y agoStandard US politics, lots of talking and hoping someone else will do your dirty work. Good thing Poland already learned how to deal with US as an ally after all previous broken promises.