3 ms·
As a non-Albertan, I'm baffled by why Alberta thinks that building east-to-west pipelines to prop up their economy, while saddling their neighbours with all the
by vkou 5y ago
As a non-Albertan, I'm baffled by why Alberta thinks that building east-to-west pipelines to prop up their economy, while saddling their neighbours with all the risks is good policy.
I mean, I understand that may be a good policy for an Alberta, but there's no reason why anyone else should think it's a good policy for them.
- earleybird 5y agoIn what way is a pipeline riskier than truck/rail/ship?
- vkou 5y agoFalse dichotomy. It's not a choice between pipeline and rail, it's a choice between pipeline, rail, and nothing. Since its neighbours receive nothing but liabilities, regardless of which option is taken, I'll go with nothing. Tar sands oil is an endless, pointless jobs program. It's barely afloat when oil prices are high, and a rock around the neck of the Canadian economy, and GHG commitments when they aren't. I'm not interested in drastically cutting back on my energy usage, to balance the books with one of the dirtiest fuel producers in the world. Pipelines do nothing for me, but encourage this economically-destructive industry to expand. For every dollar of wealth it generates, it destroys a dollar and a dime.
- earleybird 5y agoI'm looking at it through a lens of least impact overall and totally agree about the tar sands. Trucking is wasteful, shipping and trucking don't have a very good ecological safety record. A good step in reducing environmental effects of oil is to stop exporting it as that just moves the problem elsewhere. Being self sufficient and weaning ourselves off of oil & gas is a step in that direction. We need to fix the problems at home before telling others what to do.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoAbsolutely, 100%. And the distortions that "rip and ship" makes in the economy aren't worth it when oil prices are high. It makes some people rich but most of us just suffer net effects and I'm not even talking about climate change. I've lived in Edmonton during oil-boom times, and during not-oil-boom times.. and the corrosive effect of the boom and bust cycle on the Albertan economy, it's not pretty. And a high per-barrel price in Alberta does nothing good for manufacturing in the rest of the country, dragging our dollar up and making our exports less attractive and the costs of production higher. When the dollar is high also makes my labour as a software engineer more expensive, without much benefit to me. Ah well, enough ranting, off to go pick up sushi in my electric car and I'm not even joking.
- refurb 5y ago"Tar sands oil is an endless, pointless jobs program." That point alone makes me confident you aren't that familiar with the industry.
- earleybird 5y agoGiven that break even for the tar sands has been in the $100/barrel range only recently (with process upgrades) may be as low as $40 (very optimistic in my books). It's certainly appears to need subsidies to survive.
- refurb 5y agoWhere did you get $100/bbl from? It was $40-50/bbl a decade ago for some companies. This source states an average of $40 today across all oil sands producers. https://oilprice.com/Energy/Crude-Oil/Breakeven-Price-For-New-Oil-Projects-Drops-In-2021.html https://oilprice.com/Energy/Crude-Oil/Breakeven-Price-For-Ne... Typically when oil prices drop (they were <$40 in early 2020), the oil sands companies put production on standby. It's like most oil exploration - it's either feast or famine depending on global prices.
- soperj 5y agoAlberta mines & refines oil that every other province uses, and is saddled with all the pollution from that. Why should Alberta prop up the economies of all the other provinces and have to deal with the actual consequences of that?
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoHuh? No. The refining of Alberta oil generally happens elsewhere. The Albertan oil consumed in Ontario and Quebec is refined in Sarnia and the port of Montreal, respectively. Comes in via line 9 and is refined in province. The chemical industry pollution in Sarnia is pretty bad from what I hear. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_impact_of_the_chemical_industry_in_Sarnia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_impact_of_the_ch...
- soperj 5y agoLargest refineries in Canada that refine Canadian crude are in Alberta, Imperial's 191M barrels/day and Suncor's 142M barrels/day, both in Edmonton and then you can add on Fort Saskatchewan's 100M barrels/day, just outside of Edmonton. There's a west coast city that is nearly entirely dependent on Albertan crude oil & refining. Sarnia is refining an already upgraded bitumen though, so it's only getting half of the garbage. Also Line 9 goes from Sarnia to Montreal, Enbridge Mainline goes from Alberta to Sarnia.