8 ms·
For the value of an anecdote: in my grieving process, I tried several forms of catharsis: hitting a heavy bag, yelling, running and biking angry. In every case
by klyrs 5y ago
For the value of an anecdote: in my grieving process, I tried several forms of catharsis: hitting a heavy bag, yelling, running and biking angry. In every case, it made me more angry. I got worse. The anger turned inward. It wasn't until I stopped that approach that I made any progress in my grief.
> Any sort of cathartic experience would necessarily be self-reported and we all know the accuracy of self-report studies.
That's not true. In the article, they mention observational studies wherein folks who vent are more likely to lash out. That isn't self-reporting.
- swagasaurus-rex 5y ago> Since the students weren’t randomly assigned to either vent or not, it’s possible that the most anxious are the ones who chose to vent (so that venting was correlated with increased anxiety, not the cause of it)
- klyrs 5y agoYes, that particular study may have flaws in its execution. But that doesn't prove that studies on venting are necessarily self-reporting.