11 ms·
How the FRA is Regulating Passenger Rail Out of Existence
- ams6110 15y agoThe problem with government regulatory agencies is that once they solve the problem that instigated their creation, they can't stop. They keep looking for more problems to "fix" in a never ending loop of justifying their existence. Once they become typical bloated behemoth bureaucracies, common sense doesn't work anymore.
- silvestrov 15y ago1. Once a bureaucracy is created, its 1st act is to perpetuate itself. It has no allowance for self-destruction someday. 2. When one coalition of governments and bureaucracies don't work to one's advantage or agenda, create a new one. 3. If threatened w/ abolition, bureaucracy's main defense is counting d no. of bureaucrats who'll lose job, social tension. 4. Before the main mandate is accomplished, create new functions, prgrams and "needs" to perpetuate itself forever. 5. Create one admin or regulations order, monitor how ineffective it is, create a revised regulations order, monitor... http://funwithgovernment.blogspot.com/2011/07/rules-of-bureaucracy-part-1.html http://funwithgovernment.blogspot.com/2011/07/rules-of-burea...
- Lagged2Death 15y agoOnce a bureaucracy is created, its 1st act is to perpetuate itself. It has no allowance for self-destruction someday. Certainly we can all see the results of this sort of behavior, which is a real thing. You can't extract, from that observation, the general principle you propose, though. The boards, bureaus, and commissions that have allowed themselves to fade away are gone, of course. The ones that act to perpetuate themselves persist. When you observe the behavior of the organizations around you, you're not looking at a fair sample of the organizations that have existed. And exactly the same is true of private clubs, charities, corporations and companies of every sort. This isn't a characteristic of governmental organizations, it's a property of organizations, period.
- sans-serif 15y agoAh, but the crucial difference here is a private organization can no longer exist once it has exhausted its purposes. A privately-funded bureaucracy which simply self-propagates while producing no value goes bankrupt automatically, regardless of what they can spin.
- jeltz 15y agoNot really. There are plenty of private organisations that produce no value while consuming funds. There are no major differences between large corporations and the the government in this aspect.
- gwright 15y agoReally? Where are they getting these funds if they aren't providing some service or 'value' in exchange? Maybe you are right but you seem to have stopped mid-argument. Examples might help illustrate your point.
- maxxxxx 15y agoThe financial sector or defense? They operate within a framework where they are pretty much guaranteed profits.
- gwright 15y agoThat isn't a serious response. 1) Both industries are intimately tied to the government in a variety of ways and so aren't particular good examples of 'private organizations'. 2) The notion that these entire sectors have no value is preposterous. Debating this sort of thing in the aggregate ('banking sector', 'defense sector') just doesn't make sense. Lots of banks fail and go out of business even outside the fiscal mess of the last few years. Same with defense contractors. Still waiting for an example of a private firm that provides no value and consumes funds indefinitely.
- Symmetry 15y agoI'd say this is more like government taking a local optimum from one time period, and casting it in stone. You can see the same thing happen with in the nuclear power industry, with light water reactors being given a regulatory blessing that made sense at one point.
- drinian 15y agoI don't buy that. Every other country with high-speed rail has rail regulations as well.
- ajross 15y agoExactly. In fact, I'd say that looking at the existing evidence successful rail deployments are entirely uncorrelated with regulatory action. This is just a whipping post for the libertarian nutjobs, and the only notable thing is that it's one that aligns them in goal with the pinko commie rail boosters. Clearly the determining factor isn't regulation, it's subsidy. Countries that pay for fancy rail systems out of public funds ... have them.
- drinian 15y agoEffective, good-quality regulation is a form of subsidy. This article is right to look at the costs of not updating regulation to meet reality.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- mwsherman 15y agoTure and agree, but this is true of any organization. The essence of any organization is to serve its own interests. It can be charitable or ideological or profit-driven, but if it does not serve its interests, it is no longer an organization. We shouldn’t be surprised that gov’t agencies are similar. The difference is that its funding is decoupled from its benefit to constituents.
- rickmb 15y agoAmen. You don't have to go as far as an organization. Get an ad-hoc team together and they'll try perpetuate themselves. It's normal human behavior, and has nothing to do with the "evils" of bureaucracy. The problem as far government agencies are concerned is the informal corruption that allows for ever increasing amounts of money to flow into those agencies. This is very hard to fight, since it is almost impossible for even the most dedicated and upstanding elected representative to judge if the funds assigned are justified. Surely there is a need for something like the FRA, and surely there should be rules governing the safety of trains? The funding isn't decoupled, but it isn't coupled to something as simple and transparent as a free market. There needs to be active democratic oversight, which is way, way harder.
- thingie 15y agoFRA as such isn't the problem. See, every European country has its own railway regulatory office, which is perfectly fine, but there is simply so little unification between the different countries, that international railway traffic between various EU countries is so painful, that it simply cannot stand in competition with the road freight. You can easily load your cargo on a truck and move it from Bulgaria to Scotland, but it's incredibly painful to do that on rail. There are tons of various signalling systems, there are multiple electrification systems (even in a single country), there are different norms everywhere, various load gauges, available railway clearances… it's a HUGE mess. And it's expensive. Some progress is being made, but of course, it doesn't get so easily through. ETCS (European Train Control System) is being developed and very slowly deployed, but only very slowly, it's expensive to equip a locomotive with it (more so than to put a multiple national signalling systems there) and you can use it on only very few lines. And you will never fix everything. Like, you are not going to rebuild every railway line in the UK to the continental clearance. Won't happen. So, I don't think there is a problem in having a federal reguatory agency. The problem is that it's dysfunctional and nobody really cares. But not having anything like that is bad as well.
- yxhuvud 15y agoThere are even different track widths, with the russian system being wider than the most common standard.
- thingie 15y agoWell, there isn't much of a passenger traffic to the Russia and back, there are facilities to handle the freight, it's an EU border (implying long legal procedures regardless of a transport mode) and the roads there aren't very good (in comparison). Baltic states and Finland lack connections to the rest of EU and again, it's mostly freight only. So it doesn't harm rail transport that much. Less obvious, but much worse problem is that there are incompatible axle loads and clearances, russian carriages are heavier and wider. Too much for the most of standard gauge lines. Much funnier example of a country with multiple railway gauges is Spain. There are three widely used gauges…
- WalterBright 15y agoThe idea is to regulate business out of existence, then declare capitalism to be a failure.
- starwed 15y agoThis is the worst sort of comment -- blanket assertion of a controversial yet vague idea, no actual arguments, no specific statements, nothing to discuss. It's just as much noise as reddit-style joke threads. Those don't seem to be tolerated here, and neither should comments like this.
- dpearson 15y agoAnother failed government policy regarding rail: the requirement for cleaner locomotives. The vast majority of railroads in the US do not buy new locomotives, and in fact usually use locomotives from the 60s and 70s (bought secondhand). Yet, the federal government is requiring newly bought locomotives to have cleaner emissions. Given that most emissions are from yard switchers (again, old locomotives no longer used in long-haul service), this makes no sense...
- keithpeter 15y agoGood luck: in the UK the worst train accidents with the largest number of fatalities have been due to poor track maintenance. The accidents have tended to occur on commuter trains with high passenger numbers and many people standing. Not sure what the French have seen as history on their much faster trains.
- dpearson 15y agoTrack has been an issue in the US, as has losing track of trains and having collisions. The vast majority of fatalities are exactly what these laws won't help with: people swerving the gates, or walking on the tracks.
- jrockway 15y agoOr a boat crashing into a rail bridge pier: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1993_Big_Bayou_Canot_train_wreck http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1993_Big_Bayou_Canot_train_wrec... (Honestly, I feel like this is one of those "cannot be avoided" situations.)
- billpaetzke 15y agoOr parking your car on the tracks: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_Glendale_train_crash http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_Glendale_train_crash
- cdavid 15y agoThere is a link in the article about TGV accidents (although to be fair, it is a website about TGV, so maybe biased toward TGV safety, I dunno). It should be noted though that the French railway system is pretty good from a quality POV, if only because it is used so much (traveling within France by plane rarely makes sense time-wise, and buses are rarely used). The situation may not apply to the US, although it would certainly remain a safe transportation. But I think it is a bit disingenuous not to mention critical factors like low-cost flight companies, huge facilities in the vicinity of airports and big net of inter-states buses. None of that is really true in France (there are low cost flight companies, but they go to airports which make it a non-starter for business).
- smokeyj 15y agoAs an airliner, lobbying for tightened RR regulation seems like a handsome roi. /takes off conspiracy hat
- _delirium 15y agoI wouldn't be too surprised if that's part of it. In the failed early-90s project to build high-speed rail in Texas, Southwest Airlines spent a lot of money and litigation making sure that all "rail safety" rules would be interpreted as strictly as possible, opposing any streamlining or exemptions granted to the project that would've made it more sensible. Other main players are the freight railroads and the railroad-workers' unions, neither of which cares too much about passenger rail (freight is much bigger business, on both the corporations' and the unions' side).
- jrockway 15y agoIronic as Southwest had to ground 44 planes because they were flying them without the federally-mandated safety checks. Also, one of them "opened up" in flight. "All is fair in LUV and war," I guess
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- protomyth 15y agoI wonder if they have regulatory authority over monorails or maglev?
- dpearson 15y agoWhat this article talks about is only for trains that run on tracks used for freight...so that wouldn't apply to monorails/maglevs...
- kposehn 15y agoMonorails and Maglev are remarkably expensive and inefficient, so unfortunately I doubt they'll ever be a viable alternative.
- protomyth 15y agoI'll agree with you on maglev at present, but monorail has gotten a bad rap from some false assumptions (e.g. switching) and some early problems.
- jarek 15y agoCan we add "in the U.S." to the title?
- EGreg 15y agoThe purpose of government should be to ensure that the minimum expectations of its citizens are met. These minimum expectations are a changing set of things, and I think that better feedback between government agencies and those which are affected by the rulings would be one of the best ways to solve the country's problems. I think that http://data.gov http://data.gov and http://recovery.gov http://recovery.gov are a step in the right direction. Experts should analyze the data and blog about it, and the government agencies should be keeping an ear out to what experts are saying. Also the interested public can do the same. The word "minimum" that I use is not accidental. The problem is that government rarely solves just the minimum set of problems. Once an agency exists, among the new employees there are always those who want to make their mark, and increase the amount of regulation. This is how government grows and grows. It's free for them to regulate but not free for those who have to implement it, and thus they don't feel the right incentives at the time. We need to figure out a way to incentivize government to stick as much as possible to only enforcing minimum regulations. Maybe it can be done by requiring them to get the citizenry to clamor for something before they implement it.
- jwallaceparker 15y ago> The purpose of government should be to ensure that the minimum expectations of its citizens are met. That seems like the purpose of a welfare state. If you want a government that sticks to the 'minimums' you're asking for, I'd redefine that purpose statement to something like: The purpose of government is to ensure the natural rights of its citizens, and nothing else.
- EGreg 15y agoI've heard that a lot. The problem with this kind of formulation is that "rights" is a loaded term, like "intellectual property". It implies that there are some universally recognized rights that come from nature, and only those. For example, if "intellectual property" was a natural right, then where does the 20 years come from in patents? That number 20, or the length of copyright, show that it's society's conventions and not rights. Instead, I treat everything as "expectations". Thousands of years ago, most people expected to hunt or farm if they wanted to eat. 500 years ago you didn't expect almost every child to survive past childbirth and the early years. Now we expect all these things and more. Clean water. Food that doesn't contain killer bacteria. Buildings that don't have obvious structural problems. Obviously we can't ensure things 100% but we as a society can work to set up organizations to regulate and oversee these things. A free market allows anyone to start cutting corners at any time, such as a new and inexperienced company that wants to make things cheaper. For example, a real estate developer can build a building that's not up to code. In theory, we could all walk around with our own subscriptions to private "auditing agencies" like Zagat for buildings, that would inspect buildings as they are built or whatever. But most of us outsource this kind of stuff to a centralized government. Which we vote for. Also, government could tax us to do unprofitable stuff such as the US Postal Service. However, the problem is that our government lacks incentives to stop growing, and we need to introduce them.
- kschults 15y agoThe one issue this article doesn't address is what is being done about the FRA. Are there movements to change the regulations? Overhaul the FRA? Even something as small scale as what, if anything, the author is trying to do about it would have been nice to hear.
- davesims 15y agoThose Trinity Rail Express cars are now used for the Denton-Dallas A-train commuter rail, soon to be replaced with new Swiss-made cars. I like the old ones actually, extremely comfortable and seats like a massive couch. http://www.dentonrc.com/sharedcontent/dws/drc/localnews/stories/DRC_Rail_Cars_0821.e5c8cf00.html http://www.dentonrc.com/sharedcontent/dws/drc/localnews/stor...
- thingie 15y agoModern suburban and regional {D,E}MUs are generally becoming more like trams or light rail vehicles in their design and, sadly, even interior. Lighter seats and so on. It's a general trend in Europe as well.
- iliis 15y agoI can asssure you, the new ones will be quite comfortable as well ;) Granted, they might not have couches as seats but they are very spacious and bright. I like them quite a lot... (They are in use since a few years already here in Switzerland.)
- mahyarm 15y agoIf Caltrain did a symbolic disconnect, cut off several feet from the track, put up a barrier, a few days work to do and undo. from the national rail network, would they still be subject to the FRA?
- kens 15y agoThe article says there's "zero possibility of a passenger train colliding with a freight train" because "there are virtually no freight trains running on the Caltrain line". However, since I had to wait for a freight train last week at the Redwood City Caltrain crossing (and I hardly ever use a grade crossing), I conclude that this article is making stuff up.
- kposehn 15y agoYes, this article is remarkably inaccurate.
- _delirium 15y agoIn Caltrain's case, they actually got an interesting waiver that allows them to time-segregate the network, where it's part of the national rail network (and can accept freight traffic) at night, but cut off from it (with no freight traffic, and interlocks making sure it's disconnected) during the daytime. In that setup, it would have permission to run non-FRA passenger-rail equipment: http://wilshirevermont.com/2010/05/31/caltrains-amazing-waiver-with-the-fra/ http://wilshirevermont.com/2010/05/31/caltrains-amazing-waiv... However I believe implementation of this is on hold, because they want to coordinate any upgrades with the HSR project. They've also discussed completely cutting it off from the national rail network at times. Unlike in many places, Caltrain actually owns the rails (rather than a freight network owning them), so that would be possible. There's strong lobbying against it from various landowners along the line, though; even though the line doesn't get a lot of freight usage, the possibility to receive at least an occasional freight shipment increases the value of the land.
- kinofcain 15y agoYes Caltrain (actually the Peninsula Corridor Joint Powers Board that owns the track) has a clause in their contract from when they bought the line from Union Pacific that states they can start freight abandonment proceedings if they make a significant change to the line. It's generally believed that was put in there in case they wanted to convert the line to BART, but in theory it could be brought into play for a Caltrain electrification or the HSR project. Caltrain has so far, however, refused to go down that route. Apparently the one freight train per day is too much to lose.
- blendergasket 15y agoThis is really sad. I drove a long distance (maybe 60 miles?) for the first time in years yesterday because I'm staying with my mom in the suburbs that have 0 public transportation infrastructure. First: It's impossible to have a life without a car here when the weather gets bad for biking (I'm outside of Seattle so that's a pretty good % of the year). People without a car are basically prisoners in this town with no culture, where the last bus from town leaves at 6:45. I can't go to work on days I can't bike because I usually work crazy long hours, til 10 or 11pm so I have to work from home if the weather's going to be prohibitive (I didn't bring my waterproof gear with me). Second: My mind was blown at the mental space driving in a car for a long period of time put me in. Weird stuff like traffic lights gave me this feeling of helplessness. It's a blueprint for a system of arbitrary, total control. The fact that no decisions are really based on the situation at hand but on these lights that mindlessly blink from green to red to green to red and you never interact with anyone or anything except through this sheets of glass. Call me crazy but I really think one of the big influences that's creating the massive societal problems we have in the USA can be traced to the fact that between work, home, school, and whatever destinations we get to we interact with one another in this alienated and antagonistic way. [edit] I know this rant is a little off topic, but it just highlights to me the need for a coherent public transportation network. It'd be interesting to look at this draconian regulation in relation to what was done to the rail network in the USA in the middle of the 20th century. GM and a bunch of other auto-related corporations formed a coalition, bought up and then dismantled lots of inner-city streetcar networks in order to replace them with buses that they would sell to the cities: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_American_streetcar_scandal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_American_streetcar_scanda... [/edit]
- Alex3917 15y ago"between work, home, school, and whatever destinations we get to we interact with one another in this alienated and antagonistic way." As opposed to within work, home, or school? Most of our public and private institutions seem to train people to be in abusive relationships.
- masklinn 15y ago
- kposehn 15y agoOk, as someone who has long been very close to the rail industry, a few points: 1. "...the Long Island Commuter Railroad (LIRR) in New York City, which has no freight traffic" - Incorrect. The LIRR also is host to the New York & Atlantic railway, a freight line which does indeed operate on LIRR lines daily. Average train gross weight is about 1,200 tons for each freight on that line, not 100 tons. 2. "FRA staffers point out that it is unfair to compare US buffering standards with those in Europe because passenger rail in the US has to contend with more (and heavier) freight traffic." - They are quite right to do so. The US plays host to the highest density of freight rail traffic in the world with most trains exceeding 5,000 tons (some closer to 15,000). 3. "In both Europe and Japan, a competitive business exists in the DMU marketplace. But that market is off limits to US transit agencies because the FRA has effectively created a trade embargo." - Incorrect. In San Diego, the Sprinter lines use Siemens Desiro DMU's, a light design totally unadapted for the US Rail network as far as weight goes. The line also plays host to freight trains at night. How they got around the weight requirement, I do not know. Furthermore, the San Diego Trolley has the line from downtown to El Cajon by way of Lemon Grove. That line also plays host to freight at night - a streetcar line! The market is indeed open, but the trick agencies use to get around the requirement is a bigger question. 4. "The FRA proposed rule would only allow Quiet Zones exemptions at crossings that had been improved with "four-quadrant" gates and curb medians." - for good reason! Many fatalities happen at grade crossings and horns are one of the only really efficient ways to keep people off the tracks. Most other nations have few crossings, preferring grade-separated rights-of-way. However, in the US, drivers are often grossly idiotic and don't pay attention. Not how many grade crossing accidents you see on YouTube... That said, it is indeed a major issue that the FRA rules apply to any rail line connected to the freight network that spans the nation. It would be far better if the regulations made clear exceptions for trains on passenger-only lines, hours of operation, etc. For example, let's look at CalTrain. The main line up the peninsula only sees freight traffic at night. By setting operational rules that restrict speeds near freight trains, etc, this would allow much better equipment for CalTrain while continuing to let freight run at specific times. The FRA very much needs to get with the program and allow better conditional standards.
- kposehn 15y ago_delirium pointed out the regulation that allows Sprinter and San Diego Trolley to get around the weight requirement in this comment: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3060835 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3060835 In doing some more research, Utah's FrontRunner has a completely disconnected network that allows them to get around the weight requirement. Apparently they went with standard US commuter equipment (MPI locomotives and Bombardier coaches) because of grade crossings and collision concerns. No sense in having a super-light train at high speed with grade crossing that carry many trucks.
- Anechoic 15y ago(I worked on the environmental assessment of the Acela back in the 1990's and worked with testing the first two vehicles off the line in Pueblo and along the NEC NJ "race track in 2000. The firm I was working for back then also did the noise analysis behind the revised FRA horn noise rules) This article keeps popping up on various geek sites over the years. In addition to the points kposehn brought up, I'll add the following: FRA isn't the reason why HSR sucks. The reason that HSR sucks is because we as a nation don't want to invest in the infrastructure to make a good HSR system. At a minimum that means exclusive ROW (grade-separated crossings) with relatively few stops and long straight sections where it can get up to speed. As for the FTA buffering standards - it really doesn't matter. Yes, the Acela is heavier than the TGV. That extra weight isn't why Acela service sucks. The Acela is perfectly capable of maintaining 155+ mph speeds for extended periods (I witnessed this myself in Acela enduracing testing). The power cars are more than capable of handling the load - during the first few months of Acela operation, there was a problem with the network connection that linked the front and rear power cars. To get service running until the power could be sorted out, the trainsets were run with only one power car operating. Running with one power vs both power cars (and pulling the dead weight of the second power car) only increased DC to Boston run time by 5 minutes. As for cost, the price of an Acela trainset is within the range of most other popular HSR trainsets (TGV, ICE, Pendolino, etc) albiet at the higher end. The effect of the train weight on track wear is minimal as it's the unsprung mass of the train (essentially the wheels, axles, traction motors and brakes) that is proportional to wear, not the static train weight. And train weight has nothing to do with noise. kposehn already commented on DMU but I'll add that the biggest impediment I saw to transit agencies adopting DMU's was that since no one else in the USA had them, transit agencies didn't know what to expect in terms of maintenance, operation, and environmental effects. In fact FRA and FTA were essentially begging transit agencies to try them, and it's only been recently that they've been operating in Vermont and other locations. Finally, regarding FRA horn noise rules: first of all, the preemption of state horn rules originated with Congress who directed FRA to get involved with horn noise (Google "Swift Rail Development Act" for more information). But the reason those rules exist is because whenever there is a grade crossing fatality, inevitably the next of kin sue and all too ofter win in court. As a result, there is a tendency to do anything and everything in the name of "safety" on the part of RR operators, agencies and regulators. As long as this remains true, horns are going to be part of rail travel. edit: btw we had this discussion at ArsTechnica back in 2008 (I'm Anechoic there as well): http://arstechnica.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=2671067 http://arstechnica.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=2671067
- rmk 15y agoI think these numerous regulatory agencies are a way of circumventing popular will (read: write mandates handed out by interest groups). Whatever happened to Obama's promise that he would weed out regulations that harm small businesses (I think they would benefit the most from the increase in foot traffic that would result if public rail service were more prevalent).
- georgieporgie 15y agoThe honking is driving me nuts. They're required to hit the horn four times per crossing. Sometimes it's a series of quick blasts. Other times, they'll lay on that thing for -- I swear -- five full seconds per honk. Midnight, 2am, 3am, they don't care. I'm around a mile away from the track, and I can't imagine what life could possibly be like for those who live closer to the track.
- stretchwithme 15y agowhat strikes me as odd is that one of most cost-effective safety devices, the set built, is unavailable to most passengers on buses or trains.
- ars 15y agoWhat is a "set built"? Do you mean "seat belt"? If you do, then you should know that seat belts do nothing on vehicles of that size.
- stretchwithme 15y agoI think I was half asleep when I wrote that :-) wtf
- stretchwithme 15y agoBut I'm not sure I understand your point. It seems when large vehicles stop suddenly, unsecured cargo doesn't. Airplanes have them don't they? I had heard something suggesting seat belts are not cost effective on trains and buses for the amount of lives saved. Perhaps that's what you're thinking of. Still, I would rather have them even if it cost an additional tenth of a cent per mile.