3 ms·
Some 15 years ago or so? I don't remember. I was working at Apple on the color and graphics team. I don't even to this day remember what the exact circumstance
by JKCalhoun 5y ago
Some 15 years ago or so? I don't remember. I was working at Apple on the color and graphics team. I don't even to this day remember what the exact circumstance was, but for some reason me and another engineer were urgently called into a conference room just a week or so before some big Apple product reveal. I feel like it was when the "Aqua" UI was to be revealed — I feel like it was something about the seven label colors used in the Finder to label files.
Anyway, we went to a section of a building that I had never been to before and a conference room with no windows. When we were led in there were detailed notes all over the wraparound white boards — what features to be demoed, what order. All sorts of notes and annotations (and also sticky notes?) added to the items on the whiteboards. Something like a conspiracy theory nut's HQ, ha ha. There were machines lined up against a wall on long desks running the software to be demoed, people scurrying around (designers? marketing types?). (I believe that Phil Schiller was there — the only time I have been in a room with him.)
Jobs was not there when I was there, but this room/show was all about Job's keynote.
It amazed me the degree to which this was a major operation, not at all an after-thought (not that I think anyone would expect that of an Apple keynote presentation).
Yeah, we lowly engineers were brought in to look at a specific issue they were seeing with the OS in the demo. I don't think we were expected to fix it, maybe we offered a suggestion on how to work around it?
Related: I was told by my manager (so this could be bullshit) that Jobs never went off script. Never. Everything you saw on stage, every step of a demo, was exactly planned that way — was rehearsed precisely. A single "ad-lib" in a demo of course could have exposed a hitherto-not-seen bug that would be hugely embarrassing. But Jobs was very good at following a script he had helped create, make it look natural.
I had also heard (so this could also be bullshit) that a 2nd machine was set up behind the stage and someone was stepping through the demo at the same time Steve was. If something locked up Steve's machine, in an instant the displayed hardware could be switched to the 2nd demo machine with only a small skip of a beat. I am not aware that it was ever needed.
I guess my take away is that Steve Jobs worked very hard at being Steve Jobs. If he made it look easy then — it worked.
- somewhereoutth 5y agoI was in the 'war room' backstage for a keynote (I think?) iCloud demo (or at least, something that touched iCloud, if only briefly). After our successful 2.5 seconds, they wheeled in a trolley of champagne. I never found out what would be on the other trolley...
- lolive 5y agoI would have loved to have Steve's opinion on presenting things with a video or screenshots slideware. He must have hated that. But this is what we, mere mortals, usually do to present things to other humans.
- dbcurtis 5y agoThat's a really interesting story that resonates with one I heard from a friend. Years ago when we were both at Intel, my friend transferred into the corporate demo group. He related a story about the time he had to prep Andy Grove for a few minute segment of a CES demo. My friend was in complete awe of Grove's ability to bring 100% focus and attention to learning every detail of the script, learn it quickly, and never deviate from the script. I guess that goes with the territory for people at that level.
- ksec 5y agoBoth were confirmed by other apple engineers. Steve rehearse his keynotes weeks and months before it even started. And the backup machine was once used in an OSX keynote presentation.
- hondo77 5y agoWas that the one that happened after Gates had machine problems with his keynote days before? I've suspected Jobs somehow had the "problem" added to his keynote just so he could tweak Gates by saying, "That's why we have backup systems here." 1:37 in https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnVUvW42CUA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnVUvW42CUA
- yardie 5y agoAround that time I was shipped out to do a video presentation with 3 laptops. 2 of them were cued up with Powerpoint and synchronized to play at the same time. If one went down I could switchover seamlessly. I also had a cold backup laptop in case the 2 running laptops failed. The only presentation I've seen where I think Jobs went off the script was when the 3G and wifi went down in Moscone and the demo phone couldn't open Facetime, IIRC. Telling a bunch of journalists to stop live streaming went about as well as you could imagine.
- mlajtos 5y agoHere are some off script moments: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v_5KcoSwmg4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v_5KcoSwmg4 Your example starts at 0:18 Edit: Some more https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6n-zw8L_84 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6n-zw8L_84 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnVUvW42CUA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnVUvW42CUA
- mason55 5y ago> A single "ad-lib" in a demo of course could have exposed a hitherto-not-seen bug that would be hugely embarrassing. It’s crazy what a small thing this is that people just don’t consider. We have this conversation with the sales team all the time, helping them prepare all their demos and pre-can as much as possible (eg instead of building a report in real time, just save the parameters and open your saved version). Inevitably they veer off script for no real reason and then complain that they found a bug in a feature that they tried for the first time live in a demo.
- allenu 5y agoThanks for sharing the story. I'm always surprised whenever I read about the time it takes to prepare for these presentations. On stage, it looks absolutely effortless, and dare I say, simple? As though the products are so easy to use, they just whipped up this talk a day or two prior. This is very much in line with the idea that magic tricks work because the audience can't fathom that the magician would go to such lengths to set up their trick: > Make the secret a lot more trouble than the trick seems worth. You will be fooled by a trick if it involves more time, money and practice than you (or any other sane onlooker) would be willing to invest. From a previous posting on HN about the magician Teller: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/teller-reveals-his-secrets-100744801/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/teller-reveals-h...
- srvmshr 5y agoHere's another anecdote (long read) about the insane amount of planning that went into launching an iPhone. What GP said rings absolutely true: https://www.nytimes.com/2013/10/06/magazine/and-then-steve-said-let-there-be-an-iphone.html https://www.nytimes.com/2013/10/06/magazine/and-then-steve-s...