10 ms·

One good reason not to support it is that it’s ambiguous: is it a comment (to be ignored), or does it represent a comment node? If the former, why not just use

• colejohnson66 5y ago
  I'd argue that comments only serve to help the developer. And when using JSX, the generated HTML might not look pretty (such as being a single, long line). So an HTML style comment in the JSX should be stripped because debugging the minified HTML isn't something people generally do. And if, for some reason, you wanted to inject an HTML comment into the output, you could abuse the `dangerouslySetInnerHTML` prop like this: function Comment(props) { return <span dangerouslySetInnerHTML={{__html: `<!-- ${props.comment} -->` }} />; } Then use it like this: ... <Comment comment="my comment" /> ... Using `React.Fragment` doesn't work, sadly. Use the "Inspect Element" tool on the output here: https://playcode.io/870223 https://playcode.io/870223
  • eyelidlessness 5y ago
    There are other use cases for (preserved) HTML comments in (or produced by) JSX, but generally more for library authors than end users. For example, comments can be used for hydration markers to delineate “hydration islands” without need for a wrapping element. (I have a proof of concept of this sitting in a Codepen somewhere.) And while it doesn’t work in React’s Fragment, it can certainly work with another compiler. JSX doesn’t specify anything about what it compiles to, React.createElement/_jsx are just defaults.