7 ms·
I'm leaving Rails core and I'm not interested in being in the alumni
- jaynetics 5y agoAre there internal controversies? Another core member left a few days ago.
- DetroitThrow 5y agoYes. There is a Twitter thread with a large group of Rails contributors chiming in on the related problems: https://twitter.com/kaspth/status/1499431981830086657 https://twitter.com/kaspth/status/1499431981830086657
- ksec 5y agoAnd to put things in context, Andrew White and Javan Makhmali resigned as well . https://github.com/rails/website/pull/28 https://github.com/rails/website/pull/28 https://github.com/rails/website/pull/25 https://github.com/rails/website/pull/25
- TheAceOfHearts 5y agoCould someone please provide a bit more context on why people are leaving?
- DetroitThrow 5y agoVarious reasons are brought up in the replies to this thread: https://twitter.com/kaspth/status/1499431981830086657 https://twitter.com/kaspth/status/1499431981830086657 Partly in response to tip toeing around this behavior for more than half a decade: https://twitter.com/Carnage4Life/status/1499714921726046213 https://twitter.com/Carnage4Life/status/1499714921726046213
- andrewzah 5y ago"Something went wrong. Try reloading." Linking tweets like this is not really helpful to building an understanding of the issue for outsiders.
- M2Ys4U 5y agohttps://nitter.net/Carnage4Life/status/1499714921726046213 https://nitter.net/Carnage4Life/status/1499714921726046213
- DetroitThrow 5y agoYou may have a network issue. The first suggestion you'd find on Google would be to restart your router! >Linking tweets like this is not really helpful to building an understanding of the issue for outsiders. The tweet threads in question have exactly the context needed to understand part of the reason why someone resigned in the GitHub thread, from someone who isn't anonymous in the rails community, unlike my hn account. I could copy paste them into a Medium article but I had linked them because they are informative regardless of your opinion on Twitter as a medium.
- andrewzah 5y agoNo, twitter's frontend code is garbage. It routinely does this (at least on Firefox), and -sometimes- works on a refresh or a hard refresh. It's been this way for years. Regardless if something is really serious, then compile the relevant/important stuff into a blogpost instead of making people wade through random tweets.
- DetroitThrow 5y ago
- andrewzah 5y ago"A quick Google would recommend you turn router on and off again." It's not a router issue, but thank you for assuming that I am unable to do basic internet searching. I have debugged this issue in the past as it occasionally occurs (for specific tweets only, twitter itself works well), and my conclusion is it's something on twitter's end. "Why don't you do that if it's so necessary?" I'm not the one submitting this on HN, am I? If I were, I wouldn't have linked random tweets. I wouldn't be tasking the commenters to compile the information into a usable format for me. There's nothing actionable here, this just looks like some tuesday morning drama.
- palerdot 5y agoThis thread tries to provide better context - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30600746 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30600746
- tsm 5y agoIs this related to DHH's blogpost about Railsconf?
- afandian 5y agoYou mean this https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30541345 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30541345 ?
- thematrixturtle 5y agoWhich in turn appears to be obliquely refer to this: https://www.theregister.com/2021/05/05/basecamp_political_discussion_apology/ https://www.theregister.com/2021/05/05/basecamp_political_di... This being Basecamp (of which DHH is CTO) issuing a "no politics" guideline, which was inevitably interpreted using the prevailing ideology of "if you're not with us you're against us".
- onionisafruit 5y agoThanks. I knew there must be something like that lurking behind the dhh post.
- dhimes 5y agoThank you. That's the missing piece— especially the last sentence.
- worker_person 5y agoBeen in this situation at a startup company. I refused to talk politics, only business. Which has been my policy for 20 years. This created a huge backlash against me, eventually I had to leave.
- yebyen 5y ago> issuing a "no politics" guideline, which was inevitably interpreted using the prevailing ideology of "if you're not with us you're against us". There is a lot more to the story than this. If you want to know more about what happened in May 2021 and the events leading up to that, there is no shortage of information about it. It was well covered at the time, even by Forbes: https://www.forbes.com/sites/agnesuhereczky/2021/05/09/why-do-diversity-and-inclusion-initiatives-fail-the-cautionary-tail-of-basecamp/?sh=35c171375ab1 https://www.forbes.com/sites/agnesuhereczky/2021/05/09/why-d... I just searched for "Basecamp Diversity Program" and this was the first thing that popped up. I am not inside of this community, but I've been a Rails user for literally hundreds of years. (And every year it seems like we're hearing again about how the community is really drama-free, from now on, no-takebacks...) The context for me is that the employees at Basecamp apparently cared more about a company-wide diversity and inclusion program than the founders, and when rubber met road (and the severance packages came out) they were willing to quit over it. Then, 8 or 9 months later, DHH publicly took both sides on a divisive issue, and everyone who was barely involved in the conversation (myself included) thought "hey, this must be the driver for $currentDrama." When really, it seems to have been DHH driving the drama all along. I mean, just look at the No RailsConf blog post. I mean really critically look at it. What small, narrow "opportunity for drama" was in this simple e-mail from the program committee, and yet here we are again, discussing it on a front-page HN post. DHH did that. And I'm guessing that RubyCentral program committee decided there was practically zero chance that DHH would not take his opportunity on stage to say something provocative or divisive, but I'm not on the program committee so really this is where my actual real effective insight level approaches the zero limit. I'm not taking sides, but I hate the perception that Ruby community is always full of drama. Now I'm hoping that geo-political and pandemic issues can subside for long enough to go to RailsConf, looking forward to a different keynote speaker, (and I'm sure there will be absolutely no drama of any kind!)
- MasterScrat 5y agoWhat happened?
- Zealotux 5y agoCompletely out of the loop here, I tried reading the "No RailsConf" blog post and now I'm even more confused, could someone please share context? At least Rails is consistent in being absolutely obscure to me, even outside the code.
- bob1029 5y agoI spent 30 minutes investigating this mystery as well, and the best I could arrive at is that this has something to do with politics but no one actually wants to expressly describe the exact positions held or why they are naughty.
- DetroitThrow 5y agoIt's more than one reason, and it's not just political views of the person who really wants to do the keynote. Though the replies to this thread help explain the position many who are leaving are in right now: https://twitter.com/kaspth/status/1499431981830086657 https://twitter.com/kaspth/status/1499431981830086657
- malfist 5y agoI appreciate you trying to be helpful, but I can't make anything out of that twitter link. The only thing I can gather is that maybe DHH tweeted about this developer? Or that DHH worked with this developer but didn't give him the full context of what they were working on together?
- DetroitThrow 5y agoContributors are being publicly brought up in drama posts wherein one of the other main contributors seems to be happy to implode the community in order to continue as a BDFL figure, despite that the community is at near consensus that he doesn't deserve to keep that position as someone who keeps becoming increasingly divisive and whose contributions have grown more minor every year. https://twitter.com/Carnage4Life/status/1499714921726046213 https://twitter.com/Carnage4Life/status/1499714921726046213 My original suggestion was to look through the reply chains as well, other contributors and users are more concrete. https://twitter.com/krainboltgreene/status/1499464349324234795 https://twitter.com/krainboltgreene/status/14994643493242347... https://twitter.com/ZiggyTheHamster/status/1499538111281258498 https://twitter.com/ZiggyTheHamster/status/14995381112812584...
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoI don’t know what’s going on and, at this point, I don’t really want to. In the past I mostly used Rails for quick proof of concept apps and also for teaching younger kids about web development at one point. Rails itself has been fine, but there’s something about the community and atmosphere around it that is always steeped in unnecessary drama. This was especially problematic when I was introducing younger people to web dev and their first exposure was full of Twitter drama and the DHH controversy of the month. By now, I’m just so tired of it that I want nothing to do with Rails. It’s unfortunate. I have no doubt that these individuals who resigned did great things and will be extremely valuable wherever they end up. I also don’t doubt that they had valid reasons to resign. I hope they find a better place to operate.
- forgingahead 5y agoWhat? I've used Rails professionally for over a decade and you'd be hard-pressed to find a better framework for web dev that maximises productivity to get to a working product you can earn money from. You don't need to be involved with the Twitter aspect at all to benefit from the great aspects of Ruby and Rails.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoI firmly believed that as well, right up until I learned that the broader web dev world wasn’t as difficult, slow, or unproductive as the Rails world had tried to convince me it was. I haven’t done web dev for a very long time but I still don’t have any issues dropping into modern non-Rails frameworks and being productive. > You don't need to be involved with the Twitter aspect at all. It’s possible, yes, but the drama has become so pervasive that it’s going to come across your feeds and daily conversations even if you don’t want to see it. It raises questions about the future of the project when it’s so bad that multiple core developers are resigning over it. But most importantly: This level of drama doesn’t exist in most other projects. Yes, there is always some drama and conflict, but something about Rails takes it to the next level.
- andrewzah 5y ago
- b0afc375b5 5y agoCan someone provide more context please. All I see are pull requests as resignations with little additional description. I don't see how we can have a meaningful discussion around that.
- DetroitThrow 5y agoPerhaps @dang should change the link to this thread: https://twitter.com/kaspth/status/1499431981830086657 https://twitter.com/kaspth/status/1499431981830086657
- gedy 5y agoAll these threads seem to talk obliquely about other posts, context, etc and it's not clear to outsiders "what happened".
- andrewzah 5y agoThankfully it appears to not be on the frontpage anymore. This feels like average twitter drama and not something that belongs on HN. Without concrete points there's nothing to really discuss other than speculate on what caused this particular drama.
- palerdot 5y agoThis thread has better context - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30600746 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30600746
- softwaredoug 5y agoI hate the tendency of social networks to amplify controversy without much context. No doubt this post will attract supposition about what happened and belly aching about Rails. But it’s just an annoying hack of human psyche that we want to rubber neck whatever train wreck is ongoing, yet we probably have deep, complicated issues in our own lives that need attention, and we can’t even debug those. Somehow we think we can voyeuristically understand and judge this situation from afar.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Lukas_Skywalker 5y agoI'll try to summarize what I know about the reasons and what brought people to resign from the Rails project, for those missing the context. Please note that I might be partially wrong, but I'll try to summarize as neutrally as I can: - DHH, the cofounder of Basecamp and creator of Rails serves as the de facto benevolent dictator of Rails. - April 2021: Basecamp announces that discussions around politics and society are no longer allowed at the company. The official statement was that employees should not feel pressured to take on side or the other, and that discussions would derail into flamewars. Employees instead suspected that the announcement was made because some employees found a list of "funny customer names", that had been circulating since 2009, offensive. It apparently contained mostly Asian and African names, and led to discussions about inclusion and diversity. About a third of the employees of Basecamp quit the company. [1] - April 2021 to March 2022: The story of Basecamp leads to many many discussions on Twitter and in blogs. DHH turns off the comments on his Twitter. People start doubting the fitness of DHH to lead the Rails project. There are flame wars from both sides. People start to turn their back on Rails. After multiple tweets, people start accusing DHH of being a cryptobro and QAnon sympathizer. - March 2022: DHH published a blog post containing an email from the RailsConf organizers, where they tell him that they want to fill the keynote spot at Railsconf with other speakers, because he had "mostly been offline for the past year". DHH had been very active in reality, publishing code to Rails consistently. He lists his contributions, along with the other contributors of those features (among them: Kasper Timm Hansen, author of the PR linked in this post). DHH suspects that he was uninvited for political reasons and his stance on diversity. [2] Kasper Timm Hansen tweeted, back in August 2021, that DHH was credited for work Kasper did [3]. That last blog post of DHH seems to have broken the camels back. [1] https://www.platformer.news/p/-what-really-happened-at-basecamp?s=r https://www.platformer.news/p/-what-really-happened-at-basec... [2] https://world.hey.com/dhh/no-railsconf-faa7935e https://world.hey.com/dhh/no-railsconf-faa7935e [3] https://twitter.com/kaspth/status/1431699450594988036 https://twitter.com/kaspth/status/1431699450594988036
- DetroitThrow 5y ago>DHH suspects that he was uninvited for political reasons and his stance on diversity. To be clear, he was never uninvited. He has decided not to go because of a request for a joint keynote. https://mobile.twitter.com/Carnage4Life/status/1499714921726046213 https://mobile.twitter.com/Carnage4Life/status/1499714921726... The blog post DHH made also listed mostly work that he wasn't the primary contributor to (one of his contributions was primarily done by someone who left the community because of him!), and that didn't go over well. As he escalates the drama he is largely seen as creating, people who have no interest in drama are leaving.
- Mikeb85 5y agoDoes no one remember DHH's first Rails keynote? https://images.app.goo.gl/JvyvwdnNi936uhvk8 https://images.app.goo.gl/JvyvwdnNi936uhvk8 He's always been like this, if anything has mellowed out. Dunno why people have a problem with it now. As for his politics, he's still left wing, just in a pragmatic euro way, versus the current zeitgeist in North America... Anyhow, just more dev drama, just like how people somehow found fault with Matz over the idea that people should be kind and respect each other (!?).
- softwarebeware 5y agoI would rather see a post about the new thing that someone leaving a particular coding community is choosing instead. That would be constructive and positive. What's better? That's what we need to hear.
- shantnutiwari 5y agoLooking at the link and thru the comments here-- seems to be a information-less post that is doing nothing but encouraging rumours (just see the comments here on HN) As such, I dont know how/why this is on the front page.
- rognjen 5y agoInterestingly he still has core @rails in his profile.