5 ms·
I wish the Windows software landscape was as interesting as the Mac. Windows gets all the best games, but if you aren’t interested in games, there isn’t a whole
by criddell 5y ago
I wish the Windows software landscape was as interesting as the Mac. Windows gets all the best games, but if you aren’t interested in games, there isn’t a whole lot of anything new or interesting. The web, although newer, is just as dull these days. iOS and Android aren’t doing much better.
Maybe it’s a sign that personal computing is now about as interesting as other appliances. Things are mature.
The author has posted a follow-up here: http://morrick.me/archives/9523 http://morrick.me/archives/9523
- brimble 5y ago> The web, although newer, is just as dull these days. I think it's that we stopped building, promoting, and improving new public protocols. And by "we" I mean "tech giants". There should be an open, widely-used social layer atop the Web, supported by everything under the sun. Why isn't there? Facebook and Google and Twitter have infinity money (thanks to advertising and/or VC) to throw at free products that lock in users, instead. Why's chat more silo'd now than ever? Similar reason, deep pockets with large marketing & advertising budgets pushing products that deliberately don't interoperate well. Et cetera. We couldn't invent email today. I'm not even sure we could invent the Web, anymore. For values of "invent" that include getting enough support for something to really be a standard that's widely used, not just a few white papers and something a few enthusiasts use, doomed to obscurity. This state of things is not because we ran out of things that would make excellent, useful protocols.
- rektide 5y agoAgreed basically. The G+ era murdered the engineering driven vision of the future & replaced it with more gloss-coated shit-consumerism. Things werent going great with Buzz, Salmon, OpenSocial. But they were teething, finding themselves, evolving. That all got killed by one vain executive, who murdered an explorable interconnected future for a cheapass Facebook knock-off. It's sad af it takes a massive name to drive big change, to get people hyped. There's plenty of interesting-ish projects about that could, that deserve uptake, usage, advancement. Maybe BlueSky will have technics sufficiently capable to match & drive a new interconnected angle. Im so tired of the ongoing re-silo-ization of all computing.
- wolpoli 5y agoAlso, independent (and interconnected) blogs simply have no place in their future where valuable/insightful content would be on Google+. Thus, to choke off the audience for blogs, Google Reader had to die.
- ohCh6zos 5y agoThis is a sad summary of the state of the web. Do you think if there was more focus on protocols it'd fix it, or is there no way back to a better web?
- wolpoli 5y agoThe nature open protocol makes it easy for companies to join. They could invest and insert itself somewhere in the ecosystem to add value, and once they dominate, they could evolve and close it up. Web sites with fantastic content are still out there. We just can't find them because Google search doesn't list them anymore and web sites don't link to each other.
- astrange 5y agoI have been told that Reader had to die for good privacy reasons that can't be shared. But what I don't understand is, why are people so upset about it? It's not the world's only RSS client.
- wolpoli 5y agoYes, it wasn't the world's only RSS client, but the existence of it, along with Google's backing, had somewhat stifled innovations. So there weren't that many options to choose from at the point. There were a few reasons I could think of why people were upset: Reader started in the era of when Google was generous. It gave away 1GB of email storage and free Email service for your own domain. It felt like a betrayal to end the service like this. There was the same reaction when Google announced the end of Gsuite legacy free edition. Finally, Google essentially declared to the entire world that RSS was dead. Although Google claimed that usage of Reader had fallen, the users who continued to use it do get values from it and thus they very much disagree with that assessment. It wasn't like Google was a small business that had fallen on hard time.
- KarlKemp 5y agoSlack didn’t take over its market with advertisement & marketing (although that’s certainly helpful). It was just better than IRC, which is the open protocol people often compare it to. And if you feel the impulse to list the ways that IRC is superior to slack, you are likely to just illustrate the mismatch between features people love to talk about or implement and features that drive adoption and retention. The OSS community is somewhere between incompetence and active hostility when it comes to good UIs, for example. (edit: as an example, see the sister comment and its complaint about „more gloss-coated shit-consumerism“) Chat happens to be the worst possible example for this idea that bad technology is winning against OSS or open protocols by throwing money into advertisement and fooling users that are just too stupid to understand. Besides slack, Signal and Telegram, two entities completely unknown by consumers and with budgets that round to zero took over that highly competitive market.
- brimble 5y agoOf course, Slack had a great client. It could have been a great client for an open protocol. Maybe an existing one. Maybe a new one that they could steer entirely. But that would fail to capture the user sufficiently. > The OSS community is somewhere between incompetence and active hostility when it comes to good UIs, for example. Mostly true! But commercial clients for open protocols are A Thing, for the tiny handful of user-facing protocols that haven't been sent toward a slow, obscure death. I'm writing this from a (largely) closed-source Web browser. I also have a closed-source email client open.
- astrange 5y agoI think IRC had decades to come up with a better protocol and never did. Just don't have netsplits, show the user the channel history when they join, and have encryption. I'll excuse the auth systems being driven by bots and so not built into clients.
- modo_mario 5y agoThere's Matrix and IRCv3 tho i haven't looked into the later much
- eternityforest 5y agoI wish there was some kind of Open Protocol Alliance or something. I would love to actually work on this stuff. Unfortunately, of the dozens trying, ALL are contaminated with performance hindering Web3 features. Nobody just wants to make an open social protocol. They want it to have a coin built right into it, mandatory anonymity routing, immutable scuttlebutt logs, DHT-clogging random access to individuals 256kb blocks of any file, etc. And mobile apps don't even get.discussed till the project is half dead already. I think Tox has the most potential of anything out there now and could possibly be usable if they can get the mobile bandwidth down. Matrix also has potential. Yggdrasil is a great component but not useful without applications to run on it.
- Sander_Marechal 5y ago> I wish there was some kind of Open Protocol Alliance or something. I would love to actually work on this stuff. IETF?
- rektide 5y agoThe whole Linux-on-the-desktop objective seemed like chasing where the puck was, that was a decade ago. Having connected, anywhere-we-go any-device-we-have cross-user-capable software is the new baseline. It's not just open source. Personal software in general is failing. Failing to become interpersonal. But if we simply glue in centralized services (how we typically connect), we begin walking down a vulgar path of anti-personalization/de-personalization. New ways must emerge to keep personal software relevant (imho).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]