3 ms·
For 1, 2, and maybe 3; often people talking about 83(b) will have the ability to early exercise; that is to exercise the options before they vest. If you leave
by toast0 5y ago
For 1, 2, and maybe 3; often people talking about 83(b) will have the ability to early exercise; that is to exercise the options before they vest. If you leave before vesting, the company has the opportunity (but not the obligation, unless mentioned in the contract) to buy the shares back for the exercise price.
My questions would be are these options qualified ISOs for US stock purposes or are they NQSO or something else.
If they're ISOs and you can't early exercise, then when the first vest date comes, you need to know the FMV at that day to consider your options. You wouldn't need to file an 83b on vested options that you exercise though; there's no election to be made, your holding date is the date of exercise and you'd have income for alternative minimum tax on the discount at that point; the type and amount of income for regular income tax would be determined when you dispose of the shares. Consider the holding requirements for a qualifying disposition of ISO shares; if you don't think you'll meet those, it makes more sense to wait and not exercise until you're ready to sell (or the options are likely to expire, if they're in the money)
On 4, I don't know anything about Canadian taxes; it will make a difference if you work within the US or within Canada, but if you work in the US as a US person, I wouldn't expect any Canadian taxes to be due; but I wouldn't trust me, I'm just a random internet person.
- throwaway489322 5y agoThank you for your thoughts! I believe these are actually NQSOs (not ISOs), per section 1.05(a) here.[1] Does that change your advice at all? I'm not entirely sure whether I can early exercise. There's nothing about it in my contract though, so unless this is a default of some sort, I assume it's not possible for me. I can ask my employer though. [1] https://serbinski.com/stock-option-compensation-us-and-canada-comparison#1.05a https://serbinski.com/stock-option-compensation-us-and-canad...
- toast0 5y agoNSQOs are simpler, there's no AMT, but there's also no chance to get the discount as a capital gain instead of ordinary income. It's worth checking with your employer if early exercise is possible, but it's not the default and it should be mentioned in the options documentation. With NSQOs, in a way, there's less pressure to exercise earlier, because there's no holding period for preferential treatment (isos get better tax treatment if held for at least 2 years after the grant and at least 1 year after exercise); so with ISOs, you might exercise and then want to hold and have risk there... With NQSO, if the stock is liquid, there's no reason to not sell when you exercise. If the stock isn't liquid, maybe you want to exercise and limit your ordinary income gains and hope for long term capital gains. Maybe you don't... it's always a bit tricky.