4 ms·
Yes, IQ Matters
- t-3 5y agoThe article opens by talking about standardized testing, so here's an anecdote: I tied for the highest ACT score in my grade when my school took it, and I'm the opposite of success at anything. My grades would have been a far better metric, as they place me in the 40th percentile rather than the 99th (probably still a fair bit above reality, though). Factors like work ethic, drive to succeed, ability to follow direction, and good social skills are better captured through other means, and for most positions, they matter more than raw intelligence.
- tus666 5y ago> In fact, disregarding IQ—by admitting students to colleges or hiring people for jobs in which they are very likely to fail—is harmful both to individuals and to society. Are SAT scores routinely used in the hiring process for employment? I have never head of this.
- olliej 5y agoRight? Depending on field you could argue that by gating entry to university they were controlling access to some careers, but I'm not sure there's any material that exists that could adequately express such a stretch.
- olliej 5y agoEquating SATs with IQ is a bad (and incorrect) conflation. An SAT is (ostensibly) a measure of learned skills. I'm originally from NZ so have never done SAT, and I was in the last year that had what were called "University Bursary" exams which serve the same university entrance purpose. The exams seem much more complicated than SATs but then NZ has far fewer people so manual grading is achievable. My experience with standardized testing is through my partner, and what I learned while they were preparing for MCAT and the general postgrad one (acronym???) was: Achieving a high grade in the US standardized testing system seems to benefit hugely from tutoring/training on the actual tasks of taking the tests, including a wide variety of "tricks" that serve no practical purpose outside of the testing system. There is immense time pressure, far more than I believe that there should be (and again private training helps with that as well). Because that training costs money it has the functional effect of creating a system the has a bias in favor of people who can afford it. Given having money already provides considerable benefits do educational proficiency (through many factors), this just reinforces that. So I can understand why there is concern about bias, but I think dropping SAT, etc entirely is far too extreme a response. An IQ test is (again, ostensibly) a test of innate intelligence. IQ testing as a concept has been fairly comprehensively debunked numerous times at this point due to a variety of effects that impact test results (availability of reading material while young, nutrition, cultural background, and so...). Starting from an assumption that IQ is real, then a test that accurately measures IQ should not vary in such a way, if it does, then the test isn't measuring IQ. That's where the IQ concept gets into trouble: no one has been able to develop a test that isn't influenced by factors that are not "innate".
- clove 5y agoYou have bought into a logical fallacy - a common one pushed by the many people who have agendas for whatever reason to dismiss IQ (and thereby all psychometrics, in practice). If you are really interested in understanding IQ, which is not a question of being "real" but a metric created to measure the g-factor, you can educate yourself via unbiased sources in the field of Intelligence. Just to contribute a bit to your education, though, let me point out that the examples of "debunking" you have listed confuse within-individual differences over time with between-individual differences, the latter having been shown to be extremely stable.
- vonwoodson 5y agoThe SAT is not an IQ test.
- _8j50 5y agoEven if SAT was an IQ test and IQ was not a faulty measurement of something humans don't fully understand, it would still only show you the upper limit of someones potential, like the maximum speed of a car -- useful when driven on a racetrack not the freeway or city street -- in reality motivation to apply your intelligence in a useful way and having a personality and perseverance to acheive success, much like speed limits, other cars and road conditions are the real barrier. It's not how fast you drive, it's how efficiently you drive and work with/around others. I am glad they brought up the SAT because do they really think a student that gets a perfect score on it could have done so without years of studying (barring actual genius)? Intelligence capcity is real, much like physical strength capacity is real but just like how a female marine can outperform an average office worker in combat a well studied low-intelligence student can acheive more than an underacheiving genius. And even then, I don't get why people don't get the difference between intelligence and wisdom, without the latter you're only good for party tricks and showing off not accomplishing anything. IQ matters in that it is a bell curve distribution where the peak and tail are relevant but for everyone in between it has little relevance imo.
- etempleton 5y agoThere is some cherry-picked studies and data in this without providing any counter studies, but moving beyond that, there are a few problems with the argument the author is making: 1. IQ Tests and the SAT are not the same thing. Not even close. Go try to take the sample SAT test. If it has been awhile since you were exposed to such a test you will probably need some time to get used to the line of questioning. Questions are posed and framed in a specific way and everything is geared towards testing what you have learned in school. An "IQ test" is meant to require zero past exposure to tests (though it does help if you have taken a test like that in the past). 2. "IQ tests" do not measure what the author seems to think. Modern tests are meant as a diagnosis tool and are designed accordingly. A high score is impressive, and does demonstrate cognitive ability in certain areas, but it is by no means a great predictor of really anything once you are in the above average category. 3. SAT scores do correlate to performance in college, but it is a weak correlation. SAT scores do have a strong correlation with family household income. IQ scores get higher in high wealth countries as well. 4. Colleges have a lot more data points now on prospective college students making the SAT less relevant. When college admission say they take a "holistic approach" they are telling you that they have dozens of data points that inform the decision. 5. I haven't heard of too many colleges refusing SAT / ACT scores. They say test optional. If you want to submit it go for it. If you have a 1600 on the SAT it is still going to look really good and help your chances to get into any college.
- faeriechangling 5y agoThe core problem this entire argument runs into from a validity perspective is that you cannot prove that discrimination in favor off good test takers is causing EVERY positive outcome. Promotions, employee reviews, even legitimate measures of job performance could be an outcome of discrimination in favor of test takers. You would need to setup a parallel society where those who were good at tests in school were lambasted by their parents, held back from higher education, had performance reviews and interview panels done by bad test takers, etc. etc. It’s hard to actually disprove that this argument is justifying discrimination on the grounds of the effects of the same kind of discrimination. The more I’ve dwelled on this point the more I’ve felt the modern notion of discriminating on the grounds of identity group membership can’t be proven to be any more arbitrary than discriminating based on test performance. It's a subjective preference probably driven by direct or indirect self-interest.