4 ms·
BEV solve 99% of the problem and hydrogen is not worh investing in for the rest. The battle is already over, and just like with cars 10 ago its totally clear bu
by panick21_ 5y ago
BEV solve 99% of the problem and hydrogen is not worh investing in for the rest. The battle is already over, and just like with cars 10 ago its totally clear but it will be another 5 years until the hydrogen defenders admit it.
And claiming that hydrogen doesnt need much development is an insane claim given the money put in and the total lack of success.
- dsl 5y agoWe will always need a portable liquid fuel to meet needs like emergency vehicles, construction equipment, and emergency generators. Not everything is a consumer car and truck. Being a battery maximalist prolongs the time everything else runs on dead dinosaurs.
- jeffbee 5y agoWhy can't that stuff just remain diesel? We can synthesize it, no problem.
- panick21_ 5y agoAs I said, 1%. And in those cases using hydrogen makes little sense. Emergency vehicles of most types don't need that however. And in many of the cases you mention swappable battery packs are an option as well. But we have to realize that compared to all consumer and fleet cars, 99% of all trucking is the vast majority of fuel use in transportation. Extreme long range trucking is the exception. In most cases you would make the hydrogen into methanol and you can keep mostly the same engines.
- fmajid 5y agoMost hydrogen is produced from methane and is actually worse than gasoline for global warming because methane leaks and is a far more potent greenhouse gas than CO2. It makes indeed more sense to just use renewable gasoline, e.g. using the Fischer-Tropsch process like VW's eFuel.
- panick21_ 5y agoI know, but its easier to go from renewable hydrogen to methanol then eFuel.
- dragonsky67 5y agoTell that to the person with the Tesla who is trying to drive from one side of Australia to the other and is completely dependent upon the generator powered charging station in the middle of the Nullarbor Plane to complete the trip. Yep, BEV are great for commuting, but very difficult to use if you need to travel long distances in remote areas or tow a caravan or trailer.
- panick21_ 5y agoYeah like the huge % of the population who crosses Australia or the Sahara. Please be series in these discussions. Long distances are no problem unless you you are traversing unpopulated area free of infrastructure, and that is likely 0.000001% of all driving.