3 ms·
Back then people understood that it was outside the power of federal government to ban a drug and that it would require a constitutional amendment. Today, marij
by guelo 15y ago
Back then people understood that it was outside the power of federal government to ban a drug and that it would require a constitutional amendment. Today, marijuana and a whole host of drugs are banned at the whim of bureaucrats.
- bd_at_rivenhill 15y agoThe power of the Federal government was much lower before the Supreme Court allowed the abuse of the commerce clause to get so far out of hand.
- jacobolus 15y agoThe power of the Federal Government was a lot lower before the huge “trusts” of the late-19th century grew in size and strength until they could wantonly trample the rights of consumers, their own workers, and citizens generally without any similarly powerful opposing force. It grew still further after the outsized influence of corporate and financial interests led to a calamitous worldwide economic collapse (the great depression) and citizens demanded that their government do something to prevent those imbalances and instabilities. The US Supreme Court changed its understanding of the commerce clause and other aspects of government regulation of commerce in the 40s–60s in rejection of the previous generation’s court whose every decision favored the rich and powerful and blocked corrective legislative action at every level (for instance in the famous Lochner v. New York case after which we now refer to that whole court “era”). The citizenry explicitly (and overwhelmingly) elected legislators and executives who promised to reign in the power of corporations, and they replaced the previous justices... that’s how democracy is designed to work. Government regulation is a response to real serious abuses of the type almost everyone is horrified by when they hear the specific examples that prompted the regulation – false advertising, fraud, miserable working conditions and the general treatment of workers as replaceable objects (and preserving the same by viciously breaking up any attempts by workers to organize), the sale of deadly diseased food, dumping of toxins into drinking water supplies, the use of market power to block competitors from markets or disrupt their operation, discrimination based on race, gender, and religion, etc. etc. To just sum up this history as “the Supreme Court allowed the abuse of the commerce clause to get so far out of hand” is deeply disingenuous.
- jbooth 15y agoIt's at the whim of demagogues. The bureaucrats are mostly just annoyed that they have to take pee tests. Politicians are the ones waging the war on drugs.
- muhfuhkuh 15y agoUnfortunately, you still have to follow the money to find that, behind those same politicians, are corporations of nearly every stripe (and even illegal dealers) who are behind the continued prohibition of Marijuana. The prison lobby, law enforcement unions, and the coalition of growers in Mendocino and surrounding parts provided millions to stop Prop. 19 from passing in CA. And, the liquor, prison, and law enforcement lobbies continue to contribute to politicians who keep Marijuana a schedule 1 drug (and FYI for those that don't know or aren't American, Meth and Cocaine are both schedule II drugs, because they carry "medical value").
- philwelch 15y agoI think it's simplistic to blame the drug war on self-interested lobbies. For one, shouldn't the entire food and music industries be 100% behind legalization? There is definitely a degree to which marijuana use is a social taboo associated with hippies, poor people, and unpopular ethnic groups. Whereas alcohol has always been considered more "classy", aside from a short-lived temperance movement.