4 ms·
Trying to conquer it, but failing badly. This is a war of attrition where Ukraine gets enormous supplies from rich Western countries for free, but Russia canno
by inglor_cz 5y ago
Trying to conquer it, but failing badly.
This is a war of attrition where Ukraine gets enormous supplies from rich Western countries for free, but Russia cannot replenish any equipment loss. No one will sell them new Soviet-style helicopters and fighter jets that their pilots are qualified to fly.
Every piece of heavy equipment that is destroyed with Javelins, NLAWs and Stingers is an irreplaceable loss for the attacking army. Unlike defense, you cannot sustain your attack if your offensive equipment gets blown into pieces or runs out of fuel.
This will end in a collapse of massive proportions.
- fallingknife 5y agoCould be China to the rescue here, and Ukraine turns into the first proxy war between the US and China.
- thehappypm 5y agoIf China aids Russia they may see the same sanctions Russia does, the CCP above all else wants the Chinese GDP to continue to grow. Maybe in 50 years if China becomes a wealthy nation they might start throwing stones but for now, they benefit from playing both sides and letting Russia get weakened and desperate.
- fallingknife 5y agoWe can't sanction China like that. We need too much of what they produce. The only thing that Russia produces that the West needs is oil and gas, which has not been sanctioned.
- kavalg 5y agoAlso wheat, some rare metals and maybe even electricity soon if they are able to retain control over Ukraine NPPs (well only if EU considers them green enough).
- thehappypm 5y agoWe can certainly hurt them with sanctions.
- monocasa 5y agoA) The Russians absolutely have second sources for era Soviet equipment. B) Their factories were the original source for a lot of this equipment. Russia is still the second largest arms dealer in the world, only behind the US. I'm sure Putin has no problem delaying export shipments if it comes to that in a "pray I don't alter the deal further" kind of way. And buying back some of his past customers' arms for a deal on future sales is probably something that could be made to happen.
- qqqwerty 5y agoI read that Russias manufacturing capabilities were already suffering before the war (possibly due to the covid supply chain issues, not sure), and that they are likely a few months out from being able to get manufacturing capacity to a level that could replace current losses (and may not even be able to due to sanctions). Also, there are videos going around on twitter of Russian trains loaded with civilian cars and trucks supposedly headed to the front line. Assuming those videos are true, that means Russia is running out of military equipment. It is certainly possible that they are doing this for strategic reasons (maybe civilian vehicles use less gas, so easier to support logistically, etc..). But either way, this doesn't look good for them.
- monocasa 5y agoThey don't need to immediately replace them. Russia has lost about a hundred tanks. They have nearly 13,000. They've lost about a dozen Su-27s, they have about 500. And I'm a little more afraid for Ukraine having seen those civilian cars. It feels like Russia is going to start playing very dirty during the upcoming siege of Kiev. It sort of evens the playing field if the defenders also have to watch their backs everytime an unmarked civilian car drives by. It's a dirty move right out of Russia's playbook.
- inglor_cz 5y agoHow many of those 13 000 tanks and 500 Su-27s are in deployable condition? The former Soviet Union was excellent in production of impressive statistics, but the reality on the ground didn't quite match. And the Soviet way of thinking is very much alive in Putin's power circles. It is cheaper to produce impressive numbers than to actually take good care of equipment, and some people will swallow those numbers without thinking twice. Westerners from well-run countries tend to trust government figures. This may work in Sweden or even in the USA, but in case of Russia, consider every published statistics as suspect.
- mardifoufs 5y agoThis is just false; the only way you could say russia is failing badly to conquer ukraine is if you only read the ukrainian government's PR releases. It's been like a week and a half; even the Americans took a longer time to go through the extremely weakened state of Iraq in 2003. I get supporting ukraine but there's no need to fall for delusional war propaganda, just look at the map and tallies of confirmed casualties (for example we only have proof of 2 actual russian air losses, a far cry from the 35-40 claimed by the ukrainian side). It's totally counterproductive and does not help the ukrainian side to be so wildly optimistic when the situation on the ground isn't.
- inglor_cz 5y ago"for example we only have proof of 2 actual russian air losses, a far cry from the 35-40 claimed by the ukrainian side" We have way more than two Russian air losses proven. This OSINT page maps them fairly well. https://www.oryxspioenkop.com/2022/02/attack-on-europe-documenting-equipment.html https://www.oryxspioenkop.com/2022/02/attack-on-europe-docum...
- mardifoufs 5y agoInteresting, oryx has usually been very reliable in the past but there are a few glaring discrepancies in his list. I can see at least a few pictures of double counted losses, and there seems to be comments on that in the article too. For example they show the gear of a downed pilot as proof of a shutdown aircraft (which is true!) But also show the wreckage of the plane he ejected from as another air loss... The AN transport plane loss is also contested from what ive seen elsewhere. They also don't seem to be listing most confirmed ukrainian losses but that does not necessarily discredit their russian list But yes it seems my own figure was wrong and outdated by a few days, yet even in the best case scenario we are a very very far cry from the ukrainian figures. It's really not even close, considering they claimed 25 aircraft kills a week ago and most of those pictures are from the past 3 days