28 ms·
> $546 million funding round This is where nuclear just loses me. The first number I pulled up on Google says that this is what you would pay to build, site a
by ajross 5y ago
> $546 million funding round
This is where nuclear just loses me. The first number I pulled up on Google says that this is what you would pay to build, site and install 400 MW of wind capacity. The reactor when eventually built (at much greater cost, of course) is only going to produce 470 MW. You'd need to get a second reactor installed just to break even for one round of R & D funding. It just doesn't work.
I'm all for nuclear power in principle. I'm broadly opposed to tearing down existing capacity. But I'm absolutely horrified at the degree to which people want to throw money at this boondoggle. There is low hanging fruit all over the renewables market. Can we please pick it first before chasing radioactive unicorns?
- 8ytecoder 5y agoAs it stands wind and solar can’t power 100% due to them being unavailable at times. Not to mention the insane amount of land and storage capacity required. Nuclear is ideally suited for the last 30% or so that’ll continue to be some form of steady state power generation required to augment renewables.
- pfdietz 5y agoNuclear is horrible for the last 30%, since that last part is highly intermittent (if it weren't renewables could easily address some of it.) Nuclear either addresses just about all the demand, or none. There's not much middle ground.
- willcipriano 5y ago> 400 MW of wind capacity Isn't that 400 MW when it's windy vs 470 MW all day long?
- Buttons840 5y agoIs that a peak or sustained 400 MW of wind power?
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago> You'd need to get a second reactor installed just to break even for one round of R & D funding. It just doesn't work. They aren’t planning to make one or two, they want to make dozens of them.
- kmlx 5y ago> 400 MW of wind capacity these 400MW are not the same as the ones provided by nuclear. that’s the difference.
- londons_explore 5y agoWind costs a lot more when you add in the storage tech required to power your citizens homes on non-windy days.
- fuddle 5y agoSurely the costs can be reduced once the mini nuclear reactor technology is used more widely?
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoAll I read about are nuclear reactors getting more and more expensive to where they aren’t even feasible when they are completed. Why would these escape that? > Among the surprising findings in the study, which covered 50 years of U.S. nuclear power plant construction data, was that, contrary to expectations, building subsequent plants based on an existing design actually costs more, not less, than building the initial plant.
- _dain_ 5y ago>Why would these escape that? Because they're smaller and faster to build.
- ch4s3 5y agoThe regulations changed a loonoverleg that time period as the tech evolved, so old designed needed expensive modifications and recertifications to meet new standards which would often get released during construction. Being able to build modular reactors in a factory would change that.
- floren 5y agoHow much area do you have to cover with turbines to get 400MW? This may be a figure of interest to, say, a small island nation.
- dane-pgp 5y ago> a small island nation. That is to say, an island with extensive scope for offshore wind. The real question for a well-populated island nation is how much area do you have to write off if a nuclear reactor suffers from a major accident (or attack)? For reference, the Fukushima exclusion zone was 311.5 square miles, and Chernobyl's was 1,600 square miles. https://www.britannica.com/story/nuclear-exclusion-zones https://www.britannica.com/story/nuclear-exclusion-zones
- dash2 5y agoI kind of wonder if Putin's rationale for starting a fire at that Ukraine plant was "let's show them nuclear power can be risky... if some bad guy starts firing at it".
- floren 5y agoMy first thought when I heard about Russia shelling the nuke plants: "ah, that's a good way to make sure Europe will keep buying Russia gas..."
- arrosenberg 5y ago> The real question for a well-populated island nation is how much area do you have to write off if a nuclear reactor suffers from a major accident (or attack)? I always roll my eyes at this line of reasoning. First, the number of nuclear incidents of that scope can be counted on one hand, and at least the Fukushima one was a result of poor planning. Second, that analysis never accounts for the externalities incurred by continuing to use fossil fuel Peaker plants, the externalities of etching solar panels and creating batteries, etc. Yes, nuclear power accidents can be very bad if we do a bad job of engineering the plan, and our other forms of energy production have major externalities even if we do a very good job.
- VBprogrammer 5y agoAh now, let's not get ahead of ourselves. 400MW of wind power is actually about 120MW of actual power when you take into account the capacity factor typically 30% in the UK. While it's true that nuclear plants also have a capacity factor due to down time and refueling it's >90%. You also can't just arbitrarily increase the amount of wind generation and hope the grid copes. There need to be major structural changes to cope with the intermittency of power.
- ajross 5y agoSee... this is again the rathole that leads to boondoggle spending. I'm not saying "buy wind only" as all the commenters immediately interpreted. I'm pointing out that this (hypothetical!) reactor is, even now, even in the development stage, already as expensive (plus or minus an order of magnitude) as readily deployed solutions already available in the market. Be real. It's not going to catch up financially. It will never catch up financially. Nuclear will be what we start deploying only when we're working on the last 20% of capacity and trying to wind down the old fossil fuel generators (which will themselves be increasingly expensive as they become peaker plants). Nuclear will never appeal to market producers of energy. It's just too expensive. Which is why we need to throw public funds at it instead. And if we're going to throw public funds at the problem, let's start with the low hanging fruit. The UK should be putting that money somewhere else, not here.
- nicoburns 5y ago> Nuclear will be what we start deploying only when we're working on the last 20% of capacity and trying to wind down the old fossil fuel generators > Nuclear will never appeal to market producers of energy. It's just too expensive. It seems to me that these two sentences contradict. The first implies that Nuclear will be appealing for 20% of the energy market, which is still a huge market.
- ajross 5y agoIf it was appealing, private industry would be investing. What I'm saying is that the only time nuclear makes sense is when you're trying to back-fill the last 20% (or whatever) of capacity that can't easily be born by other renewable sources. That doesn't make that 20% magically profitable, it's a gap that needs to be filled (likely by public investment).
- TrispusAttucks 5y agoWind farm theoretical maximum is not equivalent to sustained continual power generation.
- krona 5y agoThese SMRs have a 60 year lifespan[1]. The lifespan of a wind turbine is optimistically 25 years for offshore (I don't know whether your stat refers to off/onshore wind.) [1] https://www.rolls-royce.com/innovation/net-zero/decarbonising-complex-critical-systems/small-nuclear-power-stations.aspx https://www.rolls-royce.com/innovation/net-zero/decarbonisin...
- jhgb 5y agoEven if the SMR itself were to have a 60 year lifespan, you'll find that the steam turbines attached to it are not really better than the wind turbines. Comparing an SMR with a complete wind turbine is like comparing apples and apple trees.
- pfdietz 5y agoMeaning: "our ROI figures assume we don't face any seriously improved competitors for six decades."
- simion314 5y agoWe don't have storage because batteries are super expensive and are not clean. The good part is that we can work on more then one problem at a time, like we can install solar panels on homes, install wind turbines on windy areas and we could also build safe and cheap nuclear power station to fill the rest.
- 7952 5y agoBritain has around 1.4GW of battery storage installed and around 20GW in planning. They are easy to install and mass producible.
- pfdietz 5y agoBatteries are rapidly falling in price, as are electrolysers. When nuclear plants are justified based on four or even six decades lifespans, it's a very dubious bet to think that storage won't be much cheaper long before that lifespan is over.
- simion314 5y agoSay I afford some solar panels, should I investigate/review batteries for home use? Or maybe I should wait a few years , maybe prices half and safety increases?
- ncmncm 5y agoBTW, solar panels may be bought by the pallet-load for 1/4 what (e.g.) Home Depot charges. Any roofer can install brackets for them, reliably, and electricians nowadays know how to wire up a system from commodity parts. So there is no need to pay 4x to a solar specialist. But, yes, battery prices are falling fast. Right now the best way to buy a battery is to buy a used Nissan Leaf and a box to connect it to your house.
- pfdietz 5y agoI personally would wait.