6 ms·
Sovereign states can always 'unilaterally' decide to do whatever they want. It all boils down to strength, really: the US can get away with much more than anyon
by mytailorisrich 5y ago
Sovereign states can always 'unilaterally' decide to do whatever they want. It all boils down to strength, really: the US can get away with much more than anyone else (Ukraine 2022 is not so different from Iraq 2003, and yet...) because they are much stronger than anyone else.
In this case, the main limitation is that the US and Russia don't want a direct war so will refrain from direct attacks. Even this guy is not suggesting the Navy should do it. But if Russia was much smaller (and without nukes) I think the US could actually be OK with sending the Navy to seize any Russian vessel they could find.
- hef19898 5y agoPrivateers, under a proper Letter of Marque, are considered to be legitimate mercenaries. No much difference if it is Privateer Babossa of Commodore Norrington who's doing the seizing at sea, as long as the former is operating a letter of marque. Both parties are, basically, part of the same Navy. The other option would be outright piracy. EDIT: Sure, sovereign states can unilaterally decide whatever they want. in case they are not North Korea they risk to break multiple treaties so. As Russia showed us, one miscalculation in such a sovereign decision bears the risk of turning said country into an isolated country, just like North Korea.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoCountries can withdraw from treaties first so as not to formally break them, or just indeed break them. The point is that the consequences depend on who you are. Russia is up against the US/West so consequences are severe and, again, we can contrast this against the consequences for the US of invading Iraq, which were none.
- pydry 5y agoThe real restriction is probably not really legitimacy but that that Russia would retaliate in kind.
- zozbot234 5y agoUkraine is not a state sponsor of terrorism like Hussein's Iraq was. I'd call this a very significant difference.
- romanfountain 5y agoFrom the Russian point of view Ukraine provides weapons to militant groups whose objective is to kill the separatists. This is not far from terrorism.
- jd115 5y agoNot far? It's about as far as it gets, really. Wouldn't you fully expect ANY nation to defend itself in this way?
- hef19898 5y agoI absolutely would! But hen I'm one of the few people that never really considered Afghan or Iraqi resistance against US and / or NATO forces to be "evil". Understanding, e.g., Putin's motivation doesn't mean defending him.
- romanfountain 5y agoOf course not, I'm not some authoritarian totalist. It was a small piece of land not critical to Ukraine as a whole. I don't think it was the right move for Ukraine to make.
- choko 5y agoWas it right for Putin to flood the disputed territories with Russian nationals then lay claim to said areas to "protect Russians"?
- romanfountain 5y agoThat would be weird if it happened but from what I understand what you're saying isn't accurate. A lot of people were leaving the area rather than entering.